quarantine (naval) · 1962.10–11

Naval Quarantine

해상 격리

The naval interdiction of Cuba ordered by US President John F. Kennedy on 22 October 1962 to stop further Soviet offensive weapons from reaching the island. Kennedy and the State Department's legal adviser deliberately called it a 'naval' or 'defensive quarantine' rather than a blockade, because under international law a blockade was held to be an act of war. The wording stressed that interdiction covered only offensive weaponry and avoided implying a state of war, helping the United States win the support of the Organization of American States; the measure ran until 20 November 1962.

In depth

Why "quarantine" rather than "blockade"?

When it was confirmed in October 1962 that Soviet medium-range ballistic missile sites were being built in Cuba, the US government weighed an air strike, an invasion and a naval interdiction. President John F. Kennedy chose the middle course, the interdiction. But he did not call it a "blockade"; he called it a "quarantine". On the surface this was a single word, but the choice had a clear reason in international law.

In international law a blockade is a belligerent right. A blockading state may stop every ship entering or leaving the enemy's ports and may search third-country ships and seize contraband. These rights presuppose a state of war. As the State Department's Office of the Historian puts it, a blockade assumed that a state of war existed; calling the measure a blockade would have meant the United States declaring itself at war with the Soviet Union and Cuba. With two nuclear powers facing each other, that had to be avoided.

Blockade without war was not unknown. Nineteenth-century great powers closed the ports of weaker states to enforce their demands without declaring war, a practice called "pacific blockade": Britain against New Granada (today's Colombia) in 1837 and France against Mexico in 1838 are examples. But pacific blockade worked only when the target could not resist; used against a state able to resist, it was regarded as the beginning of hostilities. It was not a method that could be used against the Soviet Union.

"Quarantine" is originally a medical word for isolating the sick. There was also a precedent for its use as a diplomatic term in American politics. In October 1937 President Franklin Roosevelt said in a speech in Chicago that an international quarantine was needed against the "epidemic of world lawlessness" spread by aggressor nations. The Kennedy administration's "quarantine" likewise suggested a defensive measure against contagion while avoiding the legal effects of war.

What did the quarantine stop, and what did it let through?

Kennedy announced the quarantine in a televised address on 22 October, and Proclamation 3504, signed the next day, gave it its legal form. The proclamation ordered US forces to interdict, from 2 p.m. Greenwich time on 24 October, the delivery of offensive weapons and associated materiel to Cuba. The prohibited materiel was surface-to-surface missiles, bomber aircraft, bombs, air-to-surface rockets and guided missiles, warheads for these weapons, mechanical or electronic equipment to support or operate them, and any further classes the Secretary of Defense might designate.

The Chief of Naval Operations, Admiral George Anderson, wrote a paper distinguishing a "quarantine" of offensive weapons from a classic blockade of all materials, and the operation followed that scheme. Ships bound for Cuba could be ordered to stop, identify themselves and their cargo and submit to visit and search, and a ship believed to carry prohibited materiel was to be directed to another destination. Force was to be used only on refusal to comply or in self-defence, and only to the extent necessary. In his speech Kennedy added: "We are not at this time, however, denying the necessities of life as the Soviets attempted to do in their Berlin blockade of 1948." That food and fuel could still get through was presented as the difference from a blockade.

The distinction was kept at sea as well. On 25 October the Soviet tanker Bucharest, judged not to be carrying military materiel, was allowed through the line; the next day the US Navy boarded the Lebanese freighter Marucla, chartered by the Soviets, checked its cargo and cleared it. But the quarantine line was a dangerous place in itself. On 27 October the US Navy dropped small signalling depth charges on the Soviet submarine B-59 near the line, unaware that it carried a nuclear-tipped torpedo.

Why was a resolution of the Organization of American States needed?

The quarantine meant stopping other countries' ships on the high seas, so even if it was not war it needed a legal basis. Lawyers at the State and Justice Departments decided to rely on the Rio Treaty (the Inter-American Treaty of Reciprocal Assistance) for the common defence of the Western Hemisphere: a resolution passed by two thirds of the members of the Organization of American States (OAS) would provide a basis without a declaration of war.

On 23 October the OAS Organ of Consultation recommended that member states take "all measures, individually and collectively, including the use of armed force" to keep Cuba from receiving further offensive weapons. The vote was unanimous apart from Cuba, which had already been excluded. Proclamation 3504 cited this resolution together with the Joint Resolution on Cuba passed by the US Congress on 3 October. Argentina and Venezuela sent destroyers to take part in the operation.

The State Department Legal Adviser, Abram Chayes, considered a self-defence rationale and rejected it. Instead he put the collective decision of the OAS, the framework of regional arrangements recognised by the UN Charter, at the centre. Kennedy himself stressed in his speech that the UN Charter allows for regional security arrangements.

Was the quarantine lawful?

Opinions were divided from the start. The Soviet Union called the quarantine "outright piracy" and an act of aggression. In a telegram to Kennedy on 24 October Khrushchev wrote that the Soviet Union could not afford not to decline the "despotic demands of the USA". From the Soviet point of view, renaming the act did not change the nature of stopping another country's ships on the high seas.

There was criticism in the United States too. The international lawyer Quincy Wright considered the quarantine clearly illegal. The issue was Article 53 of the UN Charter, which requires Security Council authorisation for enforcement action by regional agencies; the US government replied that no authorisation was needed because the OAS resolution recommended the removal of the missiles and did not necessarily require armed force. Defenders, by contrast, argue that the quarantine was limited to the narrow category of offensive weapons, took place on the high seas rather than in Cuban waters and could be reversed at any time, and so met the requirements of necessity and proportionality. The US side also argued that the Security Council, where both the United States and the Soviet Union held a veto, could not have reached a decision anyway.

Looking back in 1974, Chayes wrote that international law did not dictate an answer in this crisis, but that the need for a public legal justification made the decision more careful. The quarantine was also legally less aggressive than the alternatives on the table, an air strike or an invasion. Critics and defenders largely agree, however, that "quarantine" was a euphemism meant to stay below the threshold of war; English-language accounts often simply call the measure a blockade.

How has the word been used since?

Even after Khrushchev agreed on 28 October to withdraw the missiles, the United States kept the quarantine in place until the Soviet bombers left in Cuba had also been withdrawn, and lifted it on 20 November 1962. The episode left a precedent for a maritime measure that coerces an opponent without declaring a state of war.

The concept is used again today in other contexts. In 2024 the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), analysing scenarios in which China might pressure Taiwan, distinguished a "quarantine", led by law-enforcement bodies such as the coast guard and controlling maritime traffic below the threshold of armed conflict, from a military-led "blockade". The logic of the word the United States used in 1962, avoiding the legal effects of war by changing the name and the agent, has come back as a framework for analysing another great power.

What the word "quarantine" shows is one way of managing crises in the Cold War. The two nuclear powers pressed each other hard while trying above all not to enter a formal state of war, and the choice of legal vocabulary was part of that balancing act.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN) He referred to the blockade as a 'quarantine', not as a blockade, so the US could avoid the formal implications of a state of war.
  2. history.state.gov The use of 'quarantine' legally distinguished this action from a blockade, which assumed a state of war existed; the use of 'quarantine' instead of 'blockade' also enabled the United States to receive the support of the Organization of American States.
  3. history.state.gov
  4. cimsec.org
  5. Wikipedia (EN) legal experts at State and Justice on the Rio Treaty and a two-thirds OAS vote, Admiral Anderson's paper distinguishing quarantine of offensive weapons from a blockade of all materials, Argentine and Venezuelan ships, TASS "outright piracy", Soviet view of an act of aggression, Bucharest let through, Marucla boarded and cleared, B-59 signalling depth charges, quarantine kept until 20 November 1962
  6. presidency.ucsb.edu Proclamation 3504 of 23 October 1962: Joint Resolution of 3 October 1962, OAS Organ of Consultation under Articles 6 and 8 of the Rio Treaty, interdiction from 14:00 GMT 24 October, list of prohibited materiel, visit and search, force only on refusal or in self-defence
  7. Wikipedia (EN) blockade as physical interdiction distinct from sanctions or embargo, restriction of neutral trading rights, contraband inspection
  8. Wikipedia (EN) pacific blockade by great powers against weak states without war, term of Hautefeuille, 1827 Greece and 1837 New Granada precedents, Declaration of Paris 1856 requirement of effectiveness
  9. Wikipedia (EN) Roosevelt's Chicago speech of 5 October 1937 calling for a quarantine against the epidemic of world lawlessness
  10. opiniojuris.org Peter Spiro on Abram Chayes, State Department Legal Adviser in 1962: quarantine controversial at the time, Quincy Wright thought it clearly illegal, self-defence rationale considered and rejected, OAS authorisation central, legal justification matters
  11. csis.org CSIS China Power Project (2024): quarantine as a law-enforcement-led operation below the threshold of armed conflict, blockade as foremost military