Petition Movement for the Establishment of a Taiwanese Parliament
대만의회 설치 청원운동
The political movement in which Taiwanese petitioned the Imperial Diet fifteen times between 1921 and 1934 for an autonomous parliament in Taiwan. Begun by the New People's Society in Tokyo, it turned from the campaign to repeal Law 63 to a demand that the Government-General's legislative power be handed to an elected Taiwanese parliament, after Lin Cheng-lu argued that repeal would only accept the policy of treating Taiwan as an extension of Japan. The first petition, headed by Lin Hsien-tang and signed by 178 people, went in on 30 January 1921; the movement voted to stop on 2 September 1934. It marked the turn from armed resistance to modern political action and was the longest and largest political movement of Japanese rule.
In depth
The Petition Movement for the Establishment of a Taiwanese Parliament was a movement in which the intellectuals of colonial Taiwan knocked at the door of the metropolitan parliament. Year after year they submitted to the Imperial Diet in Tokyo a petition asking that the legislative power held by the Governor-General and the right to examine the budget be handed to an assembly elected by the inhabitants of Taiwan. It used only the means the law allowed, but because it demanded that Taiwan be treated as a unit distinct from Japan, the Government-General of Taiwan regarded it as a national movement and suppressed it. Liberal Diet members, Christians and scholars in Japan helped from alongside, and within Taiwan the Taiwanese Cultural Association and the Taiwanese People's Party (1927) collected the signatures.
The movement grew out of Tokyo at the end of the 1910s. In Japan the campaign for universal suffrage was at its height, and in 1919 the March First Movement broke out in Korea and the May Fourth Movement in China. In this current of national self-determination, Taiwanese students formed the Keihatsukai (Enlightenment Society) at the end of 1918 and its successor, the Shinminkai (New People's Society), in January 1920. Their first goal was the repeal of Law No. 63, the basis of the Governor-General's autocracy. When Governor-General Den Kenjirō said in November 1920 that Taiwan had not yet reached the stage at which the law could be given up, more than 200 members of the Shinminkai demonstrated in Tokyo. But Lin Cheng-lu, a graduate of Meiji University, pointed out that repealing Law No. 63 and simply receiving the laws of Japan proper meant denying Taiwan's particularity, and proposed a special representative body for Taiwan. Tsai Pei-huo, who thought full self-government out of reach, put forward the plan of an elected assembly, and at the end of 1920 Lin Hsien-tang's decision changed the goal.
The first petition made four points: Taiwan's conditions are different and require special legislation; Taiwan, ruled by a constitutional state, should enjoy constitutional government; the Governor-General's holding of both legislative and executive power is contrary to the spirit of the constitution; special legislation and the examination of the budget for Taiwan should be done by a Taiwanese parliament. In March 1921 the first petition was "not adopted" by both the House of Peers and the House of Representatives, but it met a warm response in Taiwan, and Chiang Wei-shui held a welcome meeting in Taipei for Lin Hsien-tang's party on its return. Men such as Koo Hsien-jung, a member of the Government-General's Advisory Council, opposed it on the ground that one state could not have two parliaments. The Government-General began to apply pressure in August 1922, and Lin Hsien-tang, with a bank calling in his debts and those around him urging him to stop, gave up heading the list of signatures for the third petition.
When the petitioners formed a League for the Establishment of a Taiwanese Parliament while preparing the third petition, Governor-General Den Kenjirō banned it on grounds of public order. The mass searches, arrests and prosecutions of 16 December 1923 are known as the Public Order Police Law Incident; Chiang Wei-shui and Tsai Pei-huo were each sentenced to four months.
The trial had an unexpected result. Kiyose Ichirō and the other defence lawyers argued that the movement did nothing against the constitution, and Suehiro Izutarō, a professor of Tokyo Imperial University, wrote in its support in the Taiwan Minpao. The Diet members who introduced the first petition were Ebara Soroku in the House of Peers and Tagawa Daikichirō in the House of Representatives. Both belonged to the church of the pastor Uemura Masahisa, where Tsai Pei-huo had been baptised, and Tagawa acted as introducing member for as long as he held a seat. Yanaihara Tadao, a professor of Tokyo Imperial University, studied Taiwan in the spring of 1927 and in 1929 published Taiwan under Imperialism, which supplied the movement with arguments. The number of signatories reached its peak of 2,470 with the eighth petition.
Meanwhile the demand was lowered. The first idea had been a special colonial parliament with legislative and budgetary power over Taiwan; faced with the objection that the only parliament the constitution knew was the House of Peers and the House of Representatives, the explanatory statement attached to the fifth petition in 1924 retreated as follows.
The petitioners do not ask that a parliament with full legislative power be set up in Taiwan. Their intention is only to obtain the right to examine the budget of Taiwan's administrative expenditure and the right to take part in examining local regulations in accordance with Taiwan's particular conditions and customs; in short, its powers would be no more than those of a local assembly in Japan proper.
When the Taiwanese Cultural Association passed into the hands of the left in 1927, the movement split. The Taiwanese People's Party, founded by those who had left the association, carried on the petitions, while the new Cultural Association issued a statement at the time of the ninth petition calling the movement an obstacle to Taiwan's liberation. At the welcome meeting in Tokyo, too, left-wing students jeered. In August 1930 the right wing around Lin Hsien-tang and Tsai Pei-huo set up the separate Taiwan Alliance for Local Self-Government. When the People's Party was banned in February 1931 and Chiang Wei-shui died in August, the movement lost the organisations that had carried it.
The movement then won support in Japanese opinion and among Taiwanese, but the Diet never accepted a petition. It ended in 1934, the year before the Government-General's 1935 local reform made half of the members of prefectural, city, town and village councils elective. On 2 September 1934 Lin Hsien-tang and twenty-eight others issued a statement suspending it. It was a time when liberalism and national self-determination, the foundations of the movement, were being pushed aside by fascism. The Diet never adopted a petition, but the movement was the frame within which the different currents of Taiwan came together, so much so that the records of the Government-General's police call its first six years the "age of the united front".