The Communist Party of Korea and the Singanhoe
How did a secret communist party that was broken up again and again help build the largest legal national organisation in colonial Korea, and why did it take that organisation apart four years later?
Founded in secret in Seoul in April 1925, the Communist Party of Korea was destroyed by 1928 in four round-ups under the Peace Preservation Law. In those years the socialists, announcing in the Jeongwuhoe Declaration their readiness to ally with nationalists, joined in founding the Singanhoe in February 1927. After the Comintern's December Theses of 1928 the line changed, and the Singanhoe was dissolved at its general congress in May 1931.
Under what conditions was the Communist Party of Korea founded?
After the March First Movement of 1919 the Government-General of Korea turned to what it called cultural rule, allowing some newspapers and associations. In that opening youth, labour and peasant organisations appeared and socialist ideas, under the influence of the Russian Revolution, spread. Socialists built open study societies alongside secret organisations, and several groups competed: the Tuesday faction around the Tuesday Society, the Seoul faction that came out of the Seoul Youth Association, the North Wind faction of former students in Japan, and the Shanghai faction linked to the Korean Communist Party in Shanghai. In April 1924 the Korean Youth Federation, uniting youth groups across the country, and the Korean Workers' and Peasants' Federation, uniting labour and peasant groups, were formed. 1 2
On the afternoon of 17 April 1925, 19 people met at the Chinese restaurant Aseowon in Hwanggeumjeong, Seoul, and founded the Communist Party of Korea. The founding was led by the Tuesday faction (Kim Jae-bong, Kim Chan, Pak Hon-yong, Cho Bong-am and others), joined by some members of the North Wind and Shanghai factions; the Seoul faction stayed out. Kim Jae-bong became the first responsible secretary. The next day the Koryo Communist Youth Association was formed at Pak Hon-yong's house, with Pak as responsible secretary and Kwon O-seol, Kim Dan-ya, Im Won-geun and Ju Se-juk among its officers. To be recognised as a section of the Comintern, the international organisation of communist parties with its headquarters in Moscow, the party sent Cho Dong-ho and Cho Bong-am to Moscow. 1 3
At the very time the party was born, Japan enacted the Peace Preservation Law. Promulgated on 22 April 1925 and in force from 12 May, it was extended to Korea by imperial ordinance. Article 1 punished with up to ten years of penal servitude or imprisonment anyone who organised, or knowingly joined, an association aiming to alter the national polity or to deny the system of private property. The Government-General and its courts held that seeking Korean independence was itself an attempt to alter the national polity. The first organisation to which the law was applied was the Communist Party of Korea, which from first to last could exist only as a secret body. 4 5 6
Why did the party collapse four times in three years?
In November 1925, seven months after the founding, an incident at Sinuiju set off arrests of party members across the country (the first Communist Party incident). Kim Jae-bong and other officers were taken, as were Pak Hon-yong and Im Won-geun of the youth association. The party passed to Kang Dal-yeong, who ran a newspaper branch office in Jinju. His leadership restored the local organisations and the overseas bureaux, but in June 1926 its plan for demonstrations was uncovered; in three months more than 3,000 people were arrested, over 130 of them party members (the second incident), which the National Institute of Korean History puts at 89 per cent of the membership. 1 7
Kim Cheol-su, who had escaped arrest, restored the party centre in September 1926. He merged the party with the Koryo Communist League, the secret organisation of the Seoul faction that had stayed outside it, and took in An Gwang-cheon and others from the Tokyo study society Irwolhoe. When An became responsible secretary at the Second Party Congress on 6 December, what came to be called the ML faction took over the leadership. Membership rose to 450 in these months. In February 1928, however, the police learned of a planned congress and arrested Kim Chun-yon, Kim Se-yon and 32 leading officers in all (the third incident). The remaining leaders held the Third Party Congress at the end of February and elected Cha Geum-bong, a worker who had been a locomotive fireman, as responsible secretary; arrests began again in July, and 175 people had been taken by 5 October (the fourth incident). Cha died in Seodaemun Prison the following March of the after-effects of torture. 1 8 9
Three reasons are given for the repeated collapse. The first is the Peace Preservation Law and the special higher police who handled political cases. The second is the party's composition: of the members arrested in the Communist Party incidents, 42.4 per cent were petty bourgeois (intellectuals, students, merchants) and 29 per cent had no occupation, while 11.6 per cent were workers and 13 per cent peasants. With shallow roots in factories and villages, the organisation clustered around the newspapers and study societies of Seoul, and one round-up exposed the whole. The third is factionalism: the Tuesday, Seoul, ML and Shanghai factions set up rival centres even after merging, and the Comintern warned in its resolution of December 1928 that Japanese spies entered the organisation by way of the factional struggle. 10 4 11
What did the June Tenth Movement leave behind?
When Sunjong, the last emperor of the Korean Empire, died in April 1926, the leadership of the Communist Party of Korea dropped its May Day plans and decided to raise demonstrations like those of 1 March 1919 on the day of the funeral, 10 June. Kwon O-seol, responsible secretary of the Koryo Communist Youth Association, was put in charge; the party allied with the old faction of Cheondogyo, and Kim Dan-ya in Shanghai wrote leaflets and sent them in. The plan collapsed when Kwon was arrested on 7 June. The demonstrations came instead from two groups that had prepared separately, college students and secondary-school students. With some 7,000 soldiers and sailors concentrated in Seoul by the Government-General, students shouted for independence and scattered leaflets as the bier passed along Jongno on the morning of 10 June. About 210 students were arrested in Seoul and about 1,000 across the country. 1 12 13 14
Accounts differ on who led the movement. Writing on the history of the Communist Party of Korea presents it as prepared by the party; writing on the June Tenth Movement itself calls it a movement that students planned and carried out on their own. Two things are clear. The party lost its second leadership over it. And the experience of socialists, the old faction of Cheondogyo and students all moving toward the same day widened the idea that nationalists and socialists could cooperate in a single organisation. One leaflet distributed at the time stated that in a colony national liberation is class liberation and political liberation is economic liberation. 1 12 15 16
Why did socialists and nationalists join hands in the Singanhoe?
In the mid-1920s the nationalist camp was divided. Choe Rin of the new faction of Cheondogyo and Kim Song-su and Song Jin-u of the Dong-A Ilbo, judging independence impossible, prepared a movement to win home rule under Japan. The Chosun Ilbo circle, the old faction of Cheondogyo and others opposed this as a compromise; they are usually called the uncompromising nationalists or the nationalist left. Events abroad also counted. In China the Kuomintang and the Communist Party were allied in the Northern Expedition, and in Japan the universal suffrage law of 1925 was turning socialists toward a legal party movement. 17 18
The socialists' answer was the Jeongwuhoe Declaration of 15 November 1926. The Jeongwuhoe was a study society formed by the merger of the Tuesday Society, the North Wind Society and two other groups, and the declaration was written by An Gwang-cheon and others who had just joined the Communist Party of Korea. It said that the movement had to pass from its confinement to economic struggle to political struggle, and that while clearly recognising the bourgeois-democratic character of the nationalist forces, socialists should acknowledge that they could be allies for a stage, ally with them actively so long as they did not appear in a degenerate form, and fight for the reformist interests of the masses as well. The same text added the proviso that compromise that stops at compromise and reform that stops at reform mean nothing but degeneration and surrender. In December the Second Congress of the Communist Party of Korea adopted the policy of forming a party of the national united front. 16 17 1
On 19 January 1927 promoters gathered from the Chosun Ilbo circle, the Protestant churches, the old faction of Cheondogyo and Buddhism, together with Kim Chun-yon and Han Wi-geon of the Communist Party of Korea. The name was at first Sinhanhoe; when the Government-General demanded that the character han (韓) be dropped, it became Singanhoe at Hong Myong-hui's suggestion. The founding congress, held on 15 February at the YMCA hall on Jongno, elected as president Yi Sang-jae, an elder active since the days of the Independence Club, and Hong Myong-hui as vice-president. The programme read: "1. We promote political and economic awakening. 1. We consolidate unity. 1. We reject all opportunism." Opportunism here meant the home-rule movement. Yi died just over a month later and was succeeded by Kwon Dong-jin of the old faction of Cheondogyo. On 27 May the two currents of the women's movement came together to found the sister organisation, the Geunuhoe, in which socialist women activists such as Ju Se-juk and Ho Jong-suk took part. 17 19 20 7 21
What did the Singanhoe do, and where was it blocked?
The Singanhoe grew quickly. Ten months after its founding, in December 1927, it celebrated its hundredth branch, and at its height the sources give between 120 and 150 branches and between 20,000 and 40,000 members. The branches were founded by local youth, labour and peasant activists, and newspaper branch offices often served as their premises. The Communist Party of Korea and the Koryo Communist Youth Association put their members into the branches, and the Korean Youth Federation, whose "new line" of 1927 widened the proletarian youth movement into an all-national one, became a base for them. What the branches did was enlightenment work (lectures, night schools, literacy, consumer cooperatives) and demands such as the protection of tenancy rights, opposition to the settlement of Japanese farmers and opposition to national discrimination in wages. 17 18 2 3
The headquarters, however, never produced concrete guidance for the branches. The Government-General banned the regular congresses of 1928 and 1929, and the Chosun Ilbo, as the price of having its suspension lifted, accepted the demand that its staff withdraw from the Singanhoe. On 28 June 1929 the Singanhoe held a congress of delegates each chosen by several branches together and elected the lawyer Ho Hon chair of the executive. Of the 78 new officers only five had been officers at the founding, and many socialists entered. 17
The year 1929 saw mass movements surge. From January to 6 April some 2,200 workers of the Wonsan Federation of Labour were on general strike in Wonsan. On 3 November a clash between Korean and Japanese students in Gwangju turned into anti-Japanese demonstrations, and by the following spring some 54,000 students of 194 schools across the country had joined demonstrations and school strikes. The Gwangju branch of the Singanhoe, the Korean Youth Federation and the Geunuhoe were involved in spreading them. The headquarters and Seoul branch of the Singanhoe planned a mass rally to publicise the facts on 13 December, but before dawn that day 44 members, Hong Myong-hui among them, were arrested and Ho Hon's executive fell (the mass rally incident). The executive then led by Kim Byong-ro, seeking to avoid repression, narrowed its activity to what was legal and pushed for group membership, which could admit even home-rule organisations. Membership actually rose to 39,000 in November 1930, but this "moderation" at the centre deepened the distrust of the branches. 22 23 24 25 17 26
What did the December Theses demand?
On 10 December 1928 the Political Secretariat of the Executive Committee of the Comintern adopted a resolution on the Korean question, usually called the December Theses. It applied to Korea the theses on the revolutionary movement in the colonies that the Sixth Congress of the Comintern had adopted that summer, drafted by Kuusinen. The Korean revolution, it said, was a bourgeois-democratic revolution that would overthrow Japanese imperialism and solve the land question, and its motive forces were the workers, the peasants and the urban petty bourgeoisie. The bulk of the bourgeoisie was "at best only a national-reformist opposition", and the big landowners stood with Japan. The experience of 1927 in China, where the Kuomintang massacred the communists, lay behind this judgement. 10 11
Its demands on the party were sharp. "The ranks of the Communist Party of Korea have in the past consisted almost exclusively of intellectuals and students. A Communist Party built on such foundations cannot be a consistently Bolshevik and organizationally sound Party." It called for an end to the factional struggle and for the party to be rebuilt among factory workers and poor peasants. Whether the resolution withdrew the party's recognition as a section of the Comintern is read differently by scholars. Kim In-dok holds that a decision on the organisational question a month earlier had withdrawn it; Yi Kyun-yong holds that the December Theses were neither a withdrawal of recognition nor an order to dissolve but guidelines for rebuilding the party. The New History of Korea concludes that the theses did not explicitly order dissolution but that many Korean socialists took them as in effect such an order. There is also the judgement that the demand was excessive in Korean conditions, where workers were few and factions unavoidable. 11 10 1
After the theses the communists set about rebuilding the party, faction by faction, under the slogan "to the masses". Kim Dan-ya entered Seoul in 1929 as plenipotentiary of the Comintern and formed an organising committee for the party; Han Wi-geon and others of the ML faction set up a rebuilding organisation in Shanghai and An Gwang-cheon another in Beijing. None survived the arrests. Relations with the nationalists changed as well. In September 1930 the September Theses of the Profintern (the Red International of Labour Unions) classed the Singanhoe, along with the Dong-A Ilbo, the Chosun Ilbo and Cheondogyo, as national-reformist. 10 1 13 27
Why was the Singanhoe dissolved, and how is that judged?
The call for dissolution was first made publicly by the Busan branch on 6 December 1930. Its advocates distinguished haeso ("dissolution into another form") from haeche (disbandment): in their words, it meant not the breaking up of an organisation but "the dialectical self-development by which a movement passes into another form of movement". They gave four grounds. The leadership had turned to compromise. The Singanhoe was a party-like body that people of several classes joined as individuals, and so it held back the independent struggle of workers and peasants. Its programme was abstract and it had no plan of action. And the world depression and Japan's intervention in Manchuria had changed the situation, making the working masses militant. The proposal, in short, was to take workers and peasants out of the Singanhoe, organise them in labour unions and peasant unions, and set up councils of those unions under class leadership. The Iwon branch, which voted to disband, wrote that the losses from cooperation were greater than the gains. 25 28 17
There was opposition. The Wonsan and Hamhung branches agreed with dissolution in principle but called it an abstract theory so long as the labour and peasant movements had not actually been built up. The nationalist An Jae-hong argued that in Korea the parallel cooperation of the two camps had to continue and attacked the theory as a "literal-translation internationalism" that borrowed its terms and arguments from the dissolution of the Japanese labour party. Among the socialists Im Won-geun too wrote against dissolution. The dispute was not settled. On 15 May 1931 the first and last general congress since the founding opened at the central YMCA hall in Seoul. On the second day, 16 May, with the police forbidding any debate, the motion to dissolve was carried on a show of hands by 43 votes to 3 with 30 abstentions. Members of KAPF, the Korean proletarian artists' federation, are reported to have steered the mood of the congress toward dissolution. 25 29
The other form of movement that the advocates of dissolution spoke of did not take the Singanhoe's place. All meetings were banned after the vote, and dissolution became disbandment. The Korean Youth Federation in effect dissolved in the same month, and the Geunuhoe, without ever formally deciding to dissolve, ceased to function as a national organisation. The socialists went into illegal union work in factories and villages. Judgements still differ. Critics of the dissolution hold that it threw away, with nothing to replace it, the organisation that had brought together the largest number of people in legal space, a heavy loss to the national movement; they point out that the socialists overrated the revolutionary temper of workers and peasants and failed to fit the Comintern line to Korean conditions. Those who seek to understand the case for dissolution point out that the moderation of Kim Byong-ro's executive and its attempt to admit home-rule groups had already undermined the Singanhoe's own programme, and that the failure of the headquarters to lead the branches' struggles was plain before the vote. The two accounts do not cancel each other. In the autumn of 1931, months after the dissolution, Japan invaded Manchuria, and the space for legal political movements inside Korea did not open again. 25 17 30 31 20
Consequences
The Communist Party of Korea was not re-established until 1945; the communists dispersed into separate party-rebuilding efforts and illegal union work in factories and villages. With the Singanhoe, the Korean Youth Federation and the Geunuhoe gone, no legal organisation uniting nationalists and socialists remained inside Korea. Whether the dissolution of the Singanhoe was unavoidable or a loss to the national movement is still disputed.
Timeline & Map
- 11925.04.17Founding of the Communist Party of Korea
Nineteen people met at the Aseowon restaurant in Seoul and founded the Communist Party of Korea; Kim Jae-bong became its first responsible secretary.
- 21925.04.18Founding of the Koryo Communist Youth Association
Twenty delegates met at Pak Hon-yong's house, formed the Koryo Communist Youth Association and elected Pak responsible secretary.
- 31925.05.12The Peace Preservation Law takes effect
Japan's Peace Preservation Law, promulgated on 22 April, came into force and was extended to Korea by imperial ordinance.
- 41925.11First Communist Party incident
After an incident at Sinuiju the police arrested party members across the country. Kim Jae-bong, Pak Hon-yong and others were taken, and the party passed to Kang Dal-yeong.
- 51926.06.10June Tenth Movement
Students shouted for independence and scattered leaflets as Emperor Sunjong's funeral procession passed along Jongno. Kwon O-seol had been arrested three days earlier, the party's plan collapsed and the second round-up followed.
- 61926.11.15Jeongwuhoe Declaration
The study society Jeongwuhoe declared for a turn from economic to political struggle and for alliance with nationalist forces. The text appeared in the Chosun Ilbo on 17 November.
- 71926.12.06Second Congress of the Communist Party of Korea
Thirteen delegates met secretly in a private house in Cheonyeon-dong, Seoul, and adopted the policy of forming a party of the national united front. An Gwang-cheon became responsible secretary and the ML faction took over the leadership.
- 81927.02.15Founding of the Singanhoe
The founding congress at the YMCA hall on Jongno elected Yi Sang-jae president and Hong Myong-hui vice-president and adopted a three-line programme.
- 91927.05.27Founding of the Geunuhoe
Women activists of the nationalist and socialist camps held the founding meeting of the Geunuhoe at the central YMCA hall on Jongno.
- 101928.02Third Communist Party incident
The police arrested Kim Chun-yon, Kim Se-yon and 32 leading officers of the ML faction in all. The remaining leaders opened the Third Party Congress on the night of 27 February and elected Cha Geum-bong responsible secretary.
- 111928.07–
10.05 Fourth Communist Party incidentMass arrests began in July, and 175 people had been taken by 5 October. Cha Geum-bong's leadership fell and the party organisation came to an end.
- 121928.12.10December Theses
The Political Secretariat of the Executive Committee of the Comintern adopted its resolution on the Korean question, directing that the faction-ridden party of intellectuals be replaced by one rebuilt among workers and peasants.
- 131929.01.13–
04.06 Wonsan general strikeSome 2,200 workers of the Wonsan Federation of Labour struck until 6 April. A dispute at an oil company's refinery grew into a general strike across the city.
- 141929.06.28Singanhoe congress of joint delegates
With regular congresses banned, a congress of delegates each chosen by several branches together elected Ho Hon chair of the executive.
- 151929.11.03Gwangju Student Movement
Korean students in Gwangju clashed with Japanese students and then marched through the streets. Demonstrations and school strikes spread across the country until the following spring.
- 161929.12.13Mass rally incident
Before dawn on the day the Singanhoe planned a mass rally about the Gwangju Student Movement, the police arrested 44 members, Hong Myong-hui among them, and Ho Hon's executive fell.
- 171930.09.18September Theses of the Profintern
The executive bureau of the Profintern adopted theses on the revolutionary trade union movement in Korea that classed the Singanhoe as a national-reformist organisation.
- 181931.05.16Dissolution of the Singanhoe
The general congress that had opened the day before passed the motion to dissolve by 43 votes to 3 with 30 abstentions, the police having forbidden debate.
Related people 25
Leadership14
Led the founding in 1925 and headed the youth association until he was arrested in the first round-up that November.
First responsible secretary of the Communist Party of KoreaKim Jae-bong1891–1944Became responsible secretary at the founding in April 1925 and was arrested in the first round-up that November.
A founder of the Communist Party of KoreaCho Bong-am1899–1959After leading the founding he was sent to the Comintern to seek recognition for the party and in 1926 organised its Manchurian General Bureau.
Officer of the Koryo Communist Youth Association; plenipotentiary of the CominternKim Dan-ya1901–1938Wrote leaflets for the June Tenth Movement in Shanghai and entered Seoul in 1929 to direct the rebuilding of the party.
Responsible secretary of the second Communist Party of KoreaKang Dal-yeong1887–1942Rebuilt the party after the first round-up, prepared the June Tenth Movement and was arrested in July 1926.
Responsible secretary who rebuilt the third Communist Party of KoreaKim Cheol-su (born 1893)1893–1986Restored the party centre in September 1926, merged it with the Seoul faction and handed it to An Gwang-cheon in December.
Drafter of the Jeongwuhoe Declaration; responsible secretary of the ML factionAn Gwang-cheon1897–?Drafted the Jeongwuhoe Declaration, became responsible secretary in December 1926 and led the formation of the Singanhoe.
Responsible secretary of the ML faction; a promoter of the SinganhoeKim Chun-yon1895–1971A promoter of the Singanhoe, he became responsible secretary of the party in September 1927 and was arrested in the third round-up in February 1928.
Last responsible secretary of the Communist Party of KoreaCha Geum-bong1898–1929Became responsible secretary in March 1928, was arrested in the July round-up and died in prison the following year.
First president of the SinganhoeYi Sang-jae1850–1927Chosen president at the founding congress in February 1927, he died just over a month later.
Vice-president of the SinganhoeHong Myong-hui1888–1968Led the founding of the Singanhoe, proposed its name and was jailed in the mass rally incident of December 1929.
Chair of the Singanhoe executiveHo Hon1885–1951Became chair of the executive at the congress of June 1929; his executive fell with the mass rally incident that December.
Tuesday Society, party co-founderKim Chan1894–?He led the founding of the party in April 1925 and became a central executive and head of propaganda.
Singanhoe executive leaderKim Byung-ro1887–1964After the People's Rally Incident he led the executive and narrowed its work to legal bounds.
Implementers & commanders1
Participants7
Took part in the Jeongwuhoe Declaration and the founding of the Singanhoe, and in exile set out the theory of the party-rebuilding movement.
Candidate member of the Koryo Communist Youth Association; a promoter of the GeunuhoeJu Se-juk1899–1953Arrested and released in the first and second round-ups, she took part in founding the Geunuhoe in 1927.
Central executive member of the GeunuhoeHo Jong-suk1902–1991Involved in the schoolgirls' demonstrations when the Gwangju Student Movement spread to Seoul, she was sentenced to a year in prison.
Central executive member of the Koryo Communist Youth AssociationIm Won-geun1900–1963Imprisoned after the first round-up, he wrote against dissolving the Singanhoe in 1931.
Drafter of the Comintern's colonial thesesOtto Wille Kuusinen1881–1964The theses on the colonial revolutionary movement that he drafted for the Sixth Congress of the Comintern were the basis of the December Theses.
Founding central executive member of the Communist Party of Korea (North Wind faction)Kim Yak-su1890–1964Of the North Wind Society group, he attended the founding congress in April 1925 and was elected one of the seven central executive members.
A promoter of the Singanhoe; opponent of its dissolutionAhn Chai-hong1891–1965Of the Chosun Ilbo circle, he took part in promoting the Singanhoe and in 1930 to 1931 argued that the cooperation of the two camps had to continue, attacking the case for dissolution as a "literal-translation internationalism".
Opposition & resistance3
With Choe Rin and Kim Song-su he prepared a movement for home rule under Japan; opposition to it was the immediate occasion for founding the Singanhoe.
Advocate of home rule in the Dong-A Ilbo circleKim Seong-su1891–1955With Choe Rin and Song Jin-u he judged independence impossible and tried to form a home-rule organisation; the "opportunism" rejected in the Singanhoe programme meant this movement.
Cheondogyo new faction, home-rule advocateChoe Rin1878–1958He prepared a movement for home rule under Japanese rule, which the non-compromising nationalists opposed.
Related terms
Sources: reference 1reference 2reference 3reference 4reference 5reference 6reference 7reference 8reference 9reference 10reference 11reference 12reference 13reference 14reference 15reference 16reference 17reference 18reference 19reference 20reference 21reference 22reference 23reference 24reference 25reference 26reference 27reference 28reference 29reference 30reference 31