Situated knowledges
상황적 지식
A concept the American historian of science and feminist theorist Donna Haraway put forward in her 1988 essay "Situated Knowledges": the idea that all knowledge is a partial view from a particular body and a particular social and historical place, and that objectivity comes from accounting responsibly for exactly that fact. Haraway called the traditional objectivity that seems to look down on everything while standing nowhere the "god trick", and saw relativism, in which every view is equally right, as the same trick. Written as a commentary on Sandra Harding's standpoint theory, it stays close to standpoint theory while stressing many partial views that connect with one another instead of a single privileged standpoint.
In depth
What question does it answer?
The satellite view in a map app looks as if it showed the world from anywhere in the sky. Yet the picture was taken by a particular satellite at a particular angle and time, and chosen and processed by some company for some purpose. Even what looks like a "view from nowhere" is in fact a view from somewhere. So what is the objectivity science speaks of? An eye standing nowhere is impossible; but must we then say every view is equally right?
Donna Haraway answered: neither. As German Wikipedia summarises, "situated knowledges" means that knowledge must always be understood within specific social and historical locations, and the idea opposes epistemological relativism as much as an objectivism that presupposes complete neutrality. Haraway first used the term in her 1988 essay "Situated Knowledges: The Science Question in Feminism and the Privilege of Partial Perspective".
Why did she reject the "god trick"?
Haraway called the traditional objectivity that claims to look down on everything at a glance, without body or place, the "god trick". Such a gaze was in fact a way for particular people, usually people in powerful positions, to present their own view as universal.
But Haraway saw the relativism on the other side as the same trick. Saying all views are equally valid amounts to refusing responsibility anywhere, no different from claiming to see from everywhere at once. Her sentence, as quoted in a review article in Frontiers, runs: "Relativism and totalization are both 'god-tricks' promising vision from everywhere and nowhere equally and fully."
Relativism and totalization are both ‘god-tricks’ promising vision from everywhere and nowhere equally and fully
Where, then, does objectivity come from?
Haraway's answer is the metaphor of the eye. The "eyes" of science, such as microscopes, cameras and telescopes, do not passively mirror the world. They are active devices built to see in particular ways. Haraway held that the eyes of our bodies are the same. Every view comes from somewhere embodied. Objectivity comes not from hiding this fact but from making clear where one sees from and through what, and taking responsibility for that view. As English Wikipedia quotes, understanding situated knowledge "allows us to become answerable for what we learn how to see".
So Haraway wrote: "The only way to find a larger vision is to be somewhere in particular." Partial views can connect and converse with one another, and that connection makes wider knowledge. But Haraway added that not just any partial view will do: it must be critically trained and open to views from places that cannot be known in advance.
The only way to find a larger vision is to be somewhere in particular.
How does it differ from standpoint theory?
"Situated Knowledges" was originally written as a commentary on Sandra Harding's The Science Question in Feminism (1986), and was heavily influenced by conversations with Nancy Hartsock and other feminist philosophers and activists. So the two share a great deal. Both criticise the objectivity of a science that claims value neutrality, both hold that knowledge is socially situated, and both seek to redefine objectivity rather than abandon it.
The difference lies in their attitude to oppressed positions. Standpoint theory, which grew out of Marxism, holds that knowledge starting from oppressed positions, those of workers or women, is better. Haraway valued the views of the oppressed but held that they too must not be romanticised or fixed into a single privileged standpoint. In "A Cyborg Manifesto", published in Socialist Review in 1985, she had already written: "my complaint about socialist/Marxian standpoints is their unintended erasure of polyvocal, unassimilable, radical difference made visible in anti-colonial discourse and practice."
my complaint about socialist/Marxian standpoints is their unintended erasure of polyvocal, unassimilable, radical difference made visible in anti-colonial discourse and practice
That does not mean Haraway broke with Marxism. The original title of "A Cyborg Manifesto" spoke of "Science, Technology, and Socialist Feminism in the 1980s", and she sought to build a political myth faithful to feminism, socialism and materialism.
Where is it used, and how has it been criticised?
Situated knowledges is used most in science and technology studies and feminist theory, and has spread to gender studies and postcolonial studies. Understanding knowledge as situated brings power relations and epistemic violence into view as well.
There are criticisms too. German Wikipedia notes that assuming each group shares one view can simplify identities; that focusing on individual locations makes it easy to overlook structural factors such as social inequality; and that, good as it is in theory, it offers no concrete framework for what to do in actual research.