治安維持法 · 1925.04.22–1945.10.15

Peace Preservation Law

치안유지법

Japanese thought-control law enacted in 1925 as Law No. 46. It punished with up to ten years of penal servitude or imprisonment anyone who organised or knowingly joined an association aiming to alter the national polity (kokutai) or to deny the system of private property. It was extended by imperial ordinance to Korea, Taiwan and Sakhalin. In Korea it was applied not only to the communist movement but to the independence movement as a whole, and the first organisation prosecuted under it was the Communist Party of Korea. An amendment of 1928 raised the maximum penalty to death, and the law was abolished in October 1945.

In depth

Why was it made?

After the Russian Revolution of 1917 the Japanese government saw the spread of communist ideas as a threat and from 1920 began work on new security legislation. A bill to control radical social movements, put to the Diet in 1922, would have punished even "propaganda"; it met opposition and lapsed, and an emergency ordinance issued after the Great Kantō Earthquake of 1923 filled the gap. After diplomatic relations with the Soviet Union were opened in January 1925 the legislation was taken up again.

The law was promulgated on 22 April 1925 and came into force on 12 May. It is usually explained as the counterpart of the universal manhood suffrage law of the same year, meant to contain the growth of political movements that a wider franchise would bring, and so is likened to "the carrot and the whip". Article 1 read:

Anyone who has organised an association with the object of altering the national polity or of denying the system of private property, or who has joined such an association with full knowledge of its object, shall be liable to penal servitude or imprisonment for a term not exceeding ten years.

Articles 2 to 5 punished those who conferred about or incited such acts or supplied money for them, and article 7 extended the law to acts committed abroad. Because it used the vague term kokutai ("national polity"), any political opposition could be branded as altering the kokutai.

How was it tightened?

After the March 15 incident of 1928 the Tanaka Giichi cabinet introduced an amendment; when the Diet failed to finish deliberating on it, the cabinet forced it through by emergency ordinance on 29 June. "Altering the national polity" was separated from "denying the system of private property", and those who organised or led an association aiming at the former could now be sentenced to death. A new clause punished with two years or more anyone who, without joining, committed "acts to further the aims of the association". This offence was later used widely against people who were not party members.

In 1936 the Thought Criminals Protection and Surveillance Law put those released under watch as well. In 1941 the law was wholly rewritten in 65 articles, in force from 15 May. It banned even associations "preparing" to form an association, required defence counsel to be chosen from lawyers designated in advance by the Minister of Justice, and added preventive detention, under which a person who had served a sentence could be kept in custody if judged clearly likely to offend again.

To enforce the law, special higher police sections (the Tokkō) and "thought prosecutors" were assigned to political cases. By about 1933 obtaining tenkō, rather than judicial punishment, had become the main means of enforcement.

Against whom was it used in Japan?

On 15 March 1928 some 1,600 members and supporters of the Japanese Communist Party were arrested at once on suspicion of violating the law (the March 15 incident). After the left-wing movement was broken in the early 1930s the targets widened: new religions, starting with Ōmoto in 1935; the Kōza-ha scholars in the Com-Academy incident of 1936; the Rōnō-ha, which had no connection with the Communist Party, in the Popular Front incidents of 1937 and 1938; and magazine editors in the Yokohama incident of 1942. From 1925 to 1945 over 70,000 people were arrested, but only about one in ten reached trial. In Japan proper no one was sentenced to death for violating this law alone; one explanation is that the authorities judged it more effective, in weakening the movement as a whole, to make people convert and leave it than to kill them. Even so, 194 are said to have died from torture and ill-treatment and 1,503 of illness in prison.

How was it used in Korea?

The law was extended to Korea by imperial ordinance. The Government-General of Korea and its courts held that aiming at Korean independence was itself an attempt to alter the national polity, and used the law against the whole independence movement. Unlike in Japan proper, not only socialists but almost everyone involved in the independence movement was punished under it. In Korea the law is said to have been applied, and its articles read, more harshly than in Japan.

Korea was also where the law was first applied. The Communist Party of Korea was founded on 17 April 1925, about a month before the law took effect, and the four round-ups of the party between November 1925 and 1928 were carried out under it. Three of the members arrested in 1925 and 1926 died in prison or just after release on sick bail, the first victims of the law. In Japan proper its first application was the Kyoto Gakuren incident, from January 1926. Between 1926 and 1935, 17,621 people in Korea were arrested under the law and 5,075 were convicted. Among the Korean communists of Jiandao, Ju Hyeon-gap, of the Jiandao May 30 uprising of 1930, was sentenced to death for violating this law alone, something that never happened in Japan proper. In December 1936 a separate Korean Thought Criminals Protection and Surveillance Ordinance was promulgated.

Koreans in Japan were caught by the law too. The Korean newspaper Daejung Sinmun in Tokyo put out an extra at the time of the March 15 incident calling for opposition to the Peace Preservation Law and for a joint struggle of Korean and Japanese proletarians. Kim Du-yong, who led the Tokyo branch of KAPF, was arrested under the law in 1930.

How was it used in Taiwan?

In Taiwan too the law took effect by imperial ordinance. The Taiwanese Communist Party, which stood for Taiwan's independence, was an illegal party in the eyes of the Government-General; between 1931 and 1933, 107 of its members were arrested and sentenced to prison terms of up to fifteen years, and a few died in prison. Xie Xuehong, who had led the party, was also arrested under the law and held for more than ten years.

How did it end, and what did it leave?

After Japan's defeat the government meant to go on using the law, and on 26 September 1945 the philosopher Kiyoshi Miki, imprisoned under it, died in jail. On 4 October the Allied headquarters demanded its repeal in the civil liberties directive, and the law was abolished on 15 October. Kyūichi Tokuda and other Japanese Communist leaders held in preventive detention, and Koreans such as Kim Chon-hae, were released at this time.

The law went but its frame remained. South Korea's National Security Act is said to have taken it as its model, and critics hold that the Social Security Act continued the Korean probation ordinance. In Japan the Subversive Activities Prevention Act of 1952 was attacked as a revival of the Peace Preservation Law.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. encykorea.aks.ac.kr
  2. ja.wikipedia.org
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. ja.wikipedia.org
  5. Wikipedia (KO)
  6. encykorea.aks.ac.kr
  7. ja.wikipedia.org
  8. zh.wikipedia.org
  9. Wikipedia (EN)
  10. ja.wikipedia.org
  11. ja.wikipedia.org