Третий период · 1928–1935

Third Period

제3기 노선

The assessment of the world situation, and the line that followed from it, formalised by the Comintern at its Sixth World Congress in 1928 (1928–1934). It took the revolutionary upsurge after 1917 as the First Period and the relative stabilisation of capitalism in the mid-1920s as the Second, and held that a "Third Period" of economic collapse and working-class radicalisation had begun. Accordingly it attacked social democracy as "social fascism", rejected cooperation with its leaders in a "class against class" tactic, and set out to build communist-led revolutionary unions outside the reformist ones. It was reconsidered after the Nazis took power and replaced by the Popular Front line at the Seventh Congress in 1935.

In depth

The three periods

The term "Third Period" is closely associated with Stalin, but it was first coined by Bukharin at the Seventh Plenum of the Comintern Executive in 1926. He argued that the struggle for markets would intensify pressure to cut production costs through Taylorism, longer shifts and wage cuts, and that the resulting fall in living standards would sharpen class struggle and increase support for communism. The periodisation set the tactics of the communist parties: the Second Period (1923–1928) had been characterised by the workers' united front with social-democratic parties to defend wages, jobs and workers' rights, while the Third Period reversed this in favour of "class against class" (1928–1934). The line was instituted at the Ninth Plenum of the Executive in February 1928 and formalised at the Sixth Congress that summer.

What the line meant

The Sixth Congress theses said that social democracy had entered a more "mature" period from the standpoint of imperialism and that the struggle against this "bourgeois workers' party" had to be sharpened; they shifted the centre of gravity of the united front to the united front from below. The Tenth Plenum of the Executive in July 1929 formally confirmed the theory of social fascism, under which social democracy was a mere variant of fascism and any united front with social-democratic parties inadmissible. In the trade unions the parties built communist-controlled dual unions instead of working within the existing ones, and they also organised the unemployed into a political force. Within the movement, social democrats and moderate socialists, Trotskyists and supporters of the united front were attacked and expelled. In the same years the "Right" opposition to collectivisation and dekulakisation was pushed aside within the Soviet party, and the Comintern served as the transmission belt of this line abroad.

In Germany

The KPD adopted the theory of social fascism at its Twelfth Congress in June 1929 and cited the Blutmai in Berlin shortly before as proof that social democracy had turned into social fascism. In 1931 it joined the right-wing parties and the Nazis in backing the referendum, launched by the Stahlhelm, to dissolve the Prussian Landtag against Otto Braun's Social Democratic government. Even after the Nazis took power in 1933 and destroyed both workers' parties, the KPD declared in May that year that the Social Democrats remained "the main social prop of the dictatorship of capital".

Turn and assessment

The annihilation of the German communist movement shocked the Comintern into reassessing Third Period tactics. In 1934 the French SFIO, PCF and CGT formed a pact of joint action, and in 1935 the Seventh Congress dropped the theory of social fascism and made the Popular Front the official line. Trotskyists blame the line for helping Hitler to power by preventing unity between the German workers' parties. In the United States and elsewhere, on the other hand, communist membership and influence grew during these years of the Depression, and historians such as Robin D. G. Kelley praise the struggles of communist activists in local histories; critics reply that such histories gloss over the horrors of Stalinism and the destructive results of the Third Period's sectarianism and adventurism.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN) (supports the Comintern concept, its 1928 adoption, class-against-class tactics, social-fascism line, and 1935 Popular Front reversal)
  2. Wikipedia (RU) (supports the Sixth Comintern Congress decisions in 1928 and the Seventh Congress turn in 1935)
  3. Marxists Internet Archive (Comintern document archive supporting the primary-source context and chronology of the period)
  4. Wikipedia (EN)
  5. archive.org
  6. de.wikipedia.org
  7. de.wikipedia.org