Philosophie der neuen Musik · 1949

Philosophy of New Music

신음악의 철학

A book on the philosophy of music that Theodor W. Adorno wrote in American exile and published in Tübingen in 1949. It sets Arnold Schoenberg and Igor Stravinsky against each other as the two extremes of twentieth-century composition and reads Schoenberg's side as "progress" and Stravinsky's as "restoration". Adorno called the book an extended excursus to Dialectic of Enlightenment, and Thomas Mann drew on the manuscript while writing his novel Doctor Faustus.

In depth

Why is a book about music a book of philosophy?

When a television drama today lays down a 1980s synthesizer sound, we recognise at once that it sounds "dated". There is nothing wrong with the sound itself, so why does it sound old? Theodor W. Adorno drew a whole philosophy of music out of this question. The notes, chords, rhythms and forms a composer works with are not natural raw materials but a historical sediment, worked over and refined by those who came before. He defined musical "material" as

sedimentierter Geist, ein gesellschaftlich, durchs Bewusstsein von Menschen hindurch Präformiertes

"sedimented spirit, something preformed socially, through the consciousness of human beings." A composer's struggle with the material is therefore a struggle with society. The material even issues instructions to the composer: sounds, techniques and forms worn out by overuse go onto a "canon of the forbidden" that a serious composer can no longer use. In Adorno's terms, the 1980s synthesizer sounds dated because it has been worn down in too many commodities.

Philosophy of New Music applies this idea to twentieth-century music. Part one, "Schoenberg and Progress", was written in 1940–41; part two, "Stravinsky and Restoration", in 1947. An early version of part one was never published and circulated only inside the Institute for Social Research, which had moved to New York. The book appeared in 1949 from J. C. B. Mohr in Tübingen, Adorno's first book published in Germany after the fall of Nazism. In the preface he called it an "extended excursus" to Dialectic of Enlightenment: it tests in music that book's idea that reason, in mastering nature, turns into a new form of domination. A Korean translation exists.

Why did modern music become hard to listen to?

The introduction poses this question. Once film and radio began using music as background accompaniment, music as a whole sank into kitsch. Because music is abstract, it at first resisted the culture industry better than the other arts, but technical developments broke that defence too. In Adorno's view, only avant-garde works that critically question the musical tradition could still resist. Modern music renounced every aesthetic convention and became deliberately difficult as a way of escaping the commercialised music business.

The diagnosis also explains why familiar, comfortable sounds are a problem. Adorno held that using the pleasant and familiar major-minor tonality in composition today can no longer bear true witness to historical reality. Forms inherited from Romanticism likewise create an illusion of harmony between subject and object that history has made impossible. The most truthful work, he argued, is the fragmented one in which the conflict between form and the historically and socially derived material comes into view.

What did Schoenberg do, and why is it "progress"?

Arnold Schoenberg moved first to "atonal" music that abandoned tonality and then to "twelve-tone technique". The technique fixes an order (a row) in which each of the twelve notes of the octave is used once, then builds the whole piece from that row played backwards, upside down or both. It is a device to prevent any note from becoming a centre.

Adorno saw this as a total rationalisation of musical material: just as painting passed from representation to abstraction, music had to pass from tonality to atonality. But his judgement does not end in praise. The composer turns to twelve-tone technique to recover subjective expression, yet the constraints of the system can make the result meaningless. Adorno set humanity's domination of nature beside composition's domination of its material. A dissonant interval such as the minor second once defined a melody and gave it meaning; under twelve-tone rules intervals are partly predetermined and lose their shock. Once rules are accepted without being confronted with the concrete shape of the material, they lose their significance.

The musicologist Carl Dahlhaus summed up both sides: Adorno regarded twelve-tone technique as the necessary consequence of the ever denser thematic working from Beethoven through Brahms to Schoenberg, and at the same time saw in it a systemic compulsion that hollowed music out. For Adorno it remained "an open dialectic". He still saw it as the way forward for contemporary music, and held that Schoenberg's late works and Alban Berg's opera Lulu overcame its rigidity and reached subjective expression. In his 1961 Darmstadt lecture "Vers une musique informelle" he recast twelve-tone technique as a necessary stage on the way past tonality to a liberated music.

Why is Stravinsky "restoration"?

Adorno thought Schoenberg and Stravinsky shared the aim of restoring authenticity to new music; they differed in method. Stravinsky sought authenticity by going back to old forms, to the primitive and the ritual. For Adorno the result was a meaningless ritual of strictly applied external structure in which the subject is erased. He read the same in the subject matter: in Petrushka, the tragedy of a puppet, and in The Rite of Spring, with its pagan sacrifice, the individual dissolves into the crowd.

His judgement of the music itself was the same. Stravinsky's pieces repeat instead of developing; they are "mechanical" and "spatialised", knowing neither memory nor continuity in time. Adorno called Stravinsky "technically reactionary" and named Paul Hindemith as his neoclassical counterpart; neoclassicism in general was to him "a decoction of music that has already been".

Some scholars warn that reading the book simply as pro-Schoenberg and anti-Stravinsky oversimplifies it. Recent work points to an asymmetry: Adorno analysed Schoenberg musicologically but Stravinsky largely psychologically. It has also been argued that making Stravinsky the outstanding representative of the position opposite to Schoenberg's was itself a mark of high respect for his compositional skill.

How was it entangled with Thomas Mann's Doctor Faustus?

When Adorno followed the Institute to Los Angeles in 1941, the neighbourhood was home to exiles such as Thomas Mann, Arnold Schoenberg, Hanns Eisler and Bertolt Brecht. In 1943 Mann, writing Doctor Faustus, a novel about the composer Adrian Leverkühn who makes a pact with the devil, asked for help with the music, and Adorno handed him the unpublished manuscript of Philosophy of New Music. That September Mann invited him home and read him chapter eight; the objections and suggestions Adorno made, first orally and then in writing, were largely taken into the early chapters.

The musical theory the devil expounds in the novel's central "devil chapter" is taken almost word for word from Adorno's book, with his permission. Mann called Adorno his "real privy councillor" and thanked him by setting the word "Wiesengrund" (Adorno's original surname) under the theme of the second movement of Beethoven's piano sonata op. 111 in the novel. Mann himself called the idea that the devil resembles Adorno "quite absurd".

The collaboration also caused a quarrel. In the novel Leverkühn "invents" twelve-tone technique without knowing Schoenberg. Schoenberg felt hurt, spied upon and deceived, protested publicly, and the two men exchanged polemics from 1948 to 1950. From the second edition Mann added a note at the end acknowledging that the technique was Schoenberg's, but the relationship never recovered. That Mann had worked with Adorno of all people made it worse: Adorno was Schoenberg's most ardent champion, yet Schoenberg found his style mannered and his concepts so obscure that they harmed new music.

How was it received?

The book was controversial from the start. The first review was Joachim Kaiser's "Music and Catastrophe" in the Frankfurter Hefte in 1951. The portrayal of Stravinsky drew particular criticism, and Schoenberg's private letters show that he too disliked the book. Adorno tried to clear up misunderstandings in an article in the music journal Melos in 1950, which was included in the 1975 collected edition.

Later judgements are divided. The pianist and critic Charles Rosen called it "largely a fraudulent presentation, a work of polemic that pretends to be an objective study", and the musicologist Richard Taruskin called Adorno "preposterously overrated". Albrecht Wellmer argued that Adorno's fixation on the German-Austrian tradition left him unable to deal with the other lines of new music represented by Debussy, Bartók, Stravinsky and Charles Ives. The philosopher Günter Figal, on the other hand, saw the book as the first attempt to test the basic idea of Dialectic of Enlightenment comprehensively in the philosophy of art. Concepts that first appear here, such as the artwork's "truth content", are developed fully in his late Aesthetic Theory.

Related people

Sources

  1. de.wikipedia.org
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. de.wikipedia.org
  4. de.wikipedia.org
  5. Wikipedia (EN)
  6. de.wikipedia.org
  7. de.wikipedia.org
  8. Wikipedia (EN)
  9. de.wikipedia.org