Yamakawaism
야마카와주의
The name for the line Hitoshi Yamakawa set out in his 1922 essay "A Change of Direction for the Proletarian Movement" and for his later doctrine of a united-front party. He held that the minority vanguard, having clarified its ideas, must go "back to the masses" and build the movement on the masses' immediate demands, and he argued for a single legal proletarian party uniting workers and peasants rather than a small secret vanguard. It led to the dissolution of the Japanese Communist Party in 1924, was attacked by Fukumotoism and was criticised in the Comintern's 1927 Theses. It was carried on by the Rōnō-ha.
In depth
Which text did it begin with?
The Japanese Communist Party was founded illegally in July 1922, with Toshihiko Sakai, Hitoshi Yamakawa and Kanson Arahata, veterans of the movement since the Meiji era, at its centre. In August of that year Yamakawa published "A Change of Direction for the Proletarian Movement", which applied the Comintern's slogan "To the masses!" to Japan.
The essay is an argument in two steps. For twenty years the Japanese socialist movement had kept its eyes on the final goal of abolishing capitalism and had taken no interest in any problem that did not lead straight to it. For a minority vanguard to free itself from the mental domination of capitalism and purify its ideas was the first step, and that step had been taken well. But it had cut the vanguard off from the masses. Now the second step was due.
"Back to the masses!" must be the new slogan of the Japanese Proletarian Movement.
Yamakawa headed his fourth section "We were wrong". He added at the close that the minority vanguard must not dissolve into the masses; if it did, that would be no step forward but a fall into reformism and opportunism.
What did it argue?
First, the movement must stand on what the masses actually demand now. The attitude that dismissed partial improvements under capitalism as worthless was to be dropped, and the fight to better workers' daily lives was to be taken seriously.
Second, politics was not simply to be denied but to be contested. The movement should move from turning its back on political questions, on the ground that the state is a tool of the bourgeoisie, to actively opposing bourgeois politics.
Third came a view of the party. Yamakawa thought that what was needed was not a small revolutionary party cut off from the masses but a broad proletarian party embracing every class and stratum opposed to the bourgeoisie, within which the masses would grow and a vanguard party would be built. He advocated a single, legal proletarian party that could unite all workers and peasants, rather than a small, secretive vanguard of intellectuals. Some criticised this as "Japanese-style legalism".
The dissolution of the party and the attack from Fukumotoism
Arrests came in June 1923, and after the Great Kantō Earthquake the case for dissolving the party gained ground. Yamakawa was at its centre, and in February and March 1924 most members decided to dissolve, holding that the conditions for a communist party did not yet exist in Japan. Arahata objected and had a small committee (the bureau) set up to wind things up. Under Comintern direction that bureau moved towards rebuilding the party.
The theorist of the rebuilders, Kazuo Fukumoto, attacked Yamakawa's line as eclecticism and trade-unionism that did not separate the economic from the political movement (Fukumotoism). In December 1926 the party was re-established on Fukumotoist lines; Yamakawa stayed out and was denounced by the party mainstream as an "opportunist" and a "liquidator".
The 1927 Theses and the Rōnō-ha
The Comintern's 1927 Theses criticised Yamakawa along with Fukumoto, calling his line "dissolutionism". In December 1927 Yamakawa, Sakai, Arahata, Tsunao Inomata and others founded the journal Rōnō and set out the doctrine of a united-front party. They were the Rōnō-ha. In February 1928 the party resolved to expel Yamakawa and Arahata; the Rōnō-ha side holds that the expulsion was meaningless, since they had never joined the rebuilt party.
The Rōnō-ha's view of the party continued Yamakawaism unchanged. Since capitalism or socialism was not the immediate question for the masses, what was needed was a mass legal party gathering every stratum opposed to the bourgeoisie, a single proletarian party with the character of a united front. Yamakawa was arrested in the Popular Front incident of 1937; after the war he worked as a theorist of the Socialist Party's left wing and founded the Socialist Association in 1951.
The phrase "change of direction" later took on another colour. Changes of direction of this kind, which avoided a head-on fight with the emperor system, were for a time called tenkō, and after the 1933 statement of Manabu Sano and Sadachika Nabeyama the word hardened into meaning a betrayal of party and class.
How did it touch Korea and Taiwan?
Yamakawa also wrote on the colonies; in 1926 he published Taiwan under Colonial Policy: The Sorrow of a Weak Nation. The Taiwanese Communist Party, formed in 1928, is said to have been at first under his sway: he called for uniting workers, peasants and the petty bourgeoisie in a mass party, and the Comintern too at first favoured communists joining with bourgeois forces in an anti-imperialist war of national liberation. The party's 1931 charter, however, played down the revolutionary potential of the bourgeoisie and put class struggle first, and Xie Xuehong, who had led the party until then, opposed the turn and was forced out with her supporters.
The first issue of Daejung Sinmun, published on 1 June 1926 by the Irwolhoe, the Korean socialist group in Tokyo, carried an article by Yamakawa, "For Unity". In November of that year the Jeongwuhoe Declaration in Korea called for a "change of direction" from economic to political struggle, and the following year KAPF's literary movement used the same phrase.