Intersectionality
교차성
Intersectionality is the analytical framework holding that social positions such as race, gender, class, sexuality and disability overlap to produce combinations of discrimination and privilege that cannot be seen when each is taken separately. The American legal scholar Kimberlé Crenshaw coined the term in a 1989 essay and developed it in 1991. She argued that the discrimination Black women face is not simply sexism plus racism, and that US anti-discrimination law, which weighs one axis at a time, failed to protect them. The idea grew out of a Black feminist tradition that runs from nineteenth-century Black women activists to the "interlocking oppressions" of the 1977 Combahee River Collective Statement. Among Marxists some have taken it up, while social reproduction theorists argue that it describes oppressions without explaining them as parts of a single capitalist system.
In depth
Why did Crenshaw coin "intersectionality"?
Crenshaw first used the word in her 1989 essay "Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex: A Black Feminist Critique of Anti-discrimination Doctrine, Feminist Theory and Antiracist Politics". Her starting point was the courtroom. In DeGraffenreid v. General Motors (1976), Emma DeGraffenreid and four other Black women auto workers alleged that the company's seniority-based layoffs amounted to compound discrimination against them as Black women. The court weighed the race and sex claims separately: the employment of Black men in the factory disproved racial discrimination, and the employment of white women in the offices disproved sex discrimination. It declined to consider the combination and dismissed the case.
Crenshaw pointed out that anti-discrimination law operates on a "single axis", accounting for one identity at a time, so that a Black woman's experience that cannot be proved through one form of discrimination alone falls outside the law. In "Mapping the Margins" (1991) she examined how race and gender work together in responses to domestic violence and rape, and argued that when anti-racist and feminist movements each put forward a single axis, women of colour are marginalised in both. Since the 2010s she has rejected readings of intersectionality as a blanket term for "complicated" problems or "identity politics on steroids", describing it as
a lens, a prism, for seeing the way in which various forms of inequality often operate together and exacerbate each other
What came before Crenshaw?
The word dates from 1989, but the idea is older. Sojourner Truth's 1851 speech "Ain't I a Woman?", Anna Julia Cooper's 1892 writing and Frances M. Beal's 1969 pamphlet "Double Jeopardy: To Be Black and Female" are often cited as forerunners. The Combahee River Collective, a Black lesbian socialist organisation active in Boston from 1974 to 1980, spoke in its 1977 Statement of "interlocking" oppressions of race, sex, class and sexuality and of their simultaneity. The Statement held that the liberation of all peoples requires the destruction of capitalism, imperialism and patriarchy, and wrote that "if Black women were free, it would mean that everyone else would have to be free since our freedom would necessitate the destruction of all the systems of oppression". Angela Davis's Women, Race and Class (1981) is also counted a classic of this current. In the 1990s the sociologist Patricia Hill Collins widened the idea into a "matrix of domination" formed by intersecting oppressions.
How have Marxists taken up and criticised intersectionality?
Marxist responses vary. Social reproduction theorists accept intersectionality's concerns but criticise its method. Tithi Bhattacharya's introduction to the collection Social Reproduction Theory (2017) builds on the "insights of intersectionality" while criticising its approach to race and gender as discrete systems that intersect; David McNally develops the critique in his chapter "Intersections and Dialectics". The book's back cover presents it as "an alternative to intersectionality". Theorists such as McNally, Sue Ferguson and Bhattacharya hold that intersectionality mainly describes oppression, whereas historical materialism explains why capitalism behaves as it does (see "Social Reproduction Theory (SRT)").
Ashley Bohrer, by contrast, argued in Marxism and Intersectionality that much of the debate between the two traditions comes from mutual dismissal, and read intersectionality as a framework that refuses primacy to any single axis of oppression. She criticised the American Trotskyist Sharon Smith for treating intersectionality as a mere add-on to Marxist analysis. The Black Marxist feminist Eve Mitchell, for her part, argued that identities appear in intersectional analysis as ahistorical and idealist. Others argue that the neoliberal university has diluted and commodified intersectionality into "unthreatening" narratives of social justice.
How is the term used in Korea?
In Korean both gyocharseong and sanghogyocharseong are used, and feminism based on the theory is called "intersectional feminism" (gyocharseong peminijeum or gyochayeoseongjuui). In 2018 the Women and Culture Theory Institute published the collection Gyocharseong × Feminism. Crenshaw's essays have not appeared in Korean as a book.