The Marxist who linked the Russian and Spanish revolutions, founder of the POUM

“The working class has solved the problem of the Church simply by not leaving even one of them standing.” — La Vanguardia, August 1936

A teacher and journalist from a cobbler's family in El Vendrell, he turned to revolutionary syndicalism around 1917 and became general secretary of the CNT National Committee. Sent to the Comintern and Profintern congresses in 1921, he stayed in Moscow, became a Marxist and from 1926 belonged to Trotsky's Left Opposition. Back in Spain in 1930 he founded the Communist Left of Spain (ICE), and in 1935 merged it with Maurín's Workers' and Peasants' Bloc to found the POUM, becoming its general secretary the next year. He was Catalan Minister of Justice from September to December 1936. Arrested with the POUM leadership after the May Days of 1937, he disappeared and is held to have been killed by the Soviet NKVD. He also translated Russian classics into Catalan.

Also known as: Andreu Nin i Pérez · Andrés Nin Pérez

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

Moscow Years and the Left Opposition

When Nin arrived in Moscow in 1921 as a CNT delegate, he was deeply moved by the Russian Revolution and converted to Marxism. He remained in the USSR for nine years, working in the Profintern secretariat, joining the RCP(b), and even being elected a deputy of the Moscow Soviet. During this period he grew close to Trotsky, serving as his secretary and emerging as a key figure in the Left Opposition against Stalin's bureaucratic line. In 1926 he was removed from his Profintern post and placed under surveillance for his opposition activity; he then spent four years seeking permission to leave the USSR with his wife Olga Tareyeva and their two daughters, Ira and Nora. When Nin finally returned to Spain in 1930, he was one of the few Western European Bolsheviks fluent in Russian, enough to translate the Russian classics directly into Catalan.

From the Communist Left of Spain to the POUM, 1930–1936

Back in Spain in 1930, Nin founded the Communist Left of Spain (ICE). The group soon affiliated with the International Left Opposition and published the newspaper El Soviet, but for all its prominent militants it was too small to have any real influence on Spanish politics. Although it was regarded as an anti-Stalinist Trotskyist party, Trotsky himself, from his exile in Turkey and France, sharply criticised its line.

In the Revolution of 1934 Nin was a member of the Workers' Alliance (Alianza Obrera) and took part in the rising of 6 October in Catalonia. When Trotsky called on his followers to adopt an entryist tactic inside the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party (PSOE), Nin refused and broke with him. Trotsky later wrote that from the beginning of 1933 disagreements on essential questions had led to a complete break between them. In 1935 his group merged with Joaquín Maurín's Workers' and Peasants' Bloc (BOC) to found the Workers' Party of Marxist Unification (POUM). Nin became a member of the new party's executive committee and editor of its paper La Nueva Era, and the following year he was elected general secretary. In May 1936 he also became general secretary of the FOUS, a union federation strong in Lleida, Girona and Tarragona.

When the republicans and the workers' parties concluded the Popular Front electoral pact on 15 January 1936 ahead of the February elections, the POUM was among its parties; the PSOE signed on behalf of the Communist Party, the POUM and other workers' organisations. In an article of 22 January, "The Treachery of the Spanish 'Labor Party of Marxist Unity'", Trotsky wrote that the former Spanish Left Communists (Andrés Nin, Juan Andrade and others) had become a mere tail of the "left" bourgeoisie and condemned their betrayal of the proletariat for the sake of an alliance with the bourgeoisie. Maurín and Nin pointed to the electoral law, but Trotsky replied that electoral technique could not justify a common programme with the bourgeoisie, and he called on revolutionists in Spain to expose "the betrayal of Maurín, Nin, Andrade and Co." and to build the Spanish section of the Fourth International.

When the Civil War broke out he stepped onto the public stage as the POUM's leader. After serving on the Economic Council of Catalonia in August and September 1936 he became Catalan Minister of Justice on 26 September and introduced People's Courts by decree on 14 October. Extra-judicial executions nonetheless continued during his tenure, and POUM militias also took part in the repression of "fascists". In the autumn he proposed to Companys that Catalonia take in Trotsky, who was being forced out of Norway, but the Unified Socialist Party of Catalonia (PSUC) objected. On 24 November the PSUC handed the CNT a plan for a new cabinet that included Nin's departure, and the anarchists, many of whom regarded him as a renegade from the CNT, treated it as a quarrel among Marxists. Nin left office in the reshuffle of 16 December.

Nin's dismissal followed threats from the Soviet consul in Barcelona, Vladimir Antonov-Ovseenko. Trotsky commented that in the heat of the revolutionary war between the classes Nin had entered a bourgeois government whose goal was to destroy the workers' committees, and that once this goal was reached he was driven out of it. In "The Lessons of Spain: The Last Warning", written on 17 December 1937, he concluded that politically the POUM had remained throughout far closer to the Popular Front, for whose left wing it provided the cover, than to Bolshevism.

Arrest and disappearance, June 1937: "Where is Nin?"

In the spring of 1937 the Republican police "found" a letter supposedly written by Nin to Franco endorsing a rising by the Madrid fifth column. It was in reality an NKVD forgery, and it became one of the main pieces of evidence against him. After the May Days the Communist campaign against the POUM intensified; its leaders were openly accused of being fascists conspiring with Franco, and on 28 May the party paper La Batalla was suspended.

On 14 June the Director General of Security, Colonel Antonio Ortega, told the Communist Minister of Education and Health, Jesús Hernández, that the NKVD chief in Spain, Alexander Orlov, wanted all POUM leaders arrested. Orlov claimed there was evidence linking the POUM to Franco's espionage and that the government should not be told, because the Interior Minister, Zugazagoitia, was a friend of some POUM leaders. On 16 June the authorities closed the POUM headquarters in the Hotel Falcón and arrested the leadership. Nin was separated from the others and disappeared.

He was taken to Alcalá de Henares, an important Soviet base. How he died, including whether he was tortured, remains unclear. Paul Preston holds that he was probably killed around 22 June on Orlov's orders with the help of Iosif Grigulevich, and there is little doubt that the order came from Moscow. The slogan "Where is Nin?" soon spread through Republican Spain, first raised in public by the anarchist Federica Montseny. The head of government, Juan Negrín, repeated the semi-official story that Nin had been freed by "his friends in the Gestapo", but Hugh Thomas and others hold that Republican leaders covered up the truth so as not to lose Soviet military aid.