Profintern September Theses (1930)
프로핀테른 9월 테제
The "Theses on the Tasks of the Revolutionary Trade Union Movement in Korea," drawn up on 18 September 1930 by the executive committee of the Profintern (Red International of Labour Unions) on the basis of the decisions of its Fifth Congress in August that year, and commonly called the September Theses. Together with the Comintern's December Theses of 1928, and on the diagnosis that the Communist Party of Korea had been dominated by petty-bourgeois intellectuals, they became the basic directive of the Korean communist movement of the 1930s: help revolutionary workers and peasants form their own vanguard. With the so-called October Letter of the Pan-Pacific Trade Union Secretariat they guided the mass rebuilding of the party on the workers and peasants and the revolutionary trade union movement.
In depth
When the September Theses appeared, the Communist Party of Korea stood dissolved by the Comintern's decision of December 1928, and the Great Depression of 1929 was transforming the situation. On the basis of the December Theses, the September Theses and the "October Letter" that the Pan-Pacific Trade Union Secretariat sent to its supporters in Korea, the Comintern directed a mass movement to rebuild the party on the workers and peasants.
What the theses took issue with was the leadership of the Korean labour movement. Since the Wonsan General Strike of 1929 the workers' struggles had been sharpening, but the Korean General Federation of Labour, under a reformist leadership, could not lead the struggles that were breaking out spontaneously, and the workers had no revolutionary trade unions of their own. Supporters of the Profintern were therefore to gather the left inside the existing unions, win the leadership and reorganise them as revolutionary industrial unions, and to found new unions on the industrial principle where none existed. The theses ran to eight sections and seventeen items.
The revolutionary union they proposed was rooted at the point of production, in factories and mines; it was led by advanced workers and free of the influence of petty-bourgeois national reformists; and it was organised by industry on the basis of factory committees elected by all the workers. It was to represent the demands of women and youth, link the movement of the unemployed with that of factory workers, and combine legal activity such as night schools and workers' clubs with illegal activity. It was also to practise proletarian internationalism by uniting with Chinese and Japanese workers. The theses did not call for the immediate rebuilding of the party; the mass base was to be laid first in revolutionary trade unions and peasant unions. In the words of the Korean translation, the left "must organise and mobilise the mass of workers in the struggle against Japanese imperialism, in the struggle for the agrarian revolution, and in the struggle for a thorough improvement of the condition of the working class in Korea".
Towards the nationalists the theses were far sharper than the December Theses. They held that the national-reformist bourgeoisie of Korea, bought by Japan's promise of self-government, was acting as a breakwater against the revolution, and they classed the Dong-A Ilbo, the Chosun Ilbo, Cheondogyo and the Singanhoe as national-reformist bodies that had sabotaged the students' school strikes and the workers' demonstrations. This gave weight to the case for dissolving the Singanhoe, which was dissolved in 1931.
The September Theses were not a document for Korea alone but one branch of a line the Profintern was handing down to many countries at the time: forming a revolutionary opposition inside reformist unions or setting up separate red unions. In Japan the Profintern's Fourth Congress of 1928 recommended the merger of the Japanese Trade Union Council and the General Federation of Korean Labour in Japan, and in 1930 the Korean unions in Japan were accordingly dissolved into the National Council of Japanese Trade Unions (Zenkyo), which the Japanese Communist Party led. Inside Korea the revolutionary union movement was guided by the Profintern and by the Pan-Pacific Trade Union Secretariat in Shanghai, and was also linked with the work committee of the Chinese Communist Party and with the Zenkyo current in Japan. In its October Letter of October 1931 the secretariat took up the September Theses and again stressed the liquidation of factional struggle and the building of unions from below.
Communists who took up this directive chose to go into the factories and villages and build revolutionary trade unions and peasant unions first, rather than put forward the faction organisations that had led the party before. Kwon Dae-hyeong and others, for example, formed the League for the Reconstruction of the Communist Party of Korea at Yeongdeungpo in 1931 and dissolved it themselves two months later on the ground that it risked stirring up factional strife, defining their immediate task as building left-wing workers' and peasants' unions. In Hungnam, Hamhung and Wonsan in South Hamgyong, activists sent by the Pan-Pacific Trade Union Secretariat built unions in the nitrogen fertilizer plant and other works and were arrested one after another (the Pacific Trade Union incidents), and in Seoul the group around Yi Jae-yu organised industrial unions and led strikes.
Judgments differ. The New History of Korea holds that this policy, which rejected every labour body left in the legal sphere as reformist or centrist, reflected the leftward deviation of the international labour movement of the day and harmed the labour movement until the popular front tactic overcame it in the later 1930s. On the other hand some organisations grew out of the movement. The Wonsan Left Committee of Red Trade Unions, formed in Wonsan by Yi Ju-ha and others, took up the united front line of the Seventh Congress of the Comintern and, until the arrests of 1938, produced many revolutionary workers in key industries such as the railways, chemicals and metals.