人民戦線事件 · 1937.12.15–1938.02.01

Popular Front Incident (Japan, 1937–1938)

인민전선 사건 (1937~1938)

The arrest under the Peace Preservation Law, on 15 December 1937 and 1 February 1938, of 484 people of the Japan Proletarian Party, the National Council of Trade Unions of Japan (Zenpyō), the Rōnō faction and a group of university professors, on the charge that they had tried to form a popular front in response to the Comintern's anti-fascist united front policy. It marked the extension of arrests, until then confined to the Communist Party, to the legal left and social democrats unconnected with the Comintern. Most of the professors were acquitted; Kanju Kato, Hitoshi Yamakawa and others were convicted but were discharged in 1945 when the Peace Preservation Law was abolished.

In depth

What was the background?

The seventh congress of the Comintern, held in Moscow in July 1935, changed course: communists were to join with the social-democratic forces they had treated as enemies and build an anti-fascist united front. In 1936 popular front governments took office in Spain and France and drew the world's attention. That February Sanzo Nosaka and Yamamoto Kenzō, in Moscow, wrote under pseudonyms a "Letter to the Communists of Japan" announcing the change of line, and it was smuggled into Japan by way of the United States.

But the organisation of the Japanese Communist Party had already been destroyed by repression. The anti-fascist unity movement in Japan was in fact led by the Rōnō faction, which had opposed the Comintern. It was a group centred on the journal Rōnō, the side that contended with the Kōza faction in the debate on Japanese capitalism. Kanju Kato founded the National Council of Trade Unions of Japan (Zenpyō) in 1934, and in January 1936 formed the Labour-Farmer Proletarian Council with a number of unions. That council became the Japan Proletarian Party in February 1937, with Kato as chairman, Mosaburō Suzuki as general secretary and, it is said, 7,046 members. Their slogans were "eradicate fascism" and "unite the proletarian political front", but unity failed against the opposition of the right, including the Social Masses Party. After the Sino-Japanese War began in July 1937 the Japan Proletarian Party continued its work, issuing among other things a directive on relief for the families of soldiers sent to the front.

The Japanese Wikipedia also cites the police's own situation. With the Communist organisation destroyed, the Special Higher Police and the thought prosecutors had almost no one left to arrest, and when their budgets and staff were cut in 1935–1936 they looked for new targets to defend their organisations. In July 1936 scholars of the Kōza faction were arrested (the Com-Academy Incident).

How did it unfold?

On the morning of 15 December 1937 the police arrested at once, in 18 prefectures, officers of the Japan Proletarian Party, Zenpyō and the National Farmers' Union, together with scholars and critics (the first wave). Among them were the Diet members Kanju Kato and Kuroda Hisao, and Hitoshi Yamakawa, Kanson Arahata, Mosaburō Suzuki, Tsunao Inomata, Itsuro Sakisaka, Ōmori Yoshitarō and Minoru Takano. On 22 December the Japan Proletarian Party and Zenpyō were banned. On 1 February 1938 a further 38 people were arrested in 9 prefectures (the second wave). Because they included professors of the Rōnō faction, among them Ōuchi Hyōe and Arisawa Hiromi of Tokyo Imperial University, Ryōkichi Minobe of Hosei University and Kōzō Uno of Tōhoku Imperial University, this wave is also called the Professors' Group Incident.

In all 484 people were arrested: 265 connected with the Japan Proletarian Party, 174 with Zenpyō, 34 of the Rōnō group and 11 of the professors' group. The Social Masses Party expelled those involved, and the scholars and critics were in effect all driven out of the universities and the press.

How was the law applied?

Article 1 of the Peace Preservation Law punished forming or joining an association that aimed to "alter the national polity" (kokutai), or acting to further that aim. The Rōnō faction was a loose group, not an association; its activity lay within the law; and the anti-fascist movement did not aim to alter the national polity. Even examining judges said the law did not fit. The thought prosecutors treated the Comintern, outside the country, as an association aiming to alter the national polity, and widened the interpretation so that a suspect could be punished once any awareness of the Comintern was established. The handbook "The Rōnō Faction and the Japan Proletarian Party", written by the Supreme Court prosecutor Ikeda Katsu, repeated the argument that such activity "in the end" and "ultimately" served communism. The grounds the authorities gave for the arrests were that the Rōnō faction was a twin born of the Japanese Communist Party and that the Japan Proletarian Party and Zenpyō had responded to the line of the Comintern's seventh congress.

The strain showed at trial. The prosecution could not prove the facts against the professors' group, and most were finally acquitted on appeal. Kato, Suzuki and Yamakawa were convicted at first instance and on appeal (Yamakawa to three years on appeal), but after Japan's defeat the Peace Preservation Law was abolished and they were discharged in November 1945. The thought prosecutors, dissatisfied with the acquittals, pressed on with the revision of the Peace Preservation Law.

How did it differ from other united fronts in East Asia?

The line of the same Comintern congress led to organisation in several parts of East Asia. The Chinese Communist Party appealed for unity against Japan in its August 1 Declaration of 1935, and Korean communists in Manchuria founded the Joguk Gwangbokhoe (Association for the Restoration of the Fatherland) in June 1936. In Japan, a legal left that had opposed the Comintern was suppressed on the mere charge of having formed a popular front. The Encyclopedia Nipponica writes that the incident showed that, once the Sino-Japanese War had begun, anti-war and anti-fascist activity could no longer be carried on legally.

The number arrested in the first wave differs between sources: 446, 417 or about 400. The Japanese Wikipedia gives 466, which does not agree with the total of 484.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. ja.wikipedia.org
  2. kotobank.jp
  3. ja.wikipedia.org
  4. ja.wikipedia.org
  5. Wikipedia (KO)