Under 5 Employees and Special Zone Act Exceptions: The Scope of Application Employers Choose
On November 7, two workers' rallies were held in Seoul. At Yeouido, the Federation of Korean Trade Unions (FKTU) gathered 15,000 people according to unofficial police estimates, demanding legislation within the year to extend the retirement age to 65 and employment stability in the AI era. At Sungnyemun, the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions (KCTU) gathered 18,000 people, raising demands for bargaining with principal contractors, basic labor rights, and the abolition of the super-wide special zone act. According to organizers' estimates, the figures were about 30,000 and 50,000 nationwide, respectively. The two organizations directed the same demands at the same law. The FKTU chairman said the law is an attempt to expand exceptions to working hours and labor rights and even exclude the application of labor relations laws, and that a government claiming national sovereignty is turning into a corporate-sovereignty government. The KCTU chairman criticized it as an evil law that fattens only the chaebol under the pretext of balanced regional development. The two chairmen's language and lines differ, but the provisions they point to are the same.
Yet a heavier fact lies elsewhere this week. What the speakers at the same-day rallies pointed to was not the special exceptions of the special zone act but the size outside the law. According to a recent tally announced by labor groups in front of the National Assembly, the number of workers at businesses with fewer than five employees is 3,178,175, or 16.5 percent of the total. The restriction on dismissal under Article 23, Paragraph 1 of the Labor Standards Act and the request for remedy against unfair dismissal under Article 28 do not reach them. Workers at workplaces with fewer than five employees are outside the law, and special employment, platform workers, and freelancers receive not even minimal protection on the grounds that they are not workers. What deserves attention here is that this exclusion is not an exception but a design. Workplaces with fewer than five employees account for 67.7 percent of workplaces enrolled in workplace health insurance. The zone beyond the law's reach is larger than the zone within it.
That zone does not remain as it is. The Busan Mart World Management Office was not a workplace with fewer than five employees until 2024, but when a union was formed, it converted employees to service contracts and made it a workplace with fewer than five employees, and testimony emerged at the rally that a union member was dismissed on January 15 of this year. The same venue also heard that labor consultants even provide consulting to create workplaces with fewer than five employees. The category of fewer than five employees is not the size of a business but a legal status that an employer can choose. In this respect, the special exceptions of the super-wide special zone act and the exclusion of workplaces with fewer than five employees stand side by side. Special exceptions draw a line around space to bypass the law, and fewer than five employees count heads to bypass the law. Both are devices that let employers choose the scope of the law's application.
At the end of that lie this week's numbers. According to the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy, October exports were $115.28 billion, up 93.7 percent from the same month last year, and the cumulative total for January-October was $930 billion; semiconductors alone were $56.44 billion, up 259.4 percent, accounting for about 49 percent of total exports. According to the Ministry of Economy and Finance's September 30 re-estimate, this year's national tax revenue will be 63.2 trillion won more than the pre-supplementary forecast, of which corporate tax alone increased by 35 trillion won. Yet in the Ministry of Employment and Labor survey, the average monthly actual wage in the second quarter was 3.37 million won, down 0.8 percent from a year earlier. Strikes and sit-ins did not happen while semiconductor prices were rising. While semiconductor prices rose, workers' share fell, and in the meantime the ruling and opposition parties fought over whether to use the 63 trillion won for industrial investment or to repay debt.
On the evening of the 7th, at that rally site, the 56th anniversary of martyr Chun Tae-il was counted again. What he set himself on fire with on November 13, 1970, was not a demand but a law book. The cry to obey the Labor Standards Act was the cry of people to whom the law did not apply even though it existed, not because it did not exist. Fifty-six years later, the same cry returned with different numbers. 3.17 million are outside the law, 3.9 million are outside social insurance, and the place to contest dismissal is not the Labor Relations Commission but a civil court. The Under-Five Employees Branch tried to move that place to a constitutional complaint, but on August 27, the Constitutional Court unanimously dismissed the claim asking whether not guaranteeing paid public holidays to workplaces with fewer than five employees is unconstitutional. Thus the door through which people outside the law could question the law was also closed.
Now the place where that demand will go is set. At 2 p.m. on the 13th, the 8th working-level consultative body will put industrial safety and health and working hours and the right to health on the agenda for the first time. After loosening up at the 7th meeting on the 6th with settlement support and manpower training, where labor and management differences are small, the order moves to items with large differences. At 3 p.m. the same day, the 'Workers Outside the Labor Law Rally' will be held in front of the Korea Employers Federation, and the joint struggle against the super-wide special zone act will receive a 1,000-person declaration by the 12th and enter a sit-in in front of the National Assembly. The KCTU chairman said that of the 600 or so workplaces that demanded bargaining with principal contractors, fewer than 10 percent responded to bargaining. That 10 percent is calculated outside the meeting room on the 13th, and inside the meeting room the order of the next agenda is decided. Good faith in dialogue is not proven by the number of attendees. It is proven by whether the number of people outside the law is written as a number in the minutes.
Yet a heavier fact lies elsewhere this week. What the speakers at the same-day rallies pointed to was not the special exceptions of the special zone act but the size outside the law. According to a recent tally announced by labor groups in front of the National Assembly, the number of workers at businesses with fewer than five employees is 3,178,175, or 16.5 percent of the total. The restriction on dismissal under Article 23, Paragraph 1 of the Labor Standards Act and the request for remedy against unfair dismissal under Article 28 do not reach them. Workers at workplaces with fewer than five employees are outside the law, and special employment, platform workers, and freelancers receive not even minimal protection on the grounds that they are not workers. What deserves attention here is that this exclusion is not an exception but a design. Workplaces with fewer than five employees account for 67.7 percent of workplaces enrolled in workplace health insurance. The zone beyond the law's reach is larger than the zone within it.
That zone does not remain as it is. The Busan Mart World Management Office was not a workplace with fewer than five employees until 2024, but when a union was formed, it converted employees to service contracts and made it a workplace with fewer than five employees, and testimony emerged at the rally that a union member was dismissed on January 15 of this year. The same venue also heard that labor consultants even provide consulting to create workplaces with fewer than five employees. The category of fewer than five employees is not the size of a business but a legal status that an employer can choose. In this respect, the special exceptions of the super-wide special zone act and the exclusion of workplaces with fewer than five employees stand side by side. Special exceptions draw a line around space to bypass the law, and fewer than five employees count heads to bypass the law. Both are devices that let employers choose the scope of the law's application.
At the end of that lie this week's numbers. According to the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy, October exports were $115.28 billion, up 93.7 percent from the same month last year, and the cumulative total for January-October was $930 billion; semiconductors alone were $56.44 billion, up 259.4 percent, accounting for about 49 percent of total exports. According to the Ministry of Economy and Finance's September 30 re-estimate, this year's national tax revenue will be 63.2 trillion won more than the pre-supplementary forecast, of which corporate tax alone increased by 35 trillion won. Yet in the Ministry of Employment and Labor survey, the average monthly actual wage in the second quarter was 3.37 million won, down 0.8 percent from a year earlier. Strikes and sit-ins did not happen while semiconductor prices were rising. While semiconductor prices rose, workers' share fell, and in the meantime the ruling and opposition parties fought over whether to use the 63 trillion won for industrial investment or to repay debt.
On the evening of the 7th, at that rally site, the 56th anniversary of martyr Chun Tae-il was counted again. What he set himself on fire with on November 13, 1970, was not a demand but a law book. The cry to obey the Labor Standards Act was the cry of people to whom the law did not apply even though it existed, not because it did not exist. Fifty-six years later, the same cry returned with different numbers. 3.17 million are outside the law, 3.9 million are outside social insurance, and the place to contest dismissal is not the Labor Relations Commission but a civil court. The Under-Five Employees Branch tried to move that place to a constitutional complaint, but on August 27, the Constitutional Court unanimously dismissed the claim asking whether not guaranteeing paid public holidays to workplaces with fewer than five employees is unconstitutional. Thus the door through which people outside the law could question the law was also closed.
Now the place where that demand will go is set. At 2 p.m. on the 13th, the 8th working-level consultative body will put industrial safety and health and working hours and the right to health on the agenda for the first time. After loosening up at the 7th meeting on the 6th with settlement support and manpower training, where labor and management differences are small, the order moves to items with large differences. At 3 p.m. the same day, the 'Workers Outside the Labor Law Rally' will be held in front of the Korea Employers Federation, and the joint struggle against the super-wide special zone act will receive a 1,000-person declaration by the 12th and enter a sit-in in front of the National Assembly. The KCTU chairman said that of the 600 or so workplaces that demanded bargaining with principal contractors, fewer than 10 percent responded to bargaining. That 10 percent is calculated outside the meeting room on the 13th, and inside the meeting room the order of the next agenda is decided. Good faith in dialogue is not proven by the number of attendees. It is proven by whether the number of people outside the law is written as a number in the minutes.