féminisme matérialiste · 1970–present

Materialist feminism

유물론적 페미니즘

Materialist feminism (féminisme matérialiste) is a current that used the conceptual tools of Marxism to theorise patriarchy. It grew out of the French Women's Liberation Movement (MLF) in the 1970s and gathered around the journal Questions féministes (1977), whose director of publication was Simone de Beauvoir. Its main theorists were Christine Delphy, Colette Guillaumin, Nicole-Claude Mathieu and Monique Wittig. It rejects any biological or psychological explanation of women's oppression and treats "women" and "men" as antagonistic social classes. Delphy saw the "domestic mode of production", in which a husband appropriates his wife's unpaid work, as the economic basis of women's exploitation; Guillaumin called men's appropriation of women's whole bodies "sexage". Its conclusion, that the categories of sex must disappear with the classes, made it a main source of gender abolitionism.

In depth

Where did materialist feminism begin?

In May 1970 a group of women including Wittig published an article in L'Idiot international that already analysed women's oppression as a relation between antagonistic "sex classes". That autumn MLF activists won a special issue of the far-left journal Partisans, "Libération des femmes année 0", and applied Marx's method of analysing social relations to patriarchy. Delphy's "The Main Enemy" (L'ennemi principal), published there, is counted the starting point of the current. In 1971 Nicole-Claude Mathieu argued that men and women must be defined as social, not natural, categories and studied in relation to each other. Questions féministes was founded in 1977 and followed in 1981 by Nouvelles Questions féministes, both with Simone de Beauvoir as director of publication. Rosemary Hennessy, who introduced the current to English-language readers, explains that these French and British feminists preferred "materialist feminism" to "Marxist feminism": Marxism had to be altered to explain the sexual division of labour because of its class bias and its focus on production, while existing feminism had an essentialist concept of woman.

What did Delphy call "the main enemy"?

Delphy recalled that she began this analysis to answer a man in her mixed group who claimed that women were oppressed but, unlike the proletariat, not "exploited". She argued that society contains two modes of production: the industrial mode, in which capitalist exploitation takes place, and the domestic mode, in which familial and patriarchal exploitation takes place. Marriage is a labour contract that gives the husband the right to his wife's unpaid work, and this relation makes women an exploited class. Hence the main enemy of women as a class is not capital but patriarchy. From 1981 Delphy also argued that gender precedes sex: oppression first divides humanity into two hierarchical groups, and anatomical sex later acquires meaning as the marker by which that social division is recognised.

What did Guillaumin and Wittig add?

Colette Guillaumin held that men appropriate not only women's labour power but their whole bodies, and coined "sexage" on the model of servage (serfdom) and esclavage (slavery). Marriage is its private, legal form; the expectation that women everywhere will clean, raise children and serve is its collective form.

Monique Wittig carried the analysis into a critique of heterosexuality in "The Straight Mind" (1978) and the later "One Is Not Born a Woman". "Woman" and "man", she argued, are political and economic categories that exist only within heterosexuality as a political regime; as there are no slaves without masters, the class "women" will disappear once the class "men" disappears. Hence her claim that lesbians are not women:

Lesbian is the only concept I know of which is beyond the categories of sex (woman and man), because the designated subject (lesbian) is not a woman, either economically, or politically, or ideologically.

Judith Butler's reworking of Wittig's critique of heterosexuality made it influential in queer theory (see "Gender Performativity").

How does it differ from Marxist feminism, and how has it been criticised?

Materialist feminists took from Marx the idea that social relations shape consciousness and that the struggle of antagonistic classes drives history. But they held that Marxism recognises only the antagonism of proletarians and capitalists, and analysed the antagonism of women and men as a class relation of equal weight. This is where they parted from the current that reduces women's oppression to a result of capitalism. They also criticised the Marxist distinction between production and reproduction: a theory that reduces women's work to reproduction, they argued, ends up reaffirming patriarchal ideology (see "Social Reproduction Theory (SRT)" and "Dual-Systems Theory").

The current has had its critics. Michèle Barrett and Mary McIntosh argued that Delphy's definition of patriarchy is loose and that her focus on wives fails to connect with the oppression of women in general. Hazel Carby challenged the analysis of the family as universally oppressive to all women, noting that it did not fit Black women's experience. The tradition also divided over transgender questions. In 2020 Delphy co-signed an op-ed stating that "women are first of all female human beings" and excluding trans women from women-only spaces; several feminists, including long-time collaborators, said this contradicted her own materialist theses. In an interview with Libération Delphy said she did not share every term of the op-ed and added that sex remains a marker, not the cause, of women's subordination. In 2018 French activists launched the website Questions Transféministes to analyse trans questions with the tools of radical and materialist feminism (see "Gender abolition").

What is available in Korean?

Delphy's essays have appeared from Bomalam as Gabujangje-ui jeongchigyeongjehak ("The Political Economy of Patriarchy", 2022–23, translated by Lee Min-kyung and Kim Dabom), the first volume subtitled "The Main Enemy". Wittig's essays appeared as Monik Witig-ui Seuteureiteu Maindeu (Haengseong B, 2020, translated by Heo Yun).

Related people

Sources

  1. fr.wikipedia.org
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. libcom.org
  4. Wikipedia (EN)
  5. fr.wikipedia.org
  6. theanarchistlibrary.org
  7. Wikipedia (EN)
  8. aladin.co.kr