The Mongolian People's Republic: Leftist Deviation, Great Repression and Khalkhin Gol
Why did Mongolia, the second state after the USSR to call itself socialist, pass within twenty years through a disastrous collectivisation, an uprising close to civil war, a purge that killed several percent of its people, and international recognition of its independence?
Proclaimed a people's republic in 1924, Mongolia entered a Comintern-directed Leftist Deviation in 1928, confiscating herds, collectivising and attacking the monasteries, and retreated to the New Turn after the north-western uprising of 1932. After Japan seized Manchuria, the USSR consolidated Mongolia as a buffer, brought its troops back and removed Genden, who refused to purge the lamas. The Great Repression of 1937–1939 destroyed the clergy and the founding generation and left Choibalsan ruling alone. Having defeated Japan at Khalkhin Gol in 1939, Mongolia joined the war on Japan in 1945 and, after a plebiscite, won recognition of its independence from the Republic of China.
The monarchy ends and a people's republic is founded (1924–1928)
When the Bogd Khan (the 8th Jebtsundamba Khutuktu) died on 20 May 1924, the People's Government resolved to found a republic and forbade the traditional search for his reincarnation, removing the theocratic symbol that had survived the 1921 revolution as a limited monarch. On 31 May 1924 the USSR signed a treaty with China that acknowledged Outer Mongolia as part of China and provided for the withdrawal of Soviet troops, which left in March 1925 (some historians doubt that all of them did). Yet Moscow explicitly recognised Mongolia's independence of China in internal affairs and its right to an independent foreign policy, and made clear that it would permit no Chinese encroachment. 1 2
At the Third Party Congress, held from 4 to 24 August 1924, party chairman Danzan, who hoped to reduce Soviet influence, was arrested and executed as a "capitalist". The congress purged the party of "useless elements", renamed it the Mongolian People's Revolutionary Party, declared a socialist "non-capitalist path of development" and joined the Comintern. On 26 November the First State Great Khural adopted the first constitution, proclaiming the Mongolian People's Republic (the Library of Congress country study gives 25 November). It nationalised land, water and mineral wealth, granted suffrage at eighteen with the exception of "feudalists" and lamas living in monasteries, and adopted the soyombo as the state emblem. The capital, Niislel Khüree, was renamed Ulaanbaatar, "red hero". Balingiin Tserendorj became premier and Peljidiin Genden chairman of the Presidium of the Little Khural, the head of state. 1 3 4 5
The years 1925–1928 were later labelled the years of "Right Opportunism". The party's right wing under Dambadorj pursued a gradual course resembling the Soviet New Economic Policy. The aristocracy's feudal privileges were abolished, but many nobles kept their wealth and the number of monks actually grew between 1925 and 1928. The Mongolian Bank, set up in 1924 as a joint Mongolian–Soviet company, issued the new currency, the tögrög. Foreign trade swung quickly to the USSR: exports there rose from about 14 percent of total production in 1923–1924 to 85 percent in 1928–1929. Even so, Chinese firms still controlled nearly 90 percent of all trade. Each party congress of 1925, 1926 and 1927 saw a struggle between left and right. 2 6 3
The rightists ousted in 1928 and the Leftist Deviation (1928–1932)
The decisive clash came at the Seventh Party Congress, which sat for forty-eight days from late October to 10 December 1928. In February 1928 the Soviet Politburo had directed that Mongolia's leftists be rallied and ties with the USSR strengthened, and a Comintern delegation made the Mongolian leadership accept the change of course at the congress. Party chairman Dambadorj was branded a rightist and sent to Moscow, and the right wing was expelled. Genden, Badrakh and Eldev-Ochir (later Shijee) became co-secretaries, and Choibalsan was made chairman of the Little Khural presidium. The Library of Congress country study points to Stalin's backing, after his victory over his rivals in Moscow, and to the 1927 split between the Guomindang and the Chinese Communists, which freed Moscow from any need to accommodate Chiang Kai-shek. 7 8 5 6
The leftist leadership called for the immediate confiscation of feudal property, a five-year plan, the collectivisation of herders, the ouster of Chinese traders and a Soviet trade monopoly. In May 1929 a policy of confiscating livestock from feudal lords and wealthy lamas was set, a decree followed in September, and confiscation committees seized property across the country. Between 1929 and 1932 more than 800 properties of nobles and monasteries were confiscated and more than 700 heads of households were executed or imprisoned. Collective farms (communes) were created, but people classed as exploiters could not join them. By the end of 1930 nearly 30 percent of poor and middle herding households had been forced into collectives, and by 1931 more than a third of stock-raising households. The Eighth Party Congress of February–April 1930 set up a commission on the lama question; squeezed by heavy taxes, some 300 monasteries had closed by the end of the decade and the number of monks fell by 30 to 50 percent. 7 8 3 9
The result was a disaster. Frightened and angry herders slaughtered their animals, and some seven million head of livestock were lost in three years (Mongolian Wikipedia gives a fall of six million for 1928–1932). Famine spread in border districts cut off from supplies. As early as May 1929 the Soviet plenipotentiary Okhtin reported that anti-Soviet feeling was spreading among the population. Local uprisings broke out in the south and south-west between February and April 1930; Eldev-Ochir, who crushed the lama revolts at the Tögsbuyant and Ulaangom monasteries in Uvs, had thirty of their leaders executed on the spot. In 1931 alone about ten thousand people (thirty thousand by another account) fled to Inner Mongolia and Xinjiang. 7 10 8 9
The armed uprising of 1932 and the New Turn
The main uprising began on 10 or 11 April 1932 at the Khyalganat monastery in Rashaant sum, Khövsgöl aimag, and spread to neighbouring monasteries. The insurgents set up a command called "Ochirbat's Military Ministry", armed lamas and laypeople, burned sum centres and cooperatives, and killed party and youth league members. The revolt spread to Arkhangai, Övörkhangai, Zavkhan and Dörböt and covered some 155,000 square kilometres. The government sent a plenipotentiary commission under Jambyn Lkhümbe, whose troops burned Rashaant and summarily executed 54 of 204 captured insurgents. On 9 May the Defence Council declared a state of emergency in Khövsgöl and Arkhangai, and four government detachments of 1,300 men under Ölziibat, with aircraft and armoured cars, set out to suppress the rising. On 30 May the whole 1,195-strong garrison of Tsetserleg went over to the rebels. 9 8 11
Most participants were ordinary herders. Party secretary Luvsansharav reported that in Övörkhangai about 90 percent of party and Revolutionary Youth League members and about 95 percent of collective-farm members had joined the rebels. In July the insurgents numbered more than 3,000 in thirteen detachments (another source says over 5,000), armed with flintlocks and old rifles. Government troops had machine guns, mountain artillery, armoured cars and aircraft from the USSR, and Soviet military advisers took part in some battles. English-language accounts say Soviet units were not committed, while the Library of Congress country study writes that the government, with Soviet assistance, called in troops and tanks. The revolt was largely crushed in September, martial law was lifted on 22 September, and on 16 November the presidium of the party Central Committee ended military operations. Death tolls differ: the battle-by-battle data assembled by Kuzmin and Oyuunchimeg give more than 1,915 insurgent dead, while the Soviet official on the spot reported 8,000 to 10,000. 8 9 7
Soviet and Mongolian official historiography long described the uprising as a counter-revolution of feudal and lamaist reactionaries backed by Japan and the 9th Panchen Lama, who had left Tibet in 1924 and lived in China and Inner Mongolia. The rebels did spread rumours that the Panchen Lama was coming with an army and prophecies of a "Shambhala war". But the Russian and Mongolian researchers Kuzmin and Oyuunchimeg, re-examining the question in 2015 with newly opened documents, found that the evidence for Japanese or Panchen Lama organisation consisted only of rebels' statements and rumours, and that such charges served the domestic politics of the Mongolian left and instructions from Moscow. They judge that the uprising meets the general criteria of a civil war, and note that its participants remain the only group never officially rehabilitated. At the trial in Ulaanbaatar in April 1933, 18 of the 39 rebel leaders were sentenced to death and 15 to prison terms. 8 9
In May 1932, a month after the uprising, the Comintern and the Soviet Communist Party directed the Mongolian party to end its extremism. On 30 June an extraordinary plenum of the Central Committee condemned the previous policy as a "Leftist Deviation" and expelled Prime Minister Jigjidjav and secretaries Badrakh and Shijee as "left-wing adventurers" (Badrakh and Shijee were later executed; Jigjidjav was shot dead in his ger in May 1933 in circumstances that remain unclear). Genden survived by meeting Stalin and, with Moscow's support, became prime minister on 2 July in charge of the "New Turn" policy. Modelled on Lenin's New Economic Policy, it dissolved the collectives, cut the livestock tax, again allowed herders private property and private trade, and eased religious persecution. Choibalsan announced that "the overall development of our country has not yet entered the stage of socialism, and also it is wrong to copy Soviet experience in every single thing." Foreign trade remained a state monopoly. The Library of Congress country study sees the growing Japanese threat after the Mukden incident of 1931 as the underlying reason for Moscow's reversal, and notes that the Ninth Party Congress of 1934 pronounced the New Turn a success. 7 12 5 9
The Lkhümbe affair and the fall of Genden (1933–1936)
In spring 1933 a letter surfaced in Dadal, Khentii aimag, in which one low-level party functionary falsely accused another of collaborating with Japanese spies. Security chief Namsrai and his Soviet advisers set up a special commission. Suspects, likely prompted by their Soviet interrogators, named party secretary Jambyn Lkhümbe as the ringleader, and Prime Minister Genden and Eldev-Ochir consented to his arrest. Arrests, interrogations and torture widened the circle of "conspirators" to senior officials and army officers. More than 1,500 people were implicated; 56 were executed (a pregnant woman among them), 260 jailed for three to ten years and 126 sent to the USSR. Of those persecuted, 251 were Buryats: the Soviets, who distrusted Buryat-Mongols as linked to the Whites, used the case to break their influence in Mongolia. Lkhümbe was shot on 30 June 1934. 11 5 13
The Lkhümbe affair became a rehearsal for the purges of 1937–1939. Called to Moscow in 1934 and questioned about his own involvement, Choibalsan within days was helping the NKVD interrogate fellow Mongolians, and this loyalty raised him in Stalin's eyes. Stalin made Genden appoint Choibalsan deputy prime minister over his objections. In the same year Stalin urged Genden to eliminate the lamas as "the enemies within"; Genden, a devout Buddhist who liked to say that "on earth there are two great geniuses, Buddha and Lenin", had declared in 1933 that he would not fight religion. He also delayed the 1934 gentlemen's agreement and the 1936 mutual assistance protocol that allowed Soviet troops into Mongolia, and hesitated over advice to make the internal affairs committee a separate ministry. 11 6 5
After occupying Manchuria in 1931 Japan probed Mongolia's border. In January 1935 Mongolian and Manchukuo troops clashed around the Khalkha temple (Halhamiao), and in the Olahodag incident at the end of that year both sides used aircraft and armoured vehicles. On 27 November 1934 Mongolia and the USSR reached a "gentlemen's agreement" on mutual assistance against Japanese advances, and in January 1935 Soviet troops re-entered Mongolia. On 12 March 1936 a ten-year treaty of friendship with a mutual defence protocol was signed; it did not mention Chinese sovereignty, and Moscow ignored Chinese protests. Mongolia's military spending doubled in 1936 and exceeded half the budget by 1938. 12 14 5
In Moscow in December 1935 Stalin rejected Genden's requests for economic aid and again rebuked him for ignoring instructions. Witnesses later said that at a reception at the Mongolian embassy a drunken Genden quarrelled with Stalin and called him a Russian tsar. In March 1936, acting on Stalin's orders, Choibalsan convened a Central Committee plenum at which Luvsansharav led the charge that Genden had sabotaged relations with the USSR. Genden was removed as prime minister and foreign minister and placed under house arrest; on 22 March Amar became prime minister again, and Dogsom, one of the founding revolutionaries, became head of state. Choibalsan, as minister of the newly independent Ministry of Internal Affairs, 26 percent of whose staff were NKVD agents, became in effect the most powerful man in the country. Genden was sent to the USSR "for medical treatment" in April 1936, arrested in Sochi on 17 July 1937, and shot in Moscow on 26 November 1937. 5 6 15 16
The Great Repression (1937–1939): lamas and the founding generation
In May 1936, guided by his Soviet adviser Chopyak, Choibalsan had the internal affairs committee's rules amended so that senior politicians could be detained without consulting superiors. Soon afterwards 23 high lamas were arrested for belonging to a "counter-revolutionary centre"; after a trial of nearly a year they were publicly executed in early October 1937, and the procurator general who protested was himself arrested and shot. On 22 August 1937 Marshal Demid, popular in the army, died at Taiga station on the Trans-Siberian on his way to Moscow. The official cause was food poisoning; Russian sources say several members of his party were poisoned together by canned fish supplied by the Soviet side. Choibalsan became minister of war and sole commander-in-chief, and in early September (the 3rd or the 4th, depending on the English-language account) issued Order 366, which declared that many people "had fallen under the influence of Japanese spies and provocateurs". Demid was soon posthumously declared the head of a counter-revolutionary organisation and a Japanese spy, and his family was arrested. 13 6 17 18
That month Stalin ordered 30,000 Red Army troops stationed in Mongolia and sent Deputy NKVD Commissar Frinovsky to Ulaanbaatar with Deputy Defence Commissar Smirnov and the new plenipotentiary Mironov. Frinovsky handed Choibalsan a list of 115 "counter-revolutionaries and Japanese collaborators", and the arrest of 65 senior officials and intellectuals on the night of 10 September launched the purge in earnest. They were charged as Japanese spies in a "Genden–Demid plot" and most confessed under torture. On 2 October an Extraordinary Plenipotentiary Commission, an NKVD-style troika of Choibalsan, Justice Minister Tserendorj and party secretary Luvsansharav, was formed; at the first show trial in the Central Theatre on 18–20 October, 13 of the 14 defendants were sentenced to death, among them Sambadondogiin Tserendorj, prime minister in 1921 and abbot of the Manzushir monastery. Prime Minister Amar wept openly as his friends were condemned. 13 19 15 10
According to commission records cited both by Mongolian Wikipedia and by an article in a Kazakh academic journal, the Extraordinary Commission met 51 times between 10 September 1937 and 22 April 1939, considered the cases of 25,824 people, and sentenced 20,474 to be shot, 5,103 to ten years and 240 to shorter terms (the English-language article on Luvsansharav gives 25,785 cases and 20,099 death sentences). Between August 1937 and January 1938 alone 10,728 people were arrested, including 7,814 lamas, 322 former feudal lords, 300 officials, 180 military commanders, 1,555 Buryats and 408 Chinese; 6,311 of them were shot. Among Kazakhs, 3,270 were shot in 1937–1938, 7.6 percent of the 23,299 Kazakhs then in Mongolia. Twenty-five people from the top of the party and government, 187 from the military leadership and 36 of the 51 Central Committee members were executed. 10 20 19 13
The Buddhist clergy suffered most. Figures for executed lamas vary by source: over 16,000, 17,000, 18,000 and 18,817. Some 746 monasteries were liquidated, and monks who were not executed were forcibly laicised or conscripted. One account has about 83,000 monks living in monasteries in September 1937 and fewer than five hundred by the end of 1938. The Library of Congress country study gives a much smaller figure of about 2,000 "abbots and monks of higher rank" executed in 1937–1938. Estimates of the total dead diverge even more: 20,000 to 35,000 executed, three to five percent of the population, in English-language accounts; 36,000 shot in 1937–1939 according to Kaplonski; 45,000 to 55,000, and as many as 100,000, according to Mongolian Wikipedia. In 1991 near Mörön in Khövsgöl and in 2003 at Khambyn Ovoo in Ulaanbaatar, mass graves were found holding hundreds of lamas and civilians, each killed by a single shot to the base of the skull. 13 6 10 21 12 19
Where responsibility lies is still debated. Frinovsky later testified that Yezhov had sent him to Mongolia to station Soviet troops and "smash the conspiracy", that he had some seven to eight thousand people arrested, and that the ministry's chief adviser Golubchik raised the number to 25,000; he also said that Choibalsan accepted the mass arrests while Prime Minister Amar firmly refused. Popular memory in Mongolia tends to direct its anger at the USSR and the NKVD and to see Choibalsan as a puppet with no choice but to obey Moscow. The anthropologist Kaplonski, by contrast, argues from the archives that Stalin's instructions were contradictory and that some of the worst massacres were decided by Mongolian leaders; Mongolian historians reply that those archives were manipulated by the Soviets. Choibalsan was sometimes present, drunk, at torture and interrogations and added old rivals to arrest lists, yet when he recommended leniency the NKVD sometimes overrode him. 10 13 21 6
The fall of Amar and Choibalsan's personal rule (1939–1940)
From August 1938 to January 1939 Choibalsan stayed in Moscow and Sochi consulting with Voroshilov, Yezhov and Stalin while the purge went on. On his return he followed Soviet directives and removed the popular Prime Minister Amar. At an enlarged Central Committee meeting on 6 March 1939 Luvsansharav denounced Amar as a traitor who "had helped anti-government plotters, opposed their arrest, and neglected the defense of the borders", and Choibalsan seconded him. Amar answered that "although I believe in religion, the one thing that I believe in even more is that Mongolia should stand firmly on her feet to become an independent country", but he was arrested the next day. In July his case passed to the NKVD; before a Soviet court he insisted that if Mongolia were truly independent he should be tried by a Mongolian court, and he was shot on 10 July 1941. 15 13 19
With Amar gone Choibalsan held the posts of prime minister, minister of internal affairs, minister of war and commander-in-chief all at once. On 20 April 1939, at a special conference of the Interior Ministry, he declared that the "excesses" of the purge had been committed by overzealous officials while he was in the USSR, and brought the terror to an end; official blame fell on Deputy Interior Minister Nasantogtokh and the Soviet adviser Kichikov. In the summer of 1939 the purge's executors were rounded up and sent to Moscow, eliminating witnesses. Luvsansharav, arrested on 9 July, was held in the same prison as Amar and shot on 30 July 1941. Head of state Dogsom and Darizavyn Losol, arrested that same month, were with Choibalsan the last surviving members of the "first seven" founders of the People's Party; Dogsom was executed on 27 July 1941, and Losol died in a Soviet prison before trial. 13 19 16 6
At the Tenth Party Congress in March–April 1940 Choibalsan had General Secretary Baasanjav purged and replaced by Stalin's new favourite, the 24-year-old finance minister Tsedenbal. On 30 June the Eighth Great Khural adopted a second constitution modelled on the 1936 Soviet constitution; Choibalsan reported that "only the constitution of the Soviet Union may be a model for us in drafting our new constitution". It defined Mongolia as a state of "herdsmen, workers, and intelligentsia", added "counter-revolutionaries" to the disenfranchised, and named the Mongolian People's Revolutionary Party the "vanguard of the working people". The victims were rehabilitated only after the Soviet Military Collegium found no evidence against Genden and Amar in December 1956, and in Mongolia in 1962. In 1956 and 1962 the party acknowledged that Choibalsan had "committed serious errors" and established a personality cult. 6 4 3 5 15 12
Khalkhin Gol (1939): a Soviet–Japanese war on Mongolian soil
The border between Manchukuo and Mongolia was undefined. Mongolia and the USSR held that it ran some 16 to 20 kilometres east of the Khalkha river, as fixed by the Qing in 1734; Japan and Manchukuo claimed the river itself. The trigger came on 11 May 1939, when Manchukuo cavalry drove back 70 to 90 Mongolian horsemen who had entered the disputed area in search of grazing. The Kwantung Army escalated without Tokyo's approval, and the USSR sent Zhukov. Lhagvasüren, corps commissar of the Mongolian People's Revolutionary Army, became Zhukov's deputy, and Mongolia committed two cavalry divisions. On 20 August about 50,000 Soviet and Mongolian troops attacked, encircling the Japanese 23rd Division near Nomonhan on 25 August; by 31 August the Japanese forces on the Mongolian side of the border were destroyed. A cease-fire agreed in Moscow on 15 September took effect on the 16th. 22 14 12
Mongolian casualties were 556 to 990, including 280 killed. Japanese losses are given very differently, from the 8,629 killed in Kwantung Army internal records to the as many as 80,000 casualties mentioned by the Library of Congress country study. The defeat turned Japan away from confronting the USSR (the strike-north doctrine) toward the south, and in the Soviet–Japanese Neutrality Pact of 13 April 1941 Moscow obtained a Japanese commitment to respect Mongolia's territorial integrity. The victory, won near his birthplace, cemented Choibalsan's personality cult as the defender of independence against Japanese imperialism. At the International Military Tribunal for the Far East the USSR charged fourteen Japanese with initiating a war of aggression against the Mongolian People's Republic, and Doihara, Hiranuma and Itagaki were convicted on that count. 22 12 6
War on Japan and the independence plebiscite of 1945
When Germany invaded the USSR in 1941 Choibalsan proclaimed his support for the Soviet Union. Mongolia never declared war on Germany, but it sent livestock, raw materials, food, military clothing, fur-lined coats and money, and equipped several Soviet units. The Mongolian army was kept at 80,000 to 100,000 men throughout the war, a huge burden for a country of 900,000, and large Soviet requisitions cut the herds sharply. The adoption of the Cyrillic script was decreed in March 1941 (it came into general use only from January 1946), and the first university, Choibalsan University, opened in 1942. 6 12 3
Mongolia's international status was settled at the Allied summits. The first point of the secret Yalta agreement on Japan, of February 1945, read: "The status quo in Outer Mongolia (the Mongolian People's Republic) shall be preserved"; it added that this required Chiang Kai-shek's concurrence, which Roosevelt would take measures to obtain. In the Moscow talks of July Stalin insisted that the status quo meant Chinese recognition of Outer Mongolian independence. According to Ambassador Harriman's reports, T. V. Soong replied that China could not agree to cede territory and that no government that gave up Outer Mongolia could survive, while Stalin stressed Outer Mongolia's military importance, the danger of a Japanese recovery and the Soviet need to move troops there freely, and proposed a secret agreement on independence to be published after Japan's defeat. At the talks on the night of 9 July China, with Chiang's agreement, conceded that it would recognise independence after the war if a plebiscite favoured it. In the August round Stalin threatened that if China did not agree, the "Inner Mongolian brothers would join Outer Mongolia in forming a greater Mongolian Republic". 23 24 25 26
On 10 August, two days after the USSR, Mongolia declared war on Japan, and some 80,000 Mongolian troops joined the Soviet advance into Inner Mongolia and Manchuria; the Japanese abandoned their Inner Mongolian stronghold of Kalgan (Zhangjiakou) and fled south. Choibalsan, who dreamed of a Greater Mongolia, stirred pan-Mongolism in the press and sent troops as far as Zhangjiakou and Chengde, but an angry Stalin ordered them back. On 14 August the Republic of China's foreign minister Wang Shijie and Soviet foreign minister Molotov signed the Sino-Soviet Treaty of Friendship and Alliance in Moscow. In the accompanying exchange of notes China, citing the Outer Mongolian people's repeated wish for independence, agreed to recognise that independence within the "existing boundary" if a plebiscite after Japan's defeat confirmed it, and the USSR in return promised to stop aiding the Chinese Communists and the insurgents in Xinjiang and to support only the National Government. 12 27 6 28 29
From 30 August the Mongolian government organised some 13,000 mass meetings for independence. In the plebiscite of 20 October, observed by China's vice-minister of the interior Lei Fazhang, the official result was a 98 percent turnout and 100 percent in favour (Chinese Wikipedia gives 97 percent in favour). The historian Radchenko notes that both sides regarded the vote as political theatre. On 5 January 1946 the National Government issued a communiqué recognising the independence of Outer Mongolia on the strength of the plebiscite (English Wikipedia gives 6 January), and recognition was formally exchanged on 13–14 February, though no diplomatic representatives were ever exchanged. After the Communist victory in the civil war Mongolia recognised the People's Republic of China, and in February 1953 the Legislative Yuan of the Republic of China, now on Taiwan, renounced the treaty and withdrew its recognition of Mongolian independence. 30 29 31 12 28
Consequences
With the Republic of China's recognition in January 1946 Mongolia was for the first time acknowledged as a state by both of its great neighbours. The price was the near-extinction of the Buddhist clergy, the execution of most of the generation that had led the 1921 revolution, and deep military, economic and political dependence on the USSR. Rehabilitation of the victims began in the USSR in 1956 and in Mongolia in 1962, but open discussion of the purge waited until the democratic revolution of 1990, and how responsibility is divided between Moscow and the Mongolian leadership is still argued.
Timeline & Map
- 11924.11.26First constitution; the people's republic proclaimed
The First State Great Khural adopted a constitution proclaiming the Mongolian People's Republic and renamed the capital Ulaanbaatar.
- 21928.12.10Seventh Party Congress ousts the right
After forty-eight days the party chairman Dambadorj was sent to Moscow and the left took over party and government.
- 1929.09Decree on confiscating feudal property
A decree ordered the seizure of livestock from feudal lords and wealthy lamas, and confiscation committees were set up across the country.
- 31932.04.10Armed uprising begins in Khövsgöl
A revolt beginning at the Khyalganat monastery in Rashaant sum spread to several north-western aimags.
- 41932.06.30The "Leftist Deviation" condemned; the New Turn
An extraordinary Central Committee plenum condemned the previous line and expelled its leaders; Genden became prime minister on 2 July.
- 51934.06.30Lkhümbe shot
Party secretary Lkhümbe, accused of leading a Japanese spy ring, was shot; the case cost 56 lives.
- 1936.03.12Soviet–Mongolian mutual assistance protocol
A ten-year treaty of friendship with a mutual assistance protocol was signed, without mention of Chinese sovereignty.
- 61936.03.22Genden dismissed; Amar prime minister
Genden, who had clashed with Stalin, was removed; Amar became prime minister and Choibalsan minister of internal affairs.
- 71937.08.22Death of Marshal Demid
Demid died at Taiga station on his way to Moscow, and Choibalsan took command of the army.
- 81937.09.10Mass arrests begin
Sixty-five senior officials and intellectuals were arrested on lists Frinovsky had brought, and the Extraordinary Commission was formed.
- 91937.10.18First show trial
At the Central Theatre trial 13 of 14 defendants were sentenced to death.
- 101937.11.26Genden shot
The Military Collegium of the Soviet Supreme Court sentenced Genden to death, and he was shot in Moscow the same day.
- 111939.03.07Amar arrested
After Luvsansharav's denunciation, seconded by Choibalsan, Prime Minister Amar was arrested; Choibalsan became prime minister.
- 121939.04.22Extraordinary Commission ends its work
The commission, which had passed more than twenty thousand death sentences in fifty-one sittings, ended its work.
- 131939.05.11Fighting at Khalkhin Gol begins
Mongolian and Manchukuo cavalry clashed in the disputed area, and the fighting grew into a Soviet–Japanese war.
- 1939.09.16Khalkhin Gol cease-fire takes effect
The cease-fire agreed in Moscow took effect.
- 141940.06.30The 1940 constitution
A second constitution, modelled on the Soviet constitution of 1936, was adopted.
- 1945.02.11The Yalta clause on Outer Mongolia
The preservation of the status quo in Outer Mongolia was made a condition of Soviet entry into the war against Japan.
- 1945.08.10Mongolia declares war on Japan
Some 80,000 Mongolian troops advanced with the Soviet army into Inner Mongolia and Manchuria.
- 1945.08.14Sino-Soviet Treaty of Friendship and Alliance
China agreed to recognise Outer Mongolian independence subject to a plebiscite.
- 151945.10.20Independence plebiscite
The official result was a 98 percent turnout and 100 percent in favour.
- 1946.01.05The Republic of China recognises independence
The National Government issued a communiqué recognising the independence of Outer Mongolia.
Related people 20
Leadership2
Interior minister from 1936 and war minister from 1937, he headed the Extraordinary Commission and after removing Amar in 1939 ruled alone.
Soviet leaderJoseph Stalin1878–1953He directed both the Leftist Deviation and the New Turn, demanded that Genden purge the lamas, steered the Great Repression and Amar's removal, and in 1945 pressed China to recognise Outer Mongolian independence.
Implementers & commanders3
He led the denunciations of Genden and Amar and carried out the purge on the troika, then was arrested in 1939 and shot in 1941.
Deputy People's Commissar of Internal Affairs of the USSRMikhail Frinovsky1898–1940He came to Ulaanbaatar in 1937 with arrest lists and set up the framework of the purge.
People's Commissar of Internal Affairs of the USSRNikolai Yezhov1895–1940He gave Frinovsky the Mongolian mission.
Participants8
He consulted with Choibalsan in Moscow and Sochi in 1938–1939.
Commander of Soviet–Mongolian forces at Khalkhin GolGeorgy Zhukov1896–1974He destroyed the Japanese forces by double envelopment in August 1939.
Commander, Japanese 23rd DivisionMichitarō Komatsubara1885–1940He ordered attacks on the Mongolian forces despite the Kwantung Army's restraint.
Party general secretary from 1940Tsedenbal1916–1991At twenty-four he replaced the purged Baasanjav in 1940.
President of the United StatesFranklin D. Roosevelt1882–1945Under the Yalta agreement he undertook to obtain Chiang Kai-shek's concurrence on the Outer Mongolian status quo.
Chairman of the National Government of ChinaChiang Kai-shek1887–1975In July 1945 he agreed to recognise Outer Mongolian independence subject to a plebiscite.
Chinese premier and negotiator in MoscowSoong Ziwen1894–1971He negotiated with Stalin over Outer Mongolia in Moscow in 1945.
Soviet foreign ministerVyacheslav Molotov1890–1986He signed the Sino-Soviet Treaty of Friendship and Alliance on 14 August 1945.
Targets & victims6
Prime minister in charge of the New Turn from 1932, he resisted demands to purge the lamas, was removed in 1936 and shot in Moscow in 1937.
Prime minister (1936–1939)Amar1886–1941Powerless to stop the purge, he was denounced as a traitor in 1939 and shot in the USSR in 1941.
Marshal and minister of warDemid1900–1937He died in suspicious circumstances on the way to Moscow in August 1937 and was soon branded the head of a Japanese spy ring.
Party secretary; led the suppression of 1932Lkhümbe1902–1934He led the suppression of the 1932 uprising and was shot in 1934 as the alleged ringleader of a fabricated Japanese spy case.
Head of state (1936–1939)Dogsom1884–1941One of the "first seven" founders of the People's Party, he was arrested in 1939 after the amnesty for the Lkhümbe prisoners was held against him, and executed in 1941.
Party chairman ousted as a rightist in 1928Dambadorj?–1934Branded a rightist at the Seventh Party Congress, he was sent to Moscow.
Related terms
Sources: reference 1reference 2reference 3reference 4reference 5reference 6reference 7reference 8reference 9reference 10reference 11reference 12reference 13reference 14reference 15reference 16reference 17reference 18reference 19reference 20reference 21reference 22reference 23reference 24reference 25reference 26reference 27reference 28reference 29reference 30reference 31