информационная война · 1970s–present

Information Warfare

정보전

Information warfare is a mode of confrontation in which information is collected, protected, manipulated and spread in order to disturb an adversary's perception and decision-making and secure an information advantage for one's own side. As a military term it took hold in the United States in the 1970s and became doctrine around the Gulf War; the Russian informatsionnaya voyna likewise entered the language as a translation of the English "information and psychological warfare". It spans propaganda, psychological operations, deception, electronic warfare and cyberattacks and blurs the line between peace and war. Soviet "active measures" and the theory of reflexive control belong to its lineage as much as US information operations doctrine, and today the term is also widely used as political language in which states name each other as the aggressor.

In depth

Where does the term "information warfare" come from?

Attempts to deceive, frighten and demoralise the enemy are as old as war. Sun Tzu wrote that "all warfare is based on deception", and during the Crimean War of the nineteenth century British newspapers inflated reports of enemy atrocities. But gathering such activity under the single name of "information warfare" and making it a formal military mission is relatively recent.

An early use of the English phrase is the title of a 1970 book by the reporter Dale Minor, The Information War, on propaganda and news manipulation in the Vietnam War era. The present sense of a military capability dates from 1976, when Thomas Rona, a Boeing engineer, wrote of "information war" in a monograph for the Pentagon's Office of Net Assessment. The US Air Force has had information warfare squadrons since the 1980s, and the disabling of Iraqi communications networks in the 1991 Gulf War is considered the first full application of these techniques. In the mid-1990s the Department of Defense developed the doctrine of "command and control warfare", aimed at an adversary's command and control, which led to the doctrine of "information operations" integrating electronic warfare, computer network operations, psychological operations, military deception and operations security.

The Russian informatsionnaya voyna entered the language within this current. As Russian Wikipedia explains, the term translates the English "information and psychological warfare" and was borrowed from US military vocabulary, which is why different documents render the same concept as "information confrontation", "information and psychological war" and so on. Some accounts present information warfare as a Soviet invention, but the history of the term looks more like the United States and the Soviet Union and Russia each developing their own doctrines while watching each other's concepts.

How does it differ from propaganda and psychological warfare?

Information warfare is broader than propaganda. Propaganda spreads particular messages to an adversary or a public; information warfare adds collecting tactical information, making sure one's own information is valid, degrading the quality of the opponent's information and denying the opponent chances to collect it. Jamming broadcasts, disrupting communications networks, unsettling stock markets with planted falsehoods and the organised use of social media to sway opinion all fall under it. Psychological warfare, the part aimed directly at people's minds, overlaps most closely with it, while cyberwarfare that attacks computers and command and control systems themselves is usually distinguished from it.

At its core, information warfare manipulates information that the target trusts, without the target's awareness, so that the target makes decisions against its own interest and in the interest of the attacker. That is why it is unclear when it begins and ends and how much damage it has done. Comparing it with conventional war in 2000, the media scholar Georgy Pocheptsov named as its greatest danger that it leaves no visible destruction, so that society's defence mechanisms are never triggered. Information warfare goes on without pause in peacetime too, and groups and individuals take part in it as well as state bodies.

In 1971, at the height of the Cold War, the Canadian media theorist Marshall McLuhan said that "World War III is a guerrilla information war with no division between military and civilian participation." This diagnosis, that the lines between war and peace and between front and rear blur, is quoted as a starting point of today's debates on information warfare.

How did the Soviet Union and Russia theorise information confrontation?

In the Soviet Union covert operations to influence other states' opinion and policy were called "active measures" (aktivnye meropriyatiya). The term was used from the 1920s and covered a wide range, from propaganda and disinformation to forged documents and support for front organisations abroad. Oleg Kalugin, former head of foreign counter-intelligence in the KGB, called active measures "the heart and soul of Soviet intelligence" and recalled that their purpose was not intelligence collection but subversion: driving wedges into Western alliances and damaging the reputation of the United States. Operation Denver, run in the 1980s by the KGB with the East German Ministry for State Security, spread the story that the United States had created the AIDS virus in biological weapons research at Fort Detrick. It began with an anonymous letter in an Indian newspaper in 1983 and spread around the world.

On the theoretical side "reflexive control" matters. Formulated by the Soviet scholar Vladimir Lefebvre in the 1960s, it means handing the adversary the very basis on which it makes decisions, so that it chooses to its own disadvantage. The Russian military theorist S. A. Komov presented it as "intellectual methods of information warfare", naming elements such as distraction, overload with contradictory information, paralysis, exhaustion, deception and division. American research institutes see these Soviet doctrines as developed decades before Russia's present hybrid warfare.

An article written in 2013 by Valery Gerasimov, chief of the Russian General Staff, has been widely cited in the West as the "Gerasimov doctrine" or "new generation warfare". On this reading the main battlespace of modern war is the mind, and the aim is to break the morale of the enemy's forces and population through information and psychological warfare so that military force need be used as little as possible. The use of "hybrid warfare", though, runs in opposite directions in the two camps. In the West it has come to mean almost the same as malign Russian activity; in Russia since 2014 it has come to mean attacks the West wages against the country in every field from sport to vaccines.

How has the West waged information warfare?

US information operations also have a long history. In the Second World War the US Army's "Ghost Army" carried out large-scale deceptions with inflatable tanks and false radio traffic. In the Korean War the Eighth Army routinely conducted psychological warfare, dropping a weekly "news" leaflet on communist forces and running radio and loudspeaker broadcasts. After the Gulf War the US military built up the ability to paralyse an adversary's communications electronically as a core of information warfare.

There have been peacetime disinformation operations as well. According to a Reuters report, from 2020 to mid-2021 the US military used fake social media accounts aimed mainly at the Philippines to spread the false claim that the Chinese Sinovac vaccine contained pork ingredients and was therefore forbidden under Islamic law. The campaign was described as "payback" for Chinese COVID-19 disinformation. The case shows that information warfare is a tool of all great powers, not of one camp.

Why is the term itself contested?

First, it is hard to establish who attacked. When US Air Force intelligence computers came under a coordinated attack in 1999, part of it came from a Russian mainframe, yet it could not be confirmed as a Russian attack because an online identity does not prove a real-world one. The less clear the evidence, the more easily the label "information warfare" becomes a political claim in itself.

Second, each camp portrays the other as the aggressor and itself as the victim. Researchers find Russia and the West engaged in an information war with each other. Russia believes the West is undermining its leader by encouraging liberal values and the overthrow of authoritarian regimes; the West sees Russia undermining democracy through election interference and disinformation. Russian interference in the 2016 US election is treated in the West as the textbook case of information warfare.

Third, the line between war and peace breaks down. Information warfare carries far less risk and cost than a conventional attack, so it happens more often, and the whole of civilian information technology can become a target. Just war theory, which sets out when war is justified, was built for traditional war and fits information warfare poorly. Because critical reporting or political opposition in peacetime can also be branded "enemy information warfare", the term serves both as a concept that explains something and as a weapon for defining an opponent.

Related people

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN) overview, definition, and history of information warfare as a military-strategic concept
  2. Wikipedia (RU) Russian/Soviet conceptual history, including Cold War origins and the distinction from psychological warfare
  3. understandingwar.org Soviet doctrinal origins of reflexive control and information warfare, developed decades before Russia's hybrid warfare in Ukraine
  4. lawfaremedia.org Iranian information operations tactics, including disinformation campaigns and the use of cyber-enabled influence operations as asymmetric retaliation
  5. Wikipedia (EN) Dale Minor's The Information War (1970), Thomas Rona's 1976 Boeing monograph for the Office of Net Assessment, USAF information warfare squadrons, first application in the Gulf War, Moonlight Maze and non-attribution, Russia and the West, US Sinovac disinformation campaign 2020-2021, just war theory concerns
  6. Wikipedia (RU) term as a translation of "information and psychological warfare" borrowed from US military vocabulary; Pocheptsov's seven differences from conventional war; McLuhan 1971 on World War III as a guerrilla information war; continuous in peace and war
  7. Wikipedia (EN) Vladimir Lefebvre's definition, four stages from the early 1960s, Komov's intellectual methods of information warfare (distraction, overload, paralysis, exhaustion, deception, division)
  8. Wikipedia (EN) Soviet and Russian political warfare from the 1920s, Kalugin's "heart and soul of Soviet intelligence", Andropov Institute, term also applied to other states
  9. Wikipedia (EN) KGB and Stasi campaign of the 1980s (Operation Denver) claiming that the United States created HIV/AIDS at Fort Detrick, launched via the Indian newspaper Patriot in 1983
  10. Wikipedia (EN) new generation warfare (2013), main battlespace as the mind, hybrid warfare term shifting to mean malign Russian activities in the West and Western aggression in Russia
  11. Wikipedia (EN) US Joint Publication 3-13 definition (EW, CNO, PSYOP, MILDEC, OPSEC), command and control warfare in the mid-1990s, Eighth Army leaflets and broadcasts in the Korean War