savoir-pouvoir / pouvoir-savoir · 1975–present

Power/knowledge

권력/지식

A concept Michel Foucault put forward in the 1970s, above all in Discipline and Punish (1975): the idea that power and knowledge presuppose and produce each other. For Foucault there is no power relation without a correlative field of knowledge, and no knowledge that does not presuppose and at the same time constitute power relations. The modern disciplines, in which procedures for finding people out, such as examination, diagnosis and record-keeping, are at once procedures for governing them, are the standard example. Unlike "knowledge is power", which treats knowledge as an instrument of power, or the theory of ruling-class ideology, it treated power not as something anyone owns but as relations spread throughout society, and so met both adoption and criticism from Marxism and critical theory.

In depth

What question does it answer?

Suppose you sit an exam at school. The exam is a procedure for finding out what a student knows. Yet the same exam ranks students, leaves a record on the report card, and decides which class and which school they go to. Students change their own study habits to do well. Here, are the school's "knowing" the student and "governing" the student two things, or one?

Michel Foucault held they are one. As the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy summarises, the examination both elicits the truth about those who undergo it and controls their behaviour. The same goes for the hospital check-up, the factory's work record and the army's roll call. The procedure that finds people out is the procedure that governs them, and in governing, new knowledge piles up. Foucault called this interlocking power/knowledge (savoir-pouvoir).

He wrote: "There is no power relation without the correlative constitution of a field of knowledge, nor any knowledge that does not presuppose and constitute at the same time power relations."

Il n'y a pas de relations de pouvoir sans constitution corrélative d'un champ de savoir, ni de savoir qui ne suppose et ne constitue en même temps des relations de pouvoir

What did Discipline and Punish say?

Discipline and Punish asks why, from the late eighteenth century, Western punishment moved from torturing or publicly executing offenders to the "gentler" method of locking them up. Foucault saw the change as partly the result of humanitarian reform but at the same time as a vehicle of more effective control: not to punish less, but to punish better. The book grew out of his work with the Prison Information Group (GIP), which he founded with colleagues in 1971 to make prisoners' voices heard.

For Foucault the modern prison was the model of a "discipline" that spread through the whole of society. Factories, hospitals and schools were organised the same way. Discipline works by three techniques: hierarchical observation places people where they can be seen and watches them; normalising judgment measures them against norms and seeks to correct their shortfalls; and the examination joins the two. The examination turns the individual into a "case", in both senses: an example for science and an object of care and management.

Jeremy Bentham's circular prison design, the Panopticon, was the architectural model of this power. The guard in the central tower can see every cell, but the inmates cannot see the guard. Not knowing when they are watched, inmates behave as if always watched. Control comes less from chains than from a mind that polices itself.

Records mattered too. Once only kings and heroes had their names set down in chronicles. In modernity the lives of ordinary people became objects of observation and record. Foucault wrote: "This turning of real lives into writing is no longer a procedure of heroisation; it functions as a procedure of objectification and subjection."

Cette mise en écriture des existences réelles n’est plus une procédure d’héroïsation ; elle fonctionne comme procédure d’objectivation et d’assujettissement.

How does it differ from "knowledge is power"?

Since Francis Bacon, "knowledge is power" has treated knowledge as an instrument of power. As an engineer who knows nature can make it work, knowledge comes first and power uses it. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy notes that Foucault's view of the relation is far closer than this engineering model. In Bacon's model the two exist independently, but at least in the study of human beings Foucault held that the goals of power and of knowledge cannot be separated: in knowing we control, and in controlling we know.

So in Foucault's phrase the hyphen or slash joining the two words is the core. It does not say that knowledge serves power, nor that power distorts knowledge. Foucault wrote: "It is not the activity of the knowing subject that would produce a knowledge useful or resistant to power, but power-knowledge, the processes and struggles that traverse it and of which it is made up, that determines the forms and possible domains of knowledge."

ce n’est pas l’activité du sujet de connaissance qui produirait un savoir, utile ou rétif au pouvoir, mais le pouvoir-savoir, les processus et les luttes qui le traversent et dont il est constitué, qui déterminent les formes et les domaines possibles de la connaissance

This presupposes another picture of power. As English Wikipedia summarises, Foucault held that power cannot be fully described as the set of institutions that make citizens obey the state (the liberal definition), as yielding to rules (the psychoanalytic definition), or as a system in which one class or group oppresses another (the typical feminist or orthodox Marxist definition). Power is not a thing someone holds; it arises from large and small relations of force throughout society, and it produces rather than merely forbids. His critique of the repressive hypothesis about discourse on sex and his analysis of biopower, the power that manages life, stand on the same picture. Later he widened the question under the name "governmentality".

How did Marxism take it up and criticise it?

Encouraged by his teacher Althusser at the École Normale Supérieure, Foucault joined the French Communist Party in 1950, left in 1953, and never accepted core Marxist tenets such as class struggle. His analysis of power deliberately kept its distance from Marxist theories of power that start from the state and the ruling class. Where Marxism explains dominant ideas as the expression of ruling-class interest, as ideology, Foucault asked less whose interest knowledge serves than by what procedures knowledge makes people into objects and governs them.

That does not mean Marxists ignored him. The Greek Marxist theorist of the state Nicos Poulantzas wrestled with Foucault directly in his last book, State, Power, Socialism (1978). As English Wikipedia summarises, he took over Foucault's relational concept of power, his analysis of the disciplines and the idea of the state as a strategic terrain, while rejecting Foucault's neglect of class and of the state's repressive role. The way discipline in prisons and factories broke in workers overlapped a great deal with Marxist studies of capitalist labour discipline.

There was also criticism over norms. Jürgen Habermas called Foucault's thinking "crypto-normativist": it reduces every truth claim to an effect of power yet in fact relies on Enlightenment norms such as freedom and justice. Nancy Fraser likewise argued that in criticising traditional moral systems Foucault denied himself recourse to concepts like freedom and justice and so could not offer alternatives. In a 1971 televised debate with Noam Chomsky, Foucault rejected any fixed human nature or universal ground for justice. If power is everywhere, in the name of what does one resist? The question has stayed with Foucault's readers.

Where did it lead?

The idea of power/knowledge spread across the humanities and social sciences. English Wikipedia notes that Edward Said's Orientalism (1978) relied on it to explain the discursive formation of colonialism: the West's "knowing" the East and its dominating the East were interlocked. Gayatri Spivak, in "Can the Subaltern Speak?", pushed the question further by criticising Foucault himself for failing to see the epistemic violence of imperialism. In feminist and queer theory Judith Butler used Foucault's theories of the relation between subject, power and sex to question gendered subjects.

In his 1990 "Postscript on the Societies of Control" Gilles Deleuze argued that society was moving from discipline to control. Now that information and data have become central to knowledge and power, power/knowledge raises new questions. English Wikipedia cites a 2019 study finding that an image search for "beauty" in many languages returns mostly pictures of young white women, pointing out that what a search algorithm shows decides what becomes known.

Related people

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN)
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. fr.wikipedia.org
  4. fr.wikipedia.org
  5. plato.stanford.edu
  6. Wikipedia (EN)
  7. Wikipedia (EN)
  8. Wikipedia (EN)
  9. de.wikipedia.org
  10. fr.wikipedia.org