Objective, relative and absolute truth
객관적 진리와 상대적·절대적 진리
The dialectical-materialist theory of truth, on which truth has a content independent of human consciousness (objective truth), the knowledge of any moment is incomplete and revisable (relative truth), and within that knowledge an unshakable content accumulates (absolute truth). Engels outlined it in Anti-Dühring against Dühring's "final truths", and Lenin bound the three concepts together in Materialism and Empirio-criticism against Bogdanov's relativism. It seeks to avoid both dogmatism and relativism, and it became a standard item in Soviet philosophy textbooks.
In depth
What difficulty is this theory meant to solve?
Old science textbooks taught that atoms cannot be split. Today they do not. So was the old science simply wrong, will today's be wrong too, and is truth just the consensus of an age? Conversely, if science is reliable, must what we now know be right forever? Both answers look off.
The three terms here are Marxism's answer to the difficulty. Knowledge changes, but that does not make it unrelated to the world. The old atomism was partly wrong, yet it held the content that matter comes in small units, and that content survived in the new theory. The three concepts are distinguished to make this picture exact.
What does each term mean?
Objective truth means that the content of knowledge does not depend on the mind or the consensus of the knower. The earth goes round the sun whether people believe it or not. Lenin made this the test of materialism: "To be a materialist is to acknowledge objective truth, which is revealed to us by the sense organs."
Быть материалистом значит признавать объективную истину, открываемую нам органами чувств.
Relative truth does not mean wrong. It means that the knowledge of a given moment represents the world correctly only within a certain range and to a certain accuracy. Absolute truth is used in two senses. Narrowly it means facts that will not later be overturned; broadly it means the complete knowledge of the world that is endlessly approached, which no individual and no generation can possess.
How did Engels illustrate it?
Engels's target was Eugen Dühring, who claimed "final and ultimate truths" even on questions of society and morals. Part One, Chapter 9 of Anti-Dühring resolves the question of whether human thought is unlimited. "The sovereignty of thought is realized in a series of extremely unsovereignly thinking people", and knowledge with an unconditional claim to truth is realized in a series of relative errors. Across the endless succession of human generations knowledge has no limit it cannot pass, while the knowledge of any one person or age is limited.
die Souveränetät des Denkens verwirklicht sich in einer Reihe höchst unsouverän denkender Menschen
Engels granted that eternal truths exist, but mocked them as commonplaces, like the fact that Napoleon died on 5 May 1821. His example at the level of serious theory is Boyle's law, by which at constant temperature the volume of a gas is inversely proportional to the pressure. Regnault found that the law did not hold in certain cases. To throw it out as false would have been a greater error: the law has true content within a certain range, and that range had been established more exactly. So, he wrote, the distinction of truth and error too has absolute validity only in a very limited field.
Wahrheit und Irrtum, wie alle sich in polaren Gegensätzen bewegenden Denkbestimmungen, haben absolute Gültigkeit eben nur für ein äußerst beschränktes Gebiet
What did Lenin dispute with Bogdanov?
In Empiriomonism Bogdanov treated truth as a form of socially organized experience. Truth changes with the age and there are no eternal truths, he argued, and that was consistent Marxism. Lenin replied that this, in granting relativity, threw out the objectivity of truth too. The relevant section of Materialism and Empirio-criticism separates three levels of judgment.
"The limits of approximation of our knowledge to objective, absolute truth are historically conditional, but the existence of such truth is unconditional, and the fact that we are approaching it is also unconditional."
исторически условны пределы приближения наших знаний к объективной, абсолютной истине, но безусловно существование этой истины, безусловно то, что мы приближаемся к ней.
Using the image of a picture, Lenin says its contours are historically conditional, while it is unconditional that the picture depicts an objectively existing model. The sentence supporting this arrangement is: "Human thought, then, by its nature is capable of giving, and does give, absolute truth, which is compounded of a sum-total of relative truths."
Итак, человеческое мышление по природе своей способно давать и дает нам абсолютную истину, которая складывается из суммы относительных истин.
Lenin also clearly distinguished this from relativism. Dialectics, as Hegel already explained, contains an element of relativism, negation and scepticism, he wrote, but does not reduce to relativism. We grant the relativity of knowledge, that is, not in the sense of denying objective truth but in the sense that the limits of knowledge's approach to truth are historically conditioned.
Where is the theory weak?
The first weak point is the word "sum". Lenin wrote that each stage of science adds "new grains" to the sum of absolute truth. Thomas Kuhn, against the idea of science developing by accumulation of facts and theories, spoke of revolutionary ruptures and held that Newtonian mass and Einsteinian mass cannot be treated as the same. This opposes the picture of grains piling up.
The second is how we know. The claim that objective truth exists is a different matter from a method for telling whether this proposition now is such truth. Lenin fills the gap with practice (see "Criterion of practice"), while admitting that the criterion is indefinite enough to keep human knowledge from hardening into the absolute.
The third is its fate in practice. Stalin's 1938 essay stated that knowledge "tested by experiment and practice" has the significance of objective truth. According to one assessment of Soviet philosophy, the conception initiated by Lenin and completed by Stalin measured the validity of knowledge by its compatibility with the laws of dialectics and transferred the philosophical interpretation of science to the jurisdiction of political authority. The system's list of evidence for materialism came to include the Michurinist biology of Lysenkoism.