Editor of Krasnaya Nov, Marxist critic who discovered Babel and Pasternak and led Pereval against RAPP
1921, in Lenin's Kremlin apartment. At the founding meeting of Krasnaya Nov, Gorky showed a collection of Indian tales. Lenin cut him short: "We pay for this in gold currency. This year there will be famine." Voronsky recalled: "Two truths collided — one said man does not live by bread alone, the other answered: but what if there is no bread?"
Expelled from the Tambov seminary as politically unreliable, he joined the Bolsheviks in 1904 and was a delegate to the 1912 Prague Conference. As editor of the literary monthly Krasnaya Nov from 1921 to 1927 he published Babel, Pasternak and other fellow travellers, and he led the Krug publishing house and the Pereval group. Treating art as the cognition of life, he opposed Na postu and RAPP. He signed the Declaration of the 46 in 1923 and stood with the Left Opposition; expelled from the party in 1927, he was exiled to Lipetsk. He left the opposition in 1929 and worked at the State Literary Publishing House, but was arrested in February 1937 and shot on 13 August. He was rehabilitated in 1957.
Also known as: Nurmin · Aleksandr Konstantinovich Voronsky
Activities and affiliations
-
1904–1934
Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks
Political and party leadership
Career Timeline
- 1904Joined the RSDLP(B) in Tambov
- 1906–1910Arrested; one year solitary in Peter and Paul Fortress, two years exile in Yarensk
- 1912Delegate to the Prague Conference; took minutes, spoke for a mass workers' daily
- 1917–1920Odessa Soviet executive committee, Ivanovo-Voznesensk Party chair, VTsIK member; helped suppress the Kronstadt rebellion
- 1921–1927Founded and edited Krasnaya Nov; edited Prozhektor; founded Krug publishing; led the Pereval literary group
- 1923Signed the Declaration of the 46, joined the Left Opposition
- 1927–1930Expelled from Party as Trotskyist, exiled to Lipetsk; renounced opposition in 1929, reinstated in 1930
- 1930–1935Editor of classical literature at Goslitizdat; wrote autobiographical fiction
- 1937Arrested 1 Feb during the Great Purge; on Stalin's signed death list; shot 13 Aug after a 15-minute trial
Related historical events
- 1918–1922The Civil War and Foreign InterventionParticipated in the suppression of the Kronstadt uprising
- 1921.03The Kronstadt RebellionParticipant in the suppressionHe helped suppress the Kronstadt Rebellion.
- 1923–1927The Succession Struggle and the Left OppositionLeft Opposition memberIn 1923, he signed the Declaration of the 46 and joined the Left Opposition.
- 1937–1938The Great PurgeLeft Opposition literary critic and editorArrested 1 February 1937 and placed on Stalin's signed execution list. Shot 13 August after a 15-minute trial. He was the founding editor of Krasnaya Nov, leader of Pereval, and the Marxist critic who discovered Babel and Pasternak.
Krasnaya Nov and the quarrel with Na postu
In the early 1920s Voronsky emerged as one of the leading Marxist theorists of literature. From 1921 to 1927 he edited Krasnaya Nov, one of the three leading literary monthlies of the day, and from 1922 to 1927 Prozhektor, and he chaired the board of the Krug publishing house. Sergei Yesenin dedicated his long poem "Anna Snegina" to him.
Krasnaya Nov fought sharply with the critics of the journal Na postu ("On Guard") over the class character of art, the fellow travellers, literary groups and the treatment of young writers. Voronsky argued for uniting writers under the party's leadership, while the Na postu side held to the dictatorship of the proletariat and class struggle even in artistic creation. The scholar Galina Belaya sees this as no mere quarrel between groups: against the "organised simplification of culture" pursued by the Proletkult, Na postu and the journal LEF, it was a fight to defend art as a distinct sphere of the human spirit and a distinct way of knowing the world.
His views were close to Trotsky's Literature and Revolution. Like Trotsky, he criticised the principles of the Proletkult and argued for gradually drawing the intelligentsia into Soviet literature. RAPP's theorists coined "Voronshchina" as a term of abuse. The scholar Stepan Sheshukov holds that the Politburo resolution of 18 June 1925 in effect backed Voronsky's position: joint creative work of writers led by communists, continuity with the literary heritage, and the reflection of life as a whole rather than of proletarian life alone. The resolution did, however, criticise him for not recognising proletarian writers and for not helping young people who wanted to enter literature.
Art as Cognition — Voronsky's Aesthetic Theory and Pereval
The core proposition of Voronsky's aesthetic theory was that "art is above all the cognition of life." For him, art was neither an arbitrary play of fantasy nor a mere expression of subjective emotions. Art, like science, cognizes life. But where science analyzes, abstracts, and works through concepts, art synthesizes, concretizes, and works through living sensory images. This was a Marxist reformulation of the Belinsky tradition.
The literary group Pereval (Перевал, 'The Mountain Pass'), which he founded in 1923, was the practical home of this aesthetic. Pereval directly opposed the schematic doctrines of RAPP (the Russian Association of Proletarian Writers), which sought to reduce art to a direct instrument of class struggle. Voronsky did not reject proletarian hegemony in principle, but he insisted that it must not be degraded into mechanical class determinism or 'communist arrogance' (комчванство) that destroyed artistic truth. RAPP answered with the derisive neologism 'Voronshchina.'
In his late work The Art of Seeing the World (Искусство видеть мир, 1928), Voronsky refined his aesthetics further. The genuine artist, he argued, possesses the gift of 'estrangement': the ability to discover unfamiliar, new aspects in familiar things. Art is not a passive reflection of reality but an active cognitive act that reconstructs the world anew. This view formed a fundamental critique of all three dominant tendencies: Proletkult's 'art as production,' LEF's 'literature of fact,' and RAPP's 'class art.'
He also engaged deeply with Freudian psychoanalysis, exploring the dialectic of consciousness and the unconscious in the creative process. The artist, he argued, captures new aspects of the world through unconscious drives and intuition, but in the final stage of shaping, intellect and craft play the decisive role. This was neither mechanical materialism nor mystical intuitionism, but an original search for a Marxist aesthetic.
The 1925 Politburo resolution "On the Party's Policy in the Field of Literature" partially vindicated Voronsky's position. It called for a 'tactful and careful attitude' toward fellow-traveler writers, recognized 'free creative competition,' and warned against class conceit. But as the Stalin faction consolidated power and the Cultural Revolution radicalized, RAPP's line prevailed, and Voronsky's aesthetics was branded Trotskyist and suppressed. Nevertheless, his work was rediscovered after the Thaw of the 1960s and is now regarded as one of the most original and productive legacies of Soviet Marxist aesthetics.
1927–1937: expulsion, exile and execution
After the Trotskyist demonstration of 1927 Voronsky was expelled from the party together with 75 active Trotskyists and sent into exile. In exile in Lipetsk he wrote autobiographical prose about his youth and the beginning of his underground work. In 1929 he announced that he was leaving the opposition, and in 1930 he returned to Moscow as editor of classical literature at the State Literary Publishing House. His daughter recalled that he was very sceptical of Stalin.
He was arrested in 1935, arrested again on 1 February 1937 and shot in Moscow on 13 August. The testimony of Boris Pilnyak, arrested that October on a charge of espionage, blamed Voronsky's "pernicious influence" for "The Tale of the Unextinguished Moon" and presented his founding of the Pereval and "1930s" groups as criminal acts. His wife, Sima Pesina, was sentenced in September 1937 to eight years in a labour camp as a family member of a traitor to the motherland.
He was rehabilitated posthumously on 7 February 1957. Stepan Sheshukov, a professor at the Moscow State Pedagogical Institute who studied the literary debates of the 1920s, brought him back into Soviet literary history, and Sheshukov's graduate student Galina Belaya made Voronsky the hero of her book The Don Quixotes of the 1920s.