The 1996-97 General Strike against the Labour Law Revision
How did Korea's two union federations strike together for the first time against a labour law the ruling party forced through before dawn, and what did they win and lose?
Founded outside the law in November 1995, the KCTU demanded an end to the bans on multiple unions and third-party intervention. After a reform commission, the Kim Young-sam government pressed a revision introducing redundancy dismissals and flexible hours, and before dawn on 26 December 1996 the New Korea Party passed the labour and security agency bills with no opposition present. The KCTU and the FKTU went on general strike together for the first time since liberation, backed by citizens, churches and labour abroad.
Where did the Korean labour movement stand in the mid-1990s?
After the June 1987 democracy movement came the Great Workers' Struggle of July to September, and new unions sprang up in factory after factory; in that year alone the number of unions rose from 2,675 to 4,103. The new unions saw the Federation of Korean Trade Unions (FKTU), since 1961 the only lawful national centre, as leaning on the government and refused to join it. In January 1990 they formed the Korea Trade Union Congress (Jeonnohyeop) around manufacturing unions, with some 600 unions and about 200,000 members, and in June 1993 they joined the large-company unions in a National Council of Union Representatives. 1 2
The obstacle to uniting these "democratic unions" was the law. From 1963 the Trade Union Act refused to recognise any organisation whose purpose was to obstruct the normal running of an existing union, and the 1987 revision also barred a union with the same organising scope as an existing one. Because of this ban on multiple unions, no national centre outside the FKTU could become lawful. The Labour Dispute Adjustment Act, which after its revision by the Legislative Council for National Security in December 1980 sharply restricted strikes, punished anyone who was not a party to a dispute and "intervened" in it with up to five years in prison, and unions were barred from political activity. Teachers and public servants could not form unions at all; when the Korean Teachers and Education Workers Union (Jeongyojo) was founded in May 1989 it was declared illegal and some 1,500 teachers were dismissed. 3 4 5 6
On 11 November 1995 the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions (KCTU, Minju Nochong) held its founding congress in the main hall of Yonsei University. It elected Kwon Young-ghil of the press unions' federation as president and Kwon Yong-mok of the Hyundai group union council as general secretary. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture gives 862 affiliated unions and some 420,000 members at the founding; the Seoul Shinmun on the day reported 861 organisations with about 395,000 members. It was smaller than the FKTU (4,426 unions, some 1.16 million members), but it held the big workplaces: car plants, shipyards, the Seoul subway and the major hospitals. Labour Minister Jin Nyum said just before the founding that the KCTU could not be recognised as a lawful body. 1 7
How did the Kim Young-sam government set out to revise the labour law?
On 24 April 1996 President Kim Young-sam announced his "New Vision of Industrial Relations," saying that industrial relations had to be reformed to raise competitiveness and the quality of life in the age of segyehwa (globalisation). On 9 May the presidential Labor-Management Relations Reform Commission was launched, with thirty members: five from labour, five from business, ten from civic groups and ten public-interest experts, chaired by the former prime minister Hyun Soong-jong. Both the FKTU and the still unrecognised KCTU took part. It was the first "social dialogue" body in which labour, business and public-interest representatives discussed revising the law together. 8 9
On 11 July the commission agreed on seven basic directions for reforming labour law and institutions, but it split over the concrete issues. The Korea Employers Federation, the FKTU (19 July) and the KCTU (August) each tabled their own draft, and the public-interest members sought a compromise with a public-interest proposal on 3 September and a revised one on 7 November. Ninety-eight issues were agreed; forty-three never were. The KCTU stopped attending from the ninth session in October. Employers wanted redundancy dismissals and flexible working hours; labour wanted freedom to form multiple unions and basic labour rights for teachers and public servants. 8 10 1
In November the government set up a Labor-Management Relations Reform Promotion Committee under Prime Minister Lee Soo-sung and drafted its own bill. The government bill settled on 3 December dropped the third-party intervention ban and the ban on union political activity, and allowed multiple unions at the level of federations and confederations, but only after a three-year deferral, with a five-year deferral at workplace level. In exchange it introduced redundancy dismissals and flexible working hours and widened the use of replacement workers during strikes. Teachers' and public servants' right to organise was put off. Labour protested that the bill twisted the commission's agreements to meet employers' demands. The bill went to the National Assembly on 11 December, and the same day an amendment to the Agency for National Security Planning Act went to the National Assembly, giving the intelligence agency back its power to investigate the National Security Act offences of "praising and encouraging" the enemy and failing to report. 8 10 2 11 12
What happened in the National Assembly before dawn on 26 December 1996?
Labour moved as soon as the government bill was settled. On 9 December the FKTU held an emergency congress and voted for a general strike, and from the 11th its president Park In-sang was on hunger strike. From the 9th the KCTU staged marches on Seoul, protests at the National Assembly and head-shaving sit-ins, and on the 23rd a meeting of its labour-law struggle headquarters decided that every affiliate would strike at once if the bills were passed. The opposition National Congress for New Politics and the United Liberal Democrats vowed to block any vote before the end of the year. 2 10 13
The leaders of the ruling New Korea Party decided on a vote without the opposition on the night of 24 December and telephoned their members between the evening of the 25th and 1 a.m. on the 26th. At 5:30 a.m. on the 26th the members gathered outside four Seoul hotels and rode chartered buses into the Assembly. At 6 a.m. a plenary session chaired by Deputy Speaker Oh Se-eung opened and passed the Agency for National Security Planning Act amendment, the labour bills and other bills by standing vote. The Seoul Shinmun reported that the session lasted six minutes and that 155 New Korea Party members attended; the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture gives 154, and English Wikipedia says eleven bills were passed in twenty minutes. Not one opposition member was present. Koreans call such a surprise vote a nalchigi, a "snatch." 13 10 14
The New Korea Party's chairman Lee Hong-koo and senior advisers such as Lee Hoi-chang, Choi Hyung-woo, Lee Han-dong and Lee Man-sup were in the chamber. Caught off guard, the National Congress and the United Liberal Democrats argued that the vote was void from the start: the National Assembly Act set weekday plenary sessions at 2 p.m. and required consultation with the floor groups to change the hour, and the vote had ignored their demand for a secret ballot. The three opposition parties formed a joint committee for the struggle against dictatorship and filed a constitutional complaint. The New Korea Party replied that it had told the opposition whips thirty minutes before the session and cited a Constitutional Court precedent that the Assembly's procedure was a matter for the Assembly itself. 13 10
How did the general strike spread?
On the morning of the 26th the KCTU changed its plans and held a press conference at Myeongdong Cathedral in Seoul to declare the general strike. President Kwon Young-ghil and twenty-one industrial federation leaders appeared with shaved heads and headbands reading "Abolish the evil labour laws." The KCTU declared the snatched labour law void and ordered its 320 affiliated unions to strike at once. By 4:30 p.m. some forty unions were out, among them the Hyundai group unions, the Kia, Asia and Ssangyong Motor unions and the Korea Heavy Industries and Hanjin Heavy Industries unions. The FKTU, under Park In-sang, voted for a 24-hour strike from 1 p.m. on the 27th, and that day some 160,000 members of 553 unions joined its first-stage general strike. The public security department of the Supreme Prosecutors' Office called the strike plainly illegal and promised to prosecute participants severely. 15 16 2
On 7 January 1997, at his New Year press conference, President Kim defended the revised labour and security agency laws, calling the new labour law "an advanced law" and saying that "in advanced countries there are no labour disputes." The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture says this remark fanned the opposition, which from then on took on the character of a struggle to "defend democracy." On 11 January some 100,000 people gathered at national rallies in about twenty places, and public figures issued a "Declaration of 1,997 on the State of the Nation." Joint citizens' committees formed in some sixty localities, and religious and women's groups issued their own declarations. Prosecutors obtained arrest warrants in advance for Kwon Young-ghil and other KCTU leaders, who made Myeongdong Cathedral their base. 10 11 15
On 14 January the FKTU began its second-stage general strike, with 250,000 people rallying in twenty-five regions. On the 15th the KCTU launched its third general strike. About 3,400 Seoul subway workers struck from 4 a.m., and the operator put some 700 non-union staff and veteran drivers in their place. Unions at four broadcasters including KBS, at eighteen hospitals including Seoul National University Hospital, and at the four car makers Daewoo, Kia, Asia and Ssangyong stayed out. A delegation of international labour bodies that had arrived on the 11th criticised the legalisation of redundancy dismissals and replacement labour and called for the labour and security agency laws to be withdrawn; Labour Minister Jin Nyum called this agitation and demanded an apology. The AFL-CIO in the United States and the Australian Council of Trade Unions also backed the strikers. 2 17 11 14
Counts of participation differ. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, following the KCTU's figures, gives a cumulative total of 3,422 unions and 3,878,211 workers, with an average of 163 unions and 184,498 strikers a day. English Wikipedia says up to 610,000 workers struck on a single day, the largest walkout in the country's history, and the government reckoned that in the first three weeks 200,000 workers at 176 firms had cost about $2.3 billion in lost output. What set the strike apart was the support of white-collar workers, intellectuals and religious leaders. In one newspaper poll 75 percent of salaried workers backed the general strike, and President Kim's approval rating fell to 13.9 percent. 1 14 18
How did the government and the Assembly back down?
On 16 January police fired tear gas at workers marching on Myeongdong Cathedral. On the 18th Kwon Young-ghil announced that until 18 February the KCTU would strike only on Wednesdays and rally every Saturday, and would resume an all-out strike if the government had not withdrawn the law by then. The KCTU explained that it wanted to conserve its strength and organise other sectors so that the dispute would become a political and social issue. 14 18
On 21 January President Kim met the opposition party leaders at the Blue House. He said the labour and security agency laws could be debated again in the Assembly and that he would accept a re-revision if the parties agreed on one, and he offered to suspend the execution of warrants against the leaders of the "illegal" strikes. But he refused the opposition leaders' demand that both laws be declared void, saying they had been promulgated as the Constitution required. Labour's position was that a re-revision without annulment was unacceptable. 19 10
In late January Hanbo Steel, the country's second-largest steelmaker, failed, and the collusion scandal that followed drew the press away from the strike. Workers who had lost weeks of wages hesitated to strike again, and both federations had run out of money. On 26 January the two federations held a joint workers' rally for annulling the snatched labour and security agency laws and for a democratic labour law; on the 28th the KCTU called off its mass protests, warning that it would strike again if the law was not properly amended. 14 2
On 8 March the policy chiefs of the New Korea Party, the National Congress and the United Liberal Democrats, together with the chairman of the Assembly's environment and labour committee Lee Keung-kyu and Minister Jin, hammered out a single bill. On 10 March the Assembly passed, in one package, a bill repealing the laws of 26 December 1996 and the jointly agreed bills. The Trade Union and Labor Relations Adjustment Act, which merged the old Trade Union Act and Labour Dispute Adjustment Act, was promulgated on 13 March as Act No. 5310. In his statement on promulgation President Kim said that "for the governing and opposition parties to make a new labour law by agreement is very rare even abroad." 20 21 8 5 22
Under the new law redundancy dismissals were limited to "urgent managerial reasons," and the takeover and merger grounds the government had wanted were dropped; the provision itself was deferred for two years, so that until March 1999 the existing Supreme Court case law would apply. Multiple unions were allowed at once at the level of federations and confederations, opening the way for the KCTU and its federations to become lawful, while multiple unions at workplace level were deferred for five years. The third-party intervention ban was replaced by a list of those from whom unions could seek support, and the ban on union political activity was lifted. On the other hand, striking to demand pay for strike days became a criminal offence, replacement labour within the same business was allowed, and flexible working hours of 48 hours over two weeks or 56 hours over four came in. The ban on employers paying full-time union officials was deferred for five years. Teachers and public servants still could not form unions. 12 20 5 2 14
How did the labour movement turn to politics after the strike?
Park In-sang, president of the FKTU, later recalled that the 1996 snatch had convinced him that labour needed political power of its own. The FKTU had long backed ruling-party candidates, but on 9 December 1997 Park declared its support for the opposition candidate Kim Dae-jung. Japanese Wikipedia says the New Korea Party's forcing through of the labour law in 1996 ended the FKTU's strategy of supporting the ruling party. 23 2 24
On 27 March 1997 the KCTU resolved to lay the foundations of a new party that would represent workers' interests. With the KCTU, the Progressive Political Alliance and the National Alliance for Democracy and Reunification of Korea at its core, People's Victory 21 was launched on 7 September and at its founding congress on 26 October nominated Kwon Young-ghil for president. Under the slogan "Rise up, Korea," Kwon called for lifelong job security and the abolition of the National Security Act and the security agency, and when the currency crisis struck he put stopping redundancy dismissals and breaking up the chaebol first. In the election of 18 December he won 306,026 votes (1.19 percent in the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, 1.2 percent in Wikipedia). 25 26 27
People's Victory 21 dissolved on 10 July 1999 ahead of a preparatory committee for a progressive party, and the Democratic Labor Party was founded on 30 January 2000; in the 2004 general election it won ten seats, the first progressive party to enter the National Assembly. Sources differ on when the KCTU became lawful. A March 1997 explanation of the agreed bill expected it to be legalised as soon as the law took effect, and Korean Wikipedia says it became lawful with the 1997 revision; the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture and English Wikipedia date the government's recognition of the KCTU to November 1999. 28 12 29 1 14
What did the currency crisis and the Tripartite Commission change?
The economic programme Korea agreed with the International Monetary Fund in the currency crisis of late 1997 included a labour-market reform easing restrictions on dismissals in mergers, takeovers and restructuring. Driven by President-elect Kim Dae-jung's camp, a Tripartite Commission of labour, business and government representatives was launched on 15 January 1998. On 6 February it agreed a "Social Pact to Overcome the Economic Crisis": the two-year deferral of redundancy dismissals was deleted and worker dispatch introduced, in exchange for legalising union political activity, workplace councils for public servants from January 1999 and teachers' unions from July 1999. The Labour Standards Act amendment of 20 February put redundancy dismissals into force at once. 30 31 32 33 29
The KCTU's representative agreed to the pact, but its delegates' congress repudiated the leaders who had accepted redundancy dismissals. The KCTU stayed out of the second Tripartite Commission, launched in June 1998, setting conditions such as reopening the questions of redundancy dismissals and worker dispatch. Mass redundancies followed at company after company through 1998. Dan Byung-ho, jailed in 1998 on charges of leading the 1997 general strike, was released in the Liberation Day amnesty of August 1999 and became president of the KCTU. On 6 January 1999 the National Assembly passed the Teachers' Union Act, and on 1 July 1999, ten years after its founding, the KTU became a lawful union. 29 33 10 34 6
How is the general strike judged?
The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture judges that the content of the bill and the way it was snatched through brought the two national federations into a nationwide joint struggle for the first time since liberation. English Wikipedia calls it the first successful general strike since the Korean War and one that joined blue-collar and white-collar workers, but it also says the strike was enormously successful in mobilisation and only marginally successful in its results. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture notes that labour rejected any re-revision without annulment, but the parties agreed to change only a few key clauses. 10 14
Views of the reform commission and of redundancy dismissals also differ. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture's entry on the commission credits it, as the first social dialogue in which labour and business took part in revising the law, with setting "the prototype of a Korean model of social dialogue" that led to the Tripartite Commission. The same encyclopedia's entry on redundancy dismissals sets the view that they caused excessive unemployment but laid the basis for a flexible employment structure beside the view that the commission's public debate was a "politics of exchange" and an irregular way of making law, and the tripartite grand compromise a settlement forced by the economic crisis. Its entry on the later Economic and Social Development Tripartite Commission likewise contrasts those who see the commission as a framework for a social safety net with those who see it as the starting point of neoliberalism. 8 30 33
Consequences
In March 1997 the Assembly repealed the snatched law and revised it again by agreement. Union pluralism at federation level was allowed and the bans on third-party intervention and union politics went, but redundancy dismissals stayed, deferred for two years. The strike set off labour's turn to politics through People's Victory 21 and the Democratic Labor Party, yet in the currency crisis the tripartite pact of 1998 brought redundancy dismissals into force at once.
Timeline & Map
- 1995.11.11KCTU foundedYonsei University
The Korean Confederation of Trade Unions held its founding congress at Yonsei University and elected Kwon Young-ghil president. The government refused to recognise it.
- 1996.04.24New Vision of Industrial RelationsSeoul
President Kim Young-sam announced a reform of industrial relations and a presidential commission to prepare it.
- 1996.05.09Reform commission launchedSeoul
The presidential Labor-Management Relations Reform Commission of thirty labour, business, civic and public-interest members was launched.
- 1996.11.07Revised public-interest proposalSeoul
The public-interest members tabled a revised proposal on the forty-three issues labour and business could not agree, but no grand compromise followed.
- 1996.12.03Government labour bill settledSeoul
The government settled a labour bill introducing redundancy dismissals and flexible hours and deferring union pluralism.
- 1996.12.26Labour and security bills snatched throughNational Assembly
New Korea Party members opened a plenary session alone at 6 a.m. and passed the labour bills and the security agency amendment. The KCTU struck at once.
- 1996.12.27FKTU first-stage strikeSeoul
Some 160,000 members of 553 FKTU unions joined its first-stage general strike.
- 1997.01.07Kim Young-sam's New Year press conferenceBlue House
President Kim defended the new labour law, saying that "in advanced countries there are no labour disputes," and fanned the protests.
- 1997.01.11National ralliesSeoul
Some 100,000 people rallied in about twenty places, and public figures issued the Declaration of 1,997.
- 1997.01.15KCTU third general strikeSeoul
Subway, broadcasting, hospital and car unions struck; the FKTU had begun its second-stage strike the day before.
- 1997.01.18Switch to Wednesday strikesMyeongdong Cathedral
Kwon Young-ghil announced that until 18 February the KCTU would strike only on Wednesdays and rally on Saturdays.
- 1997.01.21Blue House summit with the oppositionBlue House
President Kim accepted renewed debate of both laws in the Assembly and suspended the warrants against strike leaders, but refused to annul the laws.
- 1997.03.10Labour laws re-revisedNational Assembly
The Assembly repealed the laws of 26 December 1996 and passed the agreed bills: union pluralism at federation level at once, redundancy dismissals deferred two years.
- 1997.03.13Trade Union and Labor Relations Adjustment Act promulgatedSeoul
The new labour relations law was promulgated as Act No. 5310.
- 1997.10.26People's Victory 21 foundedSeoul
The KCTU, the Progressive Political Alliance and the National Alliance held the founding congress of People's Victory 21 and nominated Kwon Young-ghil for president.
- 1997.12.18Fifteenth presidential electionSeoul
Kim Dae-jung was elected; Kwon Young-ghil won 306,026 votes.
- 1998.02.06Tripartite social pactSeoul
The Tripartite Commission agreed a pact deleting the deferral of redundancy dismissals and introducing worker dispatch, in return for union political activity and teachers' unions.
- 1999.07.01KTU legalisedSeoul
With the Teachers' Union Act in force, the KTU became a lawful union ten years after its founding.
Related people 6
Labour (KCTU and FKTU)3
Leadership2
Led the general strike while under an arrest warrant at Myeongdong Cathedral; People's Victory 21 presidential candidate in 1997.
President of the FKTUPark In-sang1939–Took the FKTU into a joint general strike with the KCTU after a hunger strike, and declared for Kim Dae-jung in 1997.
Kim Young-sam government and New Korea Party2
Opposition (National Congress and ULD)1
Related terms
Sources: reference 1reference 2reference 3reference 4reference 5reference 6reference 7reference 8reference 9reference 10reference 11reference 12reference 13reference 14reference 15reference 16reference 17reference 18reference 19reference 20reference 21reference 22reference 23reference 24reference 25reference 26reference 27reference 28reference 29reference 30reference 31reference 32reference 33reference 34