The NKVD chief in Spain who shipped the Republic's gold to Moscow and broke the POUM, then fled Stalin and passed himself off as a general
In July 1938, ordered aboard a Soviet ship at Antwerp, Orlov took NKVD funds and sailed for Canada with his family. He later said he left letters for Stalin and Yezhov promising silence if he and his elderly mother were left alone.
Born Leiba Lazarevich Feldbin. After the Red Army and the border troops in the civil war he joined the foreign department (INO) in 1926 and ran illegal stations in Paris, Berlin, Vienna and London; in September 1936 he arrived in Madrid as liaison to the Republic's interior ministry and in 1937 became NKVD chief for Spain. Two operations bear his name: the shipment of 510 tonnes of the Republic's gold reserve from Cartagena to the USSR, and the framing of the POUM as traitors, in which its general secretary Andreu Nin was abducted and killed. Taking his recall in July 1938 as a death sentence, he fled with NKVD funds and his family to the United States, and after Stalin's death published The Secret History of Stalin's Crimes. Since the archives opened, his claims to general's rank and to recruiting the Cambridge ring have been judged inflated; his rank was major of state security.
Also known as: Leiba Lazarevich Feldbin · Lev Feldbin · Lev Nikolsky · William Goldin · Alexander Berg
Activities and affiliations
-
1920–1938
Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks
Security, intelligence and policing -
1924–1938
Soviet Union state institutionsState security agenciesMain
Security, intelligence and policing
Career Timeline
- 1895.08Born Leiba Feldbin into a Jewish family in Bobruisk
- 1916–1917Drafted into the Imperial Russian Army from Moscow University's law faculty; served in the rear
- 1918–1921Special Department of the Red Army's 12th Army; commanded a special-purpose detachment
- 1921–1924Law school of Moscow University; Supreme Tribunal under Krylenko
- 1924.05–1925Section head, GPU Economic Department
- 1925–1926Border guard command in Transcaucasia (Sukhumi)
- 1926–1930Foreign Department (INO) postings to Paris and Berlin under trade-delegation cover
- 1932.09–11Mission to the United States; obtained a passport as William Goldin
- 1933.05–1935.05Illegal operations from Vienna, Geneva and Copenhagen
- 1935.06–10Station chief in London, as William Goldin
- 1935.10–1936.09Deputy chief, NKVD Transport Department; major of state security from December
- 1936.09–1937NKVD liaison to the Spanish Republic's interior ministry; ran the gold reserve shipment; Order of Lenin
- 1937–1938.07NKVD station chief in Spain: directed the suppression of the POUM and the killing of Andreu Nin; ran guerrilla schools
- 1938–1953Lived underground in the United States as Alexander Berg
- 1938.07Fled with NKVD funds and his family through Canada to the United States
- 1953Published The Secret History of Stalin's Crimes and a series in Life magazine
- 1955–1957Testified twice before the Senate Internal Security Subcommittee
- 1962.09Research fellow at the University of Michigan Law School; published the Handbook of Intelligence and Guerrilla Warfare the next year
- 1973Died in Cleveland
Related historical events
- 1918–1922The Civil War and Foreign InterventionRed Army intelligence and partisan operativeDuring the civil war, he carried out intelligence and partisan work in the Red Army.
- 1936–1939The Spanish Civil WarNKVD chief for SpainCarried out the shipment of the gold reserve and directed the suppression of the POUM and the killing of Andreu Nin
- 1937–1938The Great PurgeNKVD officer who defected rather than return to the purgeRefused his recall in 1938 and fled; in 1953 he published The Secret History of Stalin's Crimes as an insider's testimony
How did Leiba Feldbin become a Soviet security officer?
Orlov was born Leiba Feldbin in August 1895 to a Jewish family in Bobruisk, Belarus. When the First World War broke out the family moved to Moscow, where he studied for two semesters at the Lazarev Institute of Oriental Languages and then moved to the law faculty of Moscow University. Drafted in 1916, he served in the rear, and after the February Revolution he joined not the Bolsheviks but the United Internationalist Social Democrats.
When the civil war began he was assigned to the Special Department of the Red Army's 12th Army, helped uncover counter-revolutionary organizations in Kiev and commanded a special-purpose detachment. He joined the Russian Communist Party in May 1920 and from about then used the name Lev Nikolsky. His claimed service in the Arkhangelsk Cheka in 1920–1921 rests on his own word and is not borne out by his archival file. In April 1921 he married Maria Rozhnetskaya in Arkhangelsk.
Demobilized in 1921, he attended the law school of Moscow University and worked at the Supreme Tribunal under Krylenko. In May 1924 he became a section head in the GPU's Economic Department, run by his cousin Zinovy Katsnelson, which began his intelligence career. In 1925 he followed Katsnelson to Transcaucasia and took charge of the Sukhumi border guard.
How did Nikolsky fare as a foreign intelligence officer?
In 1926 he moved to the Foreign Department (INO), in part because he wanted a posting abroad so that European doctors could treat his daughter Veronika's rheumatic fever. He worked in Paris and Berlin under trade-delegation cover, returned at the end of 1930, and from September to November 1932 went to the United States to reach his relatives there and obtain a genuine American passport. Identified as a spy by the US Office of Naval Intelligence, he still left with a passport in the name of William Goldin.
From 1933 he was based in Vienna and ran operation EXPRESS against French intelligence, which failed; in 1934 he assisted the station chiefs in Copenhagen and Paris. He also handled Kim Philby and the Cambridge group for a time from 1934, and in June 1935 became station chief in London under cover as a director of an American refrigerator company. But Volodarsky credits the Austrian Arnold Deutsch with the crucial role in recruiting the Cambridge group. According to Alan Judd's review, Nikolsky pretended his cover was blown in both London and Paris so as to be withdrawn before his failures became apparent.
Leaving his London post in October 1935, he returned to Moscow and was shunted into the post of deputy chief of the NKVD Transport Department. He received the rank of major of state security in December, but in 1936 his mistress shot herself outside the Lubyanka, and he was spared further disgrace by the need to send someone to Madrid. These months in Moscow, from late 1935 to September 1936, are when he watched the Zinoviev–Kamenev trial from close by, and they underlie the most reliable part of his later book.
NKVD Chief in Republican Spain: The Gold and the POUM
Orlov arrived in Madrid in September 1936 as one of two official NKVD representatives for liaison with the Spanish Republic's interior ministry; the other was Major of State Security Naum Belkin, and the alias "Alexander Mikhailovich Orlov" dates from this time. Around February–March 1937 he became NKVD resident in Spain, with Naum Eitingon as his deputy. He helped set up the Republic's counter-intelligence service, the Military Information Service (SIM), and created schools to train guerrilla and sabotage units to operate behind enemy lines.
The shipment of 510 tonnes of the Republic's gold reserve to the USSR is the deed most firmly tied to his name, and he received the Order of Lenin for it. Orlov himself later spoke as though he had negotiated the transfer with the Republican government, but his biographer Boris Volodarsky concludes that he did not negotiate with the government and was responsible only for the transport and guarding of the cargo. Sudoplatov wrote that the Spanish gold covered a large part of the cost of Soviet military and material aid to the Republicans and was also used to finance intelligence operations in Western Europe in 1939.
The documentary record puts the persecution of Trotskyists and anarchists at the centre of his work in Spain. He fabricated the "evidence" used to arrest the leaders of the Workers' Party of Marxist Unification (POUM), directed the arrest and summary execution of POUM members in Catalonia, and in June 1937 organized the removal of the POUM leader Andreu Nin from prison and his killing. Volodarsky holds that all the "liquidations" in Spain were planned and carried out under Orlov's direction and names Iosif Grigulevich as the man who shot Nin. Sudoplatov's memoir also says Orlov personally directed the removal of Nin, but writes that it was carried out by a group of German anti-fascist guerrillas and that Orlov devised the official story that Nin had escaped with the help of German intelligence; he adds that the operation appears in the NKVD archives under the name "Nikolai". Orlov himself repeatedly denied under oath in the United States that he had taken part in such operations. His report to Moscow of August 1937 set out a plan to seize and eliminate the Austrian socialist Kurt Landau; Trotsky's former secretary Erwin Wolf and the journalist Marc Rein, son of the Menshevik Rafail Abramovich, also vanished in Spain in this period. In April 1938 he recruited the American International Brigade volunteer Morris Cohen, later a courier for Soviet intelligence.
The Defection: Why He Fled and What He Kept Back
In July 1937 Orlov learned that his relative and patron Zinovy Katsnelson had been removed from all his posts and arrested, and the same month in Paris he heard from Theodore Maly, who had just been ordered home, that recalled colleagues were disappearing on their return. In February 1938 his direct superior, the foreign intelligence chief Abram Slutsky, died suddenly. That July Orlov was ordered to meet the acting foreign intelligence chief, Sergei Shpigelglas, aboard a Soviet ship moored at Antwerp. He did not go. According to Volodarsky, on 13 July he took 90,800 dollars of NKVD operational funds from the safe in the Barcelona consulate and crossed into France with his wife and daughter, sailed from Cherbourg on 21 July to Montreal, and from there went on to the United States.
According to Sudoplatov's memoir, Shpigelglas would not go ashore for fear of being detained by the French or Belgian authorities, while Orlov took the meeting for a trap to seize him. After Orlov vanished, Sudoplatov himself signed the search circular, which gave both kidnapping by a foreign service and defection as possible reasons. He recalls that in November 1938 Beria called him in and told him to stop the search: Orlov had written to Stalin and Nikolai Yezhov that if anyone tried to trace or watch him, his lawyer would release documents he had deposited, and that if his elderly mother in Moscow was left alone he would not reveal the agents and NKVD secrets he knew. Sudoplatov writes that he later reminded Andrei Vyshinsky that Stalin had ordered Orlov not to be pursued.
The two sides disagree about the letter and the motive for the flight. Orlov always said he faced imminent arrest and traded his silence for his safety by letter. Volodarsky, drawing on his declassified personal file, holds that he was in fact never recalled or under suspicion, and that after his letter to Yezhov arrived his file was annotated that the flight was "regarded as the result of fear and misunderstanding". Either way, the flight threw suspicion on the foreign intelligence cadre. Shpigelglas, Maly, Belkin and Yakov Serebryansky were among those arrested or dismissed, and Sudoplatov recalls that as a result intelligence from Western Europe fell sharply from November 1938 to March 1939.
Orlov did not give away the Cambridge ring working in Britain. It was Sudoplatov himself who decided in July 1939 to resume contact with Kim Philby, Donald Maclean and the others. Here too the explanations differ. Orlov told his FBI handler Edward Gazur that he could not betray people who had trusted him and served without reward. Sudoplatov believed it was a calculation of survival, not loyalty to the Soviet Union: if it came out that he had lived in Britain on a false American passport, or what executions he had directed in Spain, he could have been deported from the United States or prosecuted.
The historian of the security services Alexander Kolpakidi also says that he was called to Moscow to receive the Order of Lenin, and the threatening letter listing agents, as Orlov told it, appears only in his own memoirs; Volodarsky's side holds that no such letter existed.
On arriving in New York the family registered at a hotel as Leo, Maria and Vera Koornick, and on 13 August 1938 Orlov wrote to Trotsky warning of a possible attempt on his life and of the NKVD agent Mark Zborowski in Lev Sedov's circle. Trotsky took it for an NKVD hoax. They moved from New York to Philadelphia and California, and after their daughter Veronika died in 1940, to Boston and finally Cleveland, living as Alexander and Maria Berg. Orlov studied business administration at Dyke College in Cleveland, in the same building as the local FBI office, whose agents never noticed him.
The Secret History and Disputed Testimony
In April 1953, a month after Stalin's death, Orlov published four articles in Life announcing The Secret History of Stalin's Crimes. The CIA and the FBI, which had not known he was in the country for fifteen years, were deeply embarrassed. He was questioned by the FBI and appeared twice before Senate subcommittees, but he played down his own role and never named the Soviet agents working in the West. In April 1955 Congress passed a bill granting him and his wife permanent residence and citizenship, and he went on to work as a consultant to the CIA's counter-intelligence staff. Only in November 1969 did a KGB officer track him down and invite him to return; he refused.
Sudoplatov acknowledges that Orlov's revelations did much to make the nature of the 1937 purges understood. Yet he wrote that Orlov was not in Moscow during the arrests and executions of 1934–1937 and so was poorly informed about what really happened, and that although his book contains a good deal of truth it should not be taken at face value. He also points out that Orlov was never an NKVD general; his actual rank was major of state security. According to Sudoplatov's memoir, when Orlov's articles appeared in 1953 Moscow feared that the agent Iosif Grigulevich might have been exposed, recalled him and never sent him out again. Orlov was, however, working in Moscow for part of that period, from late 1935 to September 1936.
Research since the archives opened reaches a similar verdict. In the West Orlov presented himself as Stalin's friend and personal envoy and as an NKVD general, but the NKVD had no general's rank until 1945. He also claimed the leading role in recruiting the Cambridge ring, but Volodarsky finds that he had nothing to do with the first three when they were recruited and knew nothing of those who joined after he left London. His 1956 Life story, that the NKVD had found proof that Stalin had been an agent of the tsarist Okhrana and plotted a coup, is likewise rejected, since the letter it relied on is considered a forgery. At the same time Christopher Andrew and Vasili Mitrokhin, authors of The Mitrokhin Archive, note that a KGB-sponsored biography of 1993 also exaggerated when it made him the "mastermind" of the Cambridge recruitment, out of the habit of crediting superiors with their subordinates' successes and a wish to make Western intelligence look foolish.
The book's reliability is judged differently by period. In his 1989 preface to the Ogonyok serialization, the novelist Anatoly Rybakov held that the part from December 1935 to September 1936, when Orlov was in Moscow and the Zinoviev–Kamenev trial took place, was the most reliable, while the Kirov affair and the trials of 1937–1938 were hearsay. A Russian edition appeared only in 1983, thirty years after the English one. Later verdicts are harsher. Volodarsky says most of what Orlov said, even under oath, has been established as "outright invention"; the historian Zhanna Artamonova regards the memoirs as a complete fabrication; and Robert Thurston, pointing to the short-lived opposition bloc of Trotsky's supporters that became known only after Orlov's death, questions his picture of trials fabricated from nothing.
How the details go wrong can be seen in the last chapter, on Karl Pauker. Orlov says Pauker was captured in 1916, received the Order of Lenin and took no part in preparing the trials, whereas the biographical record has capture in April 1915, no Order of Lenin and a role in the fabrication of the cases. Even so, his anecdotes keep circulating as fact.
He became a research fellow at the University of Michigan Law School in 1962 and published the Handbook of Intelligence and Guerrilla Warfare in 1963 with CIA help. His wife Maria died in 1971 and he died in Cleveland in 1973. Sources differ on the date: Russian and English Wikipedia give 25 March, Georgetown University's Orlov papers finding aid and Wikidata 7 April. His last memoir, The March of Time, came out in 2004 through his FBI handler and friend Edward Gazur.