Science wars
과학 전쟁
A series of scholarly and public disputes in the 1990s, mainly in the United States, over the social place of science in making authoritative claims about the world. Scientific realists accused humanities and social science scholars whom they called "postmodernist" of effectively rejecting scientific objectivity and method; the other side dismissed the charges as ill-informed and self-serving. The dispute drew wide public attention in 1996 with the Sokal affair, in which the physicist Alan Sokal got a nonsense article published in the cultural studies journal Social Text.
In depth
Does the humanities' study of science attack science?
A physicist measures the mass of the electron in a laboratory. A sociologist goes into that laboratory and observes how the physicists negotiate, win grants and write papers. If the sociologist writes that "this fact was made in the social process of the laboratory", does that mean the mass of the electron is invented? Or does it only explain how a fact comes to be accepted? In 1990s America, scientists and scholars in the humanities and social sciences clashed fiercely over this question. The clash is called the science wars.
The science wars were a series of scholarly and public discussions in the 1990s over the social place of science in making authoritative claims about the world. They took place principally in the United States, in the academic and mainstream press. Scientific realists such as Norman Levitt, Paul R. Gross, Jean Bricmont and Alan Sokal accused many writers, whom they described as "postmodernist", of having effectively rejected scientific objectivity, the scientific method, empiricism and scientific knowledge. They implicated cultural studies, feminist studies, comparative literature, media studies and especially science and technology studies, which studies science itself.
The physicist N. David Mermin understood the science wars as a series of exchanges between scientists and "sociologists, historians and literary critics". The scientists thought the others ludicrously ignorant of science and given to nonsensical pronouncements; the other side dismissed these charges as naive, ill-informed and self-serving. The sociologist Harry Collins wrote that the science wars began in the early 1990s with attacks by natural scientists or ex-natural scientists who had assumed the role of spokespersons for science, and that the target was the analysis of science coming out of literary studies and the social sciences.
What was the background?
Until the mid-twentieth century the philosophy of science had concentrated on the viability of scientific method and knowledge, proposing justifications for the truth of scientific theories and observations. Then the publication of Thomas Kuhn's The Structure of Scientific Revolutions in 1962 fully opened the study of science to new disciplines. Kuhn held that the evolution of science was in part socially determined and did not operate under the simple logical laws put forward by the logical positivists. He described the development of scientific knowledge not as a linear increase in truth but as a series of periodic revolutions that overturned the old order and replaced it with new ones, which he called "paradigms".
Some read Kuhn to mean that scientific theories were, wholly or in part, social constructs, and many took this as diminishing science's claim to represent objective reality. In the 1970s the "strong programme" of the British sociology of scientific knowledge proposed explaining successful and failed scientific theories by the same kinds of social cause. A number of schools grouped together as "postmodernism" began reinterpreting past scientific achievements in relation to politics and economics, gender, sexual orientation, race and class. More radical philosophers such as Paul Feyerabend argued that scientific theories were themselves incoherent and that other forms of knowledge production, such as those of religion, met their practitioners' needs with equal validity.
What did Higher Superstition target?
In 1994 the biologist Paul R. Gross and the mathematician Norman Levitt published Higher Superstition: The Academic Left and Its Quarrels with Science. They accused postmodernists of anti-intellectualism and set out the shortcomings of relativism. On their account postmodernists knew little about the scientific theories they criticised and practised poor scholarship for political reasons; the "science critics" offered "caricature, misreading, and condescension" rather than argument. Their topics included social constructivism, the strong programme, the science criticism of Stanley Aronowitz, Bruno Latour and Andrew Ross, feminist science criticism and environmentalist science criticism. Levitt said he was a leftist trying to save the "academic left" from itself.
The book sparked the science wars. Gross, Levitt and Gerald Holton organised a New York Academy of Sciences conference titled The Flight from Science and Reason. Attendees were critical of Gross and Levitt's polemical approach, yet agreed on the intellectual inconsistency with which laymen, non-scientists and social studies intellectuals dealt with science.
What happened in Social Text's "Science Wars" issue?
In 1996 Social Text, a left-wing Duke University publication of postmodern critical theory, compiled a "Science Wars" issue; the term "science wars" itself was coined for that issue. Postmodernist academics in the social sciences and humanities contributed brief articles emphasising the roles of society and politics in science. In his introduction the editor, the activist Andrew Ross, said that the attack on science studies was a conservative reaction to reduced funding for scientific research. The sociologist Dorothy Nelkin, pointing out that the end of the Cold War had cut military funding and left research directed by private interests, called postmodernist critics "convenient scapegoats" who diverted attention from problems in science.
The issue also carried an article by Alan Sokal, a physics professor at New York University: "Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity". It proposed that quantum gravity is a social and linguistic construct. One passage reads:
"physical 'reality', no less than social 'reality', is at bottom a social and linguistic construct"
physical “reality”, no less than social “reality”, is at bottom a social and linguistic construct
The journal did not practise peer review at the time, so it did not send the article to a physicist for review. Three weeks after publication, in May 1996, Sokal revealed in the magazine Lingua Franca, in "A Physicist Experiments With Cultural Studies", that the article was a hoax. He had tested, he said, whether a leading North American journal of cultural studies would publish an article liberally salted with nonsense if it sounded good and flattered the editors' ideological preconceptions. The editors of Social Text had liked his article because they liked its conclusion, and had felt no need to analyse the quality of the evidence or even the relevance of the arguments to the conclusion. The matter became known as the Sokal affair and brought the science wars to a far wider public.
Why did Sokal attack the left in the name of the left?
Sokal declared that he was a leftist too. Under the Sandinista government he had taught mathematics at the National University of Nicaragua, and on nearly all practical political issues he was on the same side as the Social Text editors. What angered him was that most of this silliness came from the self-proclaimed Left.
"For most of the past two centuries, the Left has been identified with science and against obscurantism"
For most of the past two centuries, the Left has been identified with science and against obscurantism
He wrote that he had believed rational thought and the fearless analysis of objective reality, both natural and social, to be incisive tools against the mystifications promoted by the powerful. The turn of many "progressive" or "leftist" humanists and social scientists to epistemic relativism, he argued, betrayed this heritage and undermined the prospects for progressive social critique. Theorising about "the social construction of reality", he said, would not help find an effective treatment for AIDS or devise strategies for preventing global warming.
The Social Text editors replied that they had asked Sokal to cut much of the philosophical speculation and most of the footnotes, and that he had refused. They defended the lack of peer review on the ground that Social Text was a journal of open intellectual inquiry and that the article had not been offered as a contribution to physics. The affair set off controversy over the scholarly merit of commentary on the physical sciences by humanists, over the influence of postmodern philosophy on the social disciplines, and over academic ethics, including whether Sokal was wrong to deceive the editors and readers.
What were Fashionable Nonsense and Derrida's reply?
In 1997 Sokal and the Belgian physicist Jean Bricmont published Impostures intellectuelles in French; the English edition, Fashionable Nonsense, followed in 1998. They criticised postmodern writing for misusing scientific and mathematical concepts. They also criticised the strong programme, associating it with the broader concept of social constructionism.
Jacques Derrida, a frequent target of anti-relativist and anti-postmodern criticism after Sokal's article, replied in "Sokal and Bricmont Aren't Serious", first published in Le Monde. He called Sokal's action sad (triste), because it overshadowed Sokal's mathematical work and ruined the chance to sort out controversies over scientific objectivity carefully. He also charged the two authors with intellectual bad faith: they had accused him of scientific incompetence in the English edition of their book but deleted the accusation from the French edition and denied it had ever existed. Sokal, he concluded, was not serious, and had used the spectacle of a "quick practical joke" to displace the scholarship the public deserved.
How did the science wars end?
In the first few years after the Social Text issue the seriousness and volume of discussion grew, much of it aimed at reconciling the warring camps. The "Science and Its Critics" conference in early 1997 featured Sokal and Steve Fuller as keynote speakers. The same year Collins organised the Southampton Peace Workshop, which gave rise to The One Culture? (2001), edited by the chemist Jay A. Labinger and Collins, with contributions from Sokal, Bricmont, Steven Weinberg and Steven Shapin among others. Yet both sides continued to hold that the other did not understand their theories, and the science wars have been judged to have had little effect on either the scientific community or the community of critical theorists.
In time there was self-criticism on the critical-theory side as well. As late as 1999 Bruno Latour protested that scientists wanted to impose the gag that only scientists should speak about science. But in 2004, writing about global warming, he observed that dangerous extremists were using the very same argument of social construction to destroy hard-won evidence that could save lives. And he asked:
"Was I wrong to participate in the invention of this field known as science studies?"
Was I wrong to participate in the invention of this field known as science studies?
Reviewing Sokal's Beyond the Hoax (2008), Mermin cited the 2008 election of Latour to Foreign Honorary Membership of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences as a sign that the science wars were over: we are, he wrote, beyond not only Sokal's hoax but the science wars themselves.