Зүүний нугалаа · 1929–1932

Leftist Deviation (Mongolia, 1929–1932)

좌편향 시기 (몽골, 1929~1932)

The radical course the Mongolian People's Revolutionary Party pursued in 1929–1932 under the direction of the Comintern and the Soviet Communist Party, after it had expelled its right wing at the Seventh Congress in late 1928, and the name the party itself gave that course when it condemned it in June 1932. Pressing at once the confiscation of the property of feudal lords and monasteries, the forced collectivisation of herders, a ban on private trade and transport, and an assault on the monasteries, it caused the loss of millions of head of livestock, famine and the armed uprising of 1932, and on Moscow's orders gave way to the New Turn policy.

In depth

Background

After founding the people's republic in 1924, the Mongolian People's Revolutionary Party followed a gradual course resembling the Soviet New Economic Policy under the right wing led by Dambadorj in 1925–1928. Many nobles kept their wealth, the number of lamas actually grew, and Chinese firms controlled nearly 90 percent of domestic trade. When Stalin defeated his rivals and ended the New Economic Policy, Mongolia changed direction too. In February 1928 the Soviet Politburo directed that Mongolia's leftists be rallied, and a Comintern delegation carried the change through at the Seventh Party Congress, which sat from late October to 10 December 1928. Dambadorj was sent to Moscow and Genden, Badrakh and Eldev-Ochir became co-secretaries. The 1927 split between the Guomindang and the Communists, which freed Moscow from any need to accommodate Chiang Kai-shek, was part of the background.

Policies

In December 1928 the Fifth Great Khural approved the line of "non-capitalist development", and the leadership called for the immediate confiscation of feudal property, a five-year plan, the collectivisation of herders, the ouster of Chinese traders and a Soviet trade monopoly. In May 1929 a policy of confiscating livestock from feudal lords and wealthy lamas was set, a decree followed in September, and confiscation committees were set up across the country. Between 1929 and 1932 more than 800 properties of nobles and monasteries were confiscated and more than 700 heads of households were executed or imprisoned. The collectives (communes and khamtral) did not admit "exploiters". By the end of 1930 nearly 30 percent of poor and middle herding households had been forced into collectives, and by 1931 more than a third of stock-raising households. The Eighth Party Congress of February–April 1930 set up a commission on the lama question, tried to draw poor lamas out of the monasteries into the collectives, and squeezed the monasteries with heavy taxes. The government banned private industry, forced craftsmen into cooperatives and nationalised foreign and domestic trade and transport.

Results

Collectivisation imposed mechanically on a nomadic society ended in disaster. Frightened and angry herders slaughtered their animals, and seven million head were lost in three years (Mongolian Wikipedia gives a fall of six million for 1928–1932). With trade destroyed and Soviet supplies inadequate, famine spread in 1931–1932. As early as May 1929 the Soviet plenipotentiary Okhtin reported that anti-Soviet feeling was spreading. Uprisings broke out in the south and south-west in spring 1930, and in 1931 alone about ten thousand people (thirty thousand by another account) fled abroad. The armed uprising that began in Khövsgöl in April 1932 spread across several north-western aimags.

Liquidation and the New Turn

In May 1932 the Comintern and the Soviet Communist Party directed the Mongolian party to end its extremism. On 30 June an extraordinary plenum of the Central Committee condemned the previous policy as a "Leftist Deviation" and expelled Prime Minister Jigjidjav and secretaries Badrakh and Shijee as "left-wing adventurers"; Badrakh and Shijee were later executed, and Jigjidjav was shot dead in his ger in May 1933 in circumstances that remain unclear. Genden, with Stalin's support, became prime minister on 2 July and, through the "New Turn" policy (Shine ergeltiin bodlogo) modelled on Lenin's New Economic Policy, dissolved the collectives, cut the livestock tax and again allowed private property and private trade. Choibalsan announced that "the overall development of our country has not yet entered the stage of socialism, and also it is wrong to copy Soviet experience in every single thing." The Library of Congress country study sees the threat from Japan, which had occupied Manchuria, as the underlying reason for Moscow's reversal.

Differing accounts

Later official histories credited Choibalsan with being the first to criticise the deviation, which English-language scholarship treats as a fabrication serving his personality cult: he had backed the leftist policies as chairman of the Little Khural presidium in 1929–1930 and enforced collectivisation as minister of livestock and agriculture from 1931. Where the party's verdict blamed Mongolian "left-wing adventurers", the research of Kuzmin and Oyuunchimeg holds that Mongolia carried out policies like Soviet collectivisation on the instructions of leaders sent by the Comintern and the USSR.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. countrystudies.us
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. countrystudies.us
  5. tohoku.repo.nii.ac.jp
  6. Wikipedia (EN)
  7. Wikipedia (EN)
  8. mn.wikipedia.org
  9. Wikipedia (EN)
  10. Wikipedia (EN)
  11. korean.go.kr
  12. Wikipedia (EN)