Postmodernism, or, the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism · 1984–1991

Postmodernism, or, the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism

포스트모더니즘, 혹은 후기자본주의 문화 논리

The essay the American Marxist critic Fredric Jameson published in New Left Review 146 in 1984, and the book of the same title (1991) that opens with it. Jameson treated postmodernism not as one style among others but as the "cultural dominant" of capitalism's third stage as described by Ernest Mandel, multinational late capitalism. He named its marks as depthlessness, pastiche, the weakening of historicity and a new kind of space in which people lose their way, and proposed "cognitive mapping", picturing one's own place in this world system, as the task of a counter-culture.

In depth

How do Van Gogh's shoes differ from Warhol's?

Jameson opens the essay with two paintings. One is Vincent van Gogh's pair of worn peasant shoes. Looking at these muddy, battered shoes we picture the person who wore them to till the field, the whole world of poverty and toil. The philosopher Martin Heidegger wrote that the painting calls back the earth and the peasant's world, and Jameson too reads the object in the painting as re-creating the lost context of life around it. Beneath the surface of the painting lies a deeper reality to which the painting points.

The other is Andy Warhol's Diamond Dust Shoes. Women's shoes scattered as in a shop display are printed flat like a photographic negative, with gold dust glittering on the surface. According to Jameson this painting does not speak to us as Van Gogh's shoes do. There is no life behind it to bring back and no place made for the viewer. The first feature he draws from the contrast is "depthlessness", superficiality in the literal sense. The second is "the waning of affect". Where Edvard Munch's The Scream gave form to modern anxiety, alienation and solitude bursting outward, Warhol's figures and objects lack such an inner life, and a giddy, decorative excitement fills its place.

Jameson did not take this to be one painter's taste. Around the end of the 1950s or the early 1960s high modernism, abstract expressionism, existentialism and the films of the great auteurs, was exhausted, and Warhol and pop art, John Cage, Thomas Pynchon and a new kind of commercial film appeared together. The change was most visible in architecture. Postmodern architecture attacked the international style of Le Corbusier and Mies van der Rohe as the work of imperious masters and came forward as an aesthetic populism, with Robert Venturi's Learning from Las Vegas as its manifesto. The old frontier between high culture and mass or commercial culture was effaced: the forms and materials of the "culture industry" that Adorno and the Frankfurt School had denounced now entered the substance of the work. The architectural current and the other uses of the word are treated under "Postmodernism".

Why a "cultural dominant" rather than a style?

Jameson's most important decision was to treat postmodernism not as a style but as the dominant cultural logic of a period.

it seems to me essential to grasp postmodernism not as a style but rather as a cultural dominant

A dominant does not mean that everything in the period is postmodern. Very different elements coexist, but one logic governs the rest. Jameson therefore granted the objection that writers such as Gertrude Stein or Marcel Duchamp showed postmodern features long before, and answered that what had changed was the social position of those features. Modernism, which had once enraged its bourgeois public, had by the late 1950s become the classics of universities and museums, and the next generation faced it as a set of dead classics. The provocations of postmodern works no longer scandalise anyone and have become the official culture of Western society.

The framework of this periodisation came from Ernest Mandel's Late Capitalism (1972). Mandel divided capitalism into three stages, market capitalism, monopoly capitalism or the stage of imperialism, and post-war late capitalism, and tied each to a technological revolution: the machine production of steam-driven motors, of electric and combustion motors, and of electronic and nuclear-powered apparatuses. Jameson paired the three stages with three cultural logics: realism, modernism and postmodernism. He rejected theories such as Daniel Bell's "post-industrial society", which held that the new society no longer obeyed the laws of industrial production and class struggle, and singled out Mandel as the rare Marxist who showed it to be, if anything, a purer stage of capitalism than any before. Aesthetic production had been integrated into commodity production generally, so that the economic pressure to turn out ever newer-seeming goods made aesthetic innovation a structural necessity. In the same passage Jameson wrote that this global, yet American, postmodern culture is the superstructural expression of a new wave of American military and economic domination, and that the underside of culture is blood, torture, death and terror. The economic theory is treated under "Late capitalism" and "Long-wave theory".

How does pastiche differ from parody?

The modernists each had a recognisable personal style. Parody imitates such a style in order to mock it, and to mock you need to believe that some normal speech exists outside the voice you are imitating. Jameson argued that once the personal style itself disappeared and society broke up into private languages that no longer communicate, parody lost its vocation and pastiche took its place. Pastiche too imitates another's style, but as a neutral mimicry without satirical intent or laughter.

Pastiche is thus blank parody, a statue with blind eyeballs

Cultural producers who can no longer invent a new style turn to the past, imitate dead styles and speak through the masks and voices stored in the imaginary museum of a now global culture.

His leading example was the "nostalgia film". George Lucas's American Graffiti (1973) set out to recapture the America of the Eisenhower 1950s, and Roman Polanski's Chinatown recreated the American 1930s as style. Lawrence Kasdan's Body Heat moved the 1940s noir Double Indemnity to present-day Florida while removing the signs of the present from the screen, so that the whole film floats outside time, both the 1930s and now. What such films show is not the past itself but our pop images and stereotypes of the past. The nostalgia Jameson meant is not the modernist ache for a lost time but the consumption of past "styles" as fashion.

Why does historicity weaken?

Pastiche and the nostalgia film are symptoms of a larger change. Jameson saw postmodern culture as suffering a "crisis of historicity": there no longer seemed to be any organic relationship between the history learned from schoolbooks and the lived experience of the multinational, high-rise, stagflated city. Paradoxically this culture is gripped by a bad "historicism", an indiscriminate appetite for the styles of every period, but that is a caricature of historical thinking rather than the thing itself. Jameson read E. L. Doctorow's novel Ragtime as depicting America in the early twentieth century through our ideas and stereotypes of that period rather than as a representation of historical fact.

Individual experience of time changes as well. Borrowing the psychoanalyst Jacques Lacan's account of schizophrenia, Jameson argued that once the chain of signifiers breaks, past, present and future can no longer be joined as in a sentence, and what remains is a series of pure and unrelated presents. This is a metaphor, not a clinical diagnosis. He read this "schizophrenic" structure of time in works made of disconnected fragments, such as John Cage's music, in which a cluster of sounds on the prepared piano is followed by an almost intolerable silence.

What does it mean to get lost in the Bonaventure Hotel?

The building Jameson analysed at greatest length was the Westin Bonaventure Hotel (1976), built in downtown Los Angeles in 1974–1977 by the architect and developer John Portman. It has three entrances, none of which opens onto the street like the front door of an older hotel. The outer walls are covered in mirror glass, so that from outside one sees not the hotel but only distorted images of the city around it. Inside, glass elevators and escalators rise and fall through an enormous atrium, and among four symmetrical towers and the balconies guests lose their bearings. Jameson noted that, ever since the hotel opened in 1977, the shopkeepers on the balconies had faced the notorious problem that nobody could find their stores.

Jameson called this experience "hyperspace". The object, the building, has mutated, but the perceptual equipment of the subjects who enter it is still formed by the space of high modernism and has not kept pace. The body's disorientation in the hotel lobby then becomes an analogy for a larger dilemma: our minds cannot yet map the great global multinational and decentred communicational network in which we are caught as individual subjects.

What is cognitive mapping?

As an answer to this dilemma Jameson proposed an aesthetic of "cognitive mapping". The term comes from the urban planner Kevin Lynch's The Image of the City (1960). Lynch studied the downtowns of Boston, Jersey City and Los Angeles through interviews and questionnaires in which residents drew their city from memory. He argued that in a city like Jersey City, with no monuments, boundaries or clear nodes, people cannot map in their minds either where they are or what the city as a whole looks like, and that this is alienation in the city.

Jameson extended this to society as a whole. There is a wide gap between what an individual experiences every day and the global class structure and flows of capital that actually determine that experience. Jameson saw a convergence here between Lynch's urban studies and Louis Althusser's redefinition of ideology as "the representation of the subject's Imaginary relationship to his or her Real conditions of existence". People live by picturing their situation in some way. The political culture Jameson called for would help them redraw that picture to fit the global totality. He admitted that he did not yet know what this new aesthetic would be, but insisted that it could not be a return to older realist representation; it would have to be a new mode of representation suited to today's space. He treated the matter as one of dialectical understanding rather than moral condemnation, asking us to think the cultural evolution of late capitalism dialectically, "as catastrophe and progress all together".

How was the essay received, and where did it lead?

The 1984 essay quickly became the centre of the debate on postmodernism. The book published by Duke University Press in 1991 placed it as the first chapter and added chapters on theory, video, architecture, the novel, space and economics and a long conclusion. The Korean edition is translated by Im Gyeong-gyu. When Jameson died in 2024 he was widely recognised as the pre-eminent critic of postmodernism.

Objections soon followed. In "Urban Renaissance and the Spirit of Postmodernism" in New Left Review 151 (1985), the American urban historian Mike Davis wrote that the new downtown centres were vivariums for the upper middle classes protected by complex security systems, and that the Bonaventure's vast mirrored surfaces reflected away both the misery of the city outside and its vibrancy. The charge was that Jameson was too indulgent towards this redevelopment. Jameson quoted the passage in the book and replied that capital comes first and the cultural style follows. The geographer David Harvey accepted Jameson's thesis in The Condition of Postmodernity (1989) but tried to give it empirical support through the change in the regime of capital accumulation from Fordism to flexible accumulation. The other Marxist assessments of postmodernism, those of Habermas, Eagleton, Callinicos and Anderson, are treated together under "Postmodernism".

Related people

Sources

  1. archive.org
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. Marxists Internet Archive
  4. Wikipedia (EN)
  5. Wikipedia (EN)
  6. aladin.co.kr
  7. pages.gseis.ucla.edu