Lenin's plan of monumental propaganda
기념비 선전 계획
The plan proposed by Lenin in the spring of 1918 and launched by the Council of People's Commissars' decree "On the Monuments of the Republic" (12 April 1918), which set out to remove monuments to the tsars and their servants and to raise monuments to revolutionaries, thinkers and cultural figures, together with revolutionary slogans, across the cities, turning the streets into a place of mass education. By November 1918 twelve monuments stood in Moscow, and by 1921 more than 25 had been erected in Moscow and more than 15 in Petrograd. Lacking materials, many were temporary works in plaster and concrete, and those by sculptors of Futurist leanings caused controversy.
In depth
Can the street itself become a textbook?
How do you spread the ideas of a new society in a country where most people cannot read? In the spring of 1918 Lenin raised an idea with the People's Commissar of Education, Anatoly Lunacharsky. According to Lunacharsky's 1933 recollection, Lenin recalled the Italian philosopher Tommaso Campanella's utopia The City of the Sun, where frescoes on the walls of the ideal city teach the young natural science and history and rouse civic feeling. Since the Russian climate hardly allowed frescoes, Lenin proposed instead to inscribe the principles and slogans of Marxism on prominent walls and, above all, to put up monuments.
Я назвал бы то, о чем я думаю, монументальной пропагандой.
"I would call what I have in mind monumental propaganda." Lenin was not after permanence: as Lunacharsky reports, "let it all be temporary for now".
What did the 1918 decree lay down?
Lunacharsky included Lenin's plan in a report to the All-Russian Central Executive Committee on 11 April 1918. The next day, 12 April, Lenin, Lunacharsky and Stalin signed the Council of People's Commissars' decree "On the Monuments of the Republic". It ordered the removal from squares and streets of monuments erected in honour of the tsars and their servants that had no historical or artistic value, a competition for monuments to commemorate the great days of the Russian socialist revolution, and the presentation of the first models "to the judgement of the masses" by 1 May.
Памятники, воздвигнутые в честь царей и их слуг и не представляющие интереса ни с исторической, ни с художественной стороны, подлежат снятию с площадей и улиц и частью перенесению в склады, частью использованию утилитарного характера.
The decree also ordered inscriptions, emblems, street names and coats of arms to be replaced by new ones expressing "the ideas and feelings of revolutionary working Russia", and the city to be decorated for May Day.
How did it go in practice?
The 1 May deadline was in effect missed. There was less than a month, money and a mechanism of execution were not settled, and the Fine Arts Department (IZO) of the Commissariat of Education, which the decree had placed on the commission, was only set up on 22 May. In July and August 1918 the Council of People's Commissars settled and published the list of people to be honoured with monuments: not only revolutionaries and social activists but also Russian and foreign poets, philosophers, scientists, painters, composers and actors. Some fifty sculptors were paid an equal fee and given commissions.
Amid the deprivation of the Civil War and "War Communism", bronze was out of the question. The first monuments were therefore temporary works in plaster, concrete and wood, the best to be transferred later into permanent materials (see the entry "War Communism"). By the first anniversary of the revolution, 7 November 1918, twelve monuments had been unveiled in Moscow, and in 1918–21 Moscow received more than 25 and Petrograd more than 15. The first bronze monuments appeared in Moscow only in 1924.
Why were the Futurists' monuments controversial?
Monumental propaganda was the revolutionary government's first large state commission to artists. But opinions differed over the style of the results. Lunacharsky recalled that some monuments were successful, but that Muscovites called the Moscow statue of Marx and Engels "Cyril and Methodius" (the two saints who created the Slavic alphabet). And he added:
Свирепствовали особенно наши модернисты и футуристы. Многих огорчило чрезвычайно нечеловеческое изображение Перовской.
"Our modernists and Futurists ran especially wild. The extremely inhuman depiction of Perovskaya upset many." Boris Korolev's Cubist Bakunin was rumoured to make horses shy away, and in the end it stayed behind a board fence and was never unveiled. Vladimir Tatlin's Monument to the Third International (1919–20), meanwhile, abandoned the very form of the statue in an attempt to turn the monument into a huge working building (see the entry "Constructivism (art)").
How did it connect with other street art?
Monumental propaganda was not a matter of sculpture alone. Russian Wikipedia writes that it envisaged a synthesis of all the arts, including literature, theatre and music, as in mass festivals. The street art of the revolutionary years unfolded in several directions. On 13 August 1918 the first agit-train left for Kazan, just retaken; it carried a printing press, film equipment and agitators, and its carriages were covered with paintings and slogans by artists. From the autumn of 1919 to 1921 the empty shop windows of the Russian Telegraph Agency (ROSTA) carried the satirical posters known as "ROSTA windows", drawn and written by Mayakovsky, Mikhail Cheremnykh and others. On 7 November 1920 the mass spectacle The Storming of the Winter Palace, with some 10,000 participants, re-enacted the revolution of three years before on Palace Square in Petrograd (see the entry "Agitprop").
How is it judged?
Soviet art history praised monumental propaganda as the starting point of Soviet sculpture. The sculptor Vera Mukhina wrote that it was "the seed from which all Soviet sculpture grew", and the Great Soviet Encyclopedia said that in a broad sense the whole history of Soviet monumental art was a continuation of the plan. Russian Wikipedia sums up that state commissions set the main direction of Soviet sculpture: urban monuments, social significance as the criterion for choosing subjects, heroic content and idealisation, and at times excessive pathos.
There are other views. The removal of monuments began even before the decree, and the dismantling of the Kremlin monument to Alexander II and of the statue of Alexander III was a kind of theatre, photographed and filmed and shown across the country. Seen this way, monumental propaganda was as much the public erasure of old symbols as the raising of new monuments.