Их хэлмэгдүүлэлт · 1937.09–1939.04

Great Repression in Mongolia (1937–1939)

몽골 대숙청 (1937~1939)

The mass arrests and executions carried out in the Mongolian People's Republic from September 1937 to April 1939 by the Extraordinary Plenipotentiary Commission headed by Choibalsan and by advisers of the Soviet NKVD. An extension of the Soviet Great Purge, it executed Buddhist monks, former nobles, leaders of the revolutionary generation, military commanders, Buryats and Kazakhs on fabricated charges of Japanese espionage and counter-revolutionary conspiracy. The commission's own records show more than twenty thousand death sentences, and estimates of the victims range from 20,000 to 100,000. In Mongolia it is called the Ikh Khelmegdüülelt, the Great Repression.

In depth

Prelude

Political purges in Mongolia ran from the execution of Prime Minister Bodoo in 1922 and of Danzan in 1924 to the ouster of the right in 1928; Mongolian Wikipedia treats the "Great Repression" as a long process beginning in 1922 and peaking in 1937. In the fabricated Lkhümbe affair of 1933–1934 more than 1,500 people were implicated and 56 executed, Buryats above all. In 1934 Stalin demanded that Prime Minister Genden eliminate 100,000 lamas; Genden refused, was removed in March 1936 and shot in Moscow the following year. Choibalsan became minister of the new Ministry of Internal Affairs, 26 percent of whose staff were NKVD agents, and in May 1936, guided by the Soviet adviser Chopyak, had its rules changed so that senior politicians could be detained without consulting superiors.

Course

After Marshal Demid died in suspicious circumstances on a train to Moscow on 22 August 1937, Choibalsan took command of the army and in early September issued Order 366, declaring that many people "had fallen under the influence of Japanese spies and provocateurs". At about the same time Stalin stationed 30,000 Red Army troops in Mongolia and sent Deputy NKVD Commissar Frinovsky with Deputy Defence Commissar Smirnov. On lists Frinovsky had brought, 65 senior officials and intellectuals were arrested on the night of 10 September and, charged as Japanese spies in a "Genden–Demid plot", confessed under torture. On 2 October a troika of Choibalsan, Justice Minister Tserendorj and party secretary Luvsansharav was formed, and at the first show trial on 18–20 October 13 of 14 defendants were sentenced to death. By 22 April 1939 the commission had met 51 times, considered 25,824 cases, and sentenced 20,474 people to be shot and 5,103 to ten years (the English-language article on Luvsansharav gives 25,785 cases and 20,099 death sentences). Of 10,728 people arrested between August 1937 and January 1938, 7,814 were lamas, 1,555 Buryats and 408 Chinese; among Kazakhs, 3,270 were shot in 1937–1938. Twenty-five people from the top of the party and government, 187 from the military leadership and 36 of the 51 Central Committee members were executed.

The purge of the lamas

The Buddhist clergy was the main target. In early October 1937, 23 high lamas tried for nearly a year as a "counter-revolutionary centre" were publicly executed. The number of executed lamas differs by source: over 16,000 (article on Luvsansharav), 17,000 (article on Choibalsan), 18,000 (English-language survey) and 18,817 (Mongolian Wikipedia). Some 746 monasteries were destroyed, and surviving monks were laicised or conscripted. One account has about 83,000 monks living in monasteries in September 1937 and fewer than five hundred by the end of 1938, while the Library of Congress country study gives about 2,000 "abbots and monks of higher rank" executed in 1937–1938. Mongolian Wikipedia describes interrogators writing down statements lamas had not made, taking the thumbprints of lamas who could not read Mongolian script, and turning the names of acquaintances that lamas gave into members of counter-revolutionary groups.

End and aftermath

Choibalsan was in the USSR from August 1938 to January 1939; on his return he had Prime Minister Amar denounced as a traitor and arrested in March 1939. In April 1939 he blamed the "excesses" on Deputy Interior Minister Nasantogtokh and the Soviet adviser Kichikov and ended the terror. The purge's executors, Luvsansharav among them, and the surviving founders such as Dogsom were then arrested and executed in the USSR in 1941. Mass graves were found near Mörön in 1991 and at Khambyn Ovoo in Ulaanbaatar in 2003. Rehabilitation began in the USSR in 1956 and in Mongolia in 1962, and since 1996 a day of remembrance for the victims of political repression has been held every year.

Differing views of scale and responsibility

Estimates of the total dead range from 20,000 to 35,000 (three to five percent of the population) in English-language accounts, through 36,000 shot in 1937–1939 according to Kaplonski, to 45,000 to 55,000, and as many as 100,000, in Mongolian Wikipedia. Frinovsky testified that he had some seven to eight thousand people arrested, that the chief adviser Golubchik raised the figure to 25,000, and that Choibalsan accepted the arrests while Amar opposed them. Popular memory in Mongolia lays the blame mainly on the USSR and the NKVD and sees Choibalsan as a puppet; the anthropologist Kaplonski argues that Stalin's instructions were inconsistent and that some of the worst killings were decided by the Mongolian leadership, and Mongolian historians reply that the records he used were manipulated by the Soviets.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN)
  2. mn.wikipedia.org
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. bulpolit.enu.kz
  5. Wikipedia (EN)
  6. bitterwinter.org
  7. countrystudies.us
  8. Wikipedia (EN)
  9. korean.go.kr