The operations chief who guarded Stalin
At a December 1936 Cheka dinner, Pauker reenacted Zinoviev's execution: dragged to his knees by two comrades, he begged "For God's sake, comrade, call Iosif Vissarionovich!" — and Stalin roared with laughter.
Born to a Jewish barber's family in Lemberg, he worked as a theatre hairdresser and make-up artist, became a Russian prisoner of war in the First World War and joined the Bolsheviks and the Cheka in Samarkand. Chief of the OGPU/NKVD Operations Department from 1923 and of Stalin's security from 1924, he took part in the arrests of oppositionists and the preparation of the trials and attended the execution of Zinoviev and Kamenev in August 1936. Dismissed and arrested in April 1937, he was shot that August for allegedly preparing an attempt on Stalin and was never rehabilitated.
Activities and affiliations
-
1917–1937
Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks
Security, intelligence and policing -
1918–1937
Soviet Union state institutionsState security agenciesMain
Security, intelligence and policing
Career Timeline
- 1915.04–1917.03Russian prisoner of war (Katta-Kurgan camp)
- 1917.10–1918.12Assistant military commandant of the Samarkand region; chairman of a field revolutionary tribunal
- 1918.12–1919.12Officer, then head of the secret-operations section, Samarkand regional Cheka
- 1920.05–08Head of the Polish section, political department, 46th Rifle Division
- 1920.09–1922.07Plenipotentiary and head of the 15th special section, Cheka Special Department
- 1922.02–1923.05Deputy chief of the OGPU Operations Department
- 1923.05–1936.11Chief of the OGPU and NKVD Operations Department
- 1924–1937.04Chief of Stalin's security
- 1935–1937Member of the USSR Central Executive Committee
- 1936.11–1937.04Chief of the guard department, then 1st Department, GUGB NKVD
- 1937.04–08.14Expelled, dismissed, arrested and shot
Related historical events
How did a barber become the head of Stalin's guard?
Pauker was born in 1893 in Lemberg (now Lviv) in Galicia, the son of a Jewish barber. After four years of primary school he worked as a theatre barber from 1906, also as a confectioner from 1912, and moved to Budapest, where he was a make-up artist and barber in the theatre. Drafted into the Austro-Hungarian army in 1914, he rose to sergeant before the Russians captured him in April 1915 and sent him to the prisoner-of-war camp at Katta-Kurgan in Turkestan. Released in March 1917, he worked in Samarkand as a tailor and barber.
His career began with the revolution. He joined the Bolsheviks in October 1917, served as assistant military commandant of the Samarkand region and chairman of a field revolutionary tribunal, entered the Samarkand Cheka in December 1918 and in January 1919 became head of its secret-operations section. In 1920 he completed courses at the Sverdlov Communist University, headed the Polish section of the political department of the 46th Rifle Division, and in September moved to the Special Department of the Cheka. He became deputy chief of the OGPU Operations Department in February 1922 and chief in May 1923, and took charge of Stalin's security in 1924.
The story Alexander Orlov tells in the last chapter of The Secret History of Stalin's Crimes differs somewhat. He calls Pauker a Hungarian, dates his capture to 1916 and says nothing of Samarkand. Orlov's Pauker is an ordinary operative doing arrests and searches who, seeing little chance of being noticed, put his old trade to use as barber and orderly to Menzhinsky, the deputy head of the Cheka, and rose from there, even accompanying Menzhinsky to Germany for treatment in 1925. Later writers repeat that Menzhinsky recommended him to Stalin, but on the record Pauker was already running the Operations Department by then.
Orlov also writes that after Lenin's death Menzhinsky removed the guard chief Abram Belenky and installed Pauker. Yet Belenky headed the OGPU special section until October 1928, so the change does not appear to have come at one stroke. Orlov's gloss shows how he saw Stalin: someone devoted to revolutionary ideals could turn against a leader he judged to have betrayed them, whereas Pauker, who cared only for his career, could never end up in the opposition, and that was why Stalin took to him.
Relationship with Stalin
From 1924, Pauker held the most intimate security post in the Soviet leadership: chief of Stalin's personal security. A former hairdresser and make-up artist, he became the only person Stalin ever trusted to shave him. No one else was permitted to hold a blade to Stalin's neck.
Pauker studied Stalin's habits and tastes with meticulous care. According to Alexander Orlov, he noticed that Stalin wanted to appear taller and devised special boots with extra-high heels partly hidden in the back of the boot; he also ordered Stalin's greatcoats to reach the heels. Stalin rewarded him with two cars, a Cadillac and a Lincoln, and Pauker became a conduit for scarce goods and delicacies flowing to Politburo members.
He also served as Stalin's court jester. With his repertoire of accents, especially Jewish impersonations, and his rotund frame squeezed into elaborate OGPU uniforms, Pauker led the Kremlin drinking sessions and invariably played Ded Moroz (Father Frost) at Kremlin children's Christmas parties. Stalin's son Vasily wrote him letters asking for ink; Stalin's niece Kira Alliluyeva recalled that "Pauker was great fun. He liked children like all Jews and did not have a high opinion of himself."
What came under the guard chief's control?
As Orlov tells it, Pauker's power went far beyond guard duty. Lenin had two bodyguards, four after Kaplan's shooting; the guard Pauker built for Stalin ran to several thousand secret agents. The 35-kilometre road from the Kremlin to the country residence alone had more than three thousand agents and motor patrols, and a strange car that stopped for even a minute would be surrounded and its occupants questioned. Orlov writes that Pauker, in an army commander's uniform, always rode beside Stalin, but the personal bodyguard at Stalin's side was someone else: Ivan Yusis from the summer of 1927 and, after Yusis died in 1931, Nikolai Vlasik. Pauker's job was the guard organization as a whole. He took Stalin's special guard out from under the Kremlin commandant's office and moved busy institutions and the VTsIK military school, with its 1,500 cadets, out of the Kremlin.
The Politburo's food, clothes, cars and dachas also passed through his hands. He imported the latest cars, pedigree dogs, fine wines and radios, found Paris dresses and perfume for the wives and expensive toys for the children. Through his guards he also knew the leaders' private lives in detail. Orlov cites Voroshilov's third villa, built for a ballerina, and a Politburo member who sent his mistress's engineer husband to the Solovki camp, and writes that even the leaders had to reckon with Pauker.
This was truer still of Stalin's daily life. No food reached his table and no one entered his homes without Pauker's approval. Pauker imported better varieties of the herring Stalin loved, became his regular vodka companion and kept a fresh supply of bawdy and antisemitic jokes ready. He became almost one of the family: Nadezhda Alliluyeva kept him at a cool distance, but Vasily and Svetlana adored him, and the four agents trailing Stalin's eldest son, Yakov Dzhugashvili, were his responsibility too. Yakov had turned his hair grey, he complained in Orlov's presence: "It's a great misfortune to have such a son."
The price was that he had no time of his own. Only at noon, once Stalin was delivered to his Kremlin office, could he rush to the Operations Department to report to Menzhinsky and Yagoda, and he complained to friends of having no private life, summoned as he was at any hour. After a rail accident, a fire or a collapse in the metro works, his men had to reach the scene first and he had to report the details to Stalin at once. His pleasures were uniforms and the theatre. At parades he stood on the Lenin Mausoleum steps with his belly held in by a corset and wearing gleaming patent-leather boots, and when he had an hour free he appeared in his private box at the opera. Orlov credits him with six decorations including the Order of Lenin, but no Order of Lenin appears in the biographical record. What is documented is two Orders of the Red Banner (1927, 1931), an Order of the Red Star in May 1936 for keeping order at the May Day parade, and two Honoured Chekist badges (1922, 1932).
Records outside Orlov also show his standing. From 1930 he was also deputy chairman of the Dynamo sports society; he became a Commissar of State Security 2nd Rank in November 1935 and sat on the USSR Central Executive Committee from 1935 to 1937. He served on Nadezhda Alliluyeva's funeral commission in 1932, organizing the orchestras, ran security in the Hall of Columns at Kirov's funeral in 1934 and supervised the transfer of Gorky's body in 1936. He also watched over Vasily after his mother's death, and when the boy became unmanageable at school wrote to Vlasik that a transfer was absolutely necessary. According to Montefiore, when Stalin summoned Yezhov to Sochi in September 1936 and Yagoda rushed there after him, it was Pauker who turned Yagoda back from the gates of the dacha.
Orlov also reports a more discreet errand. In 1932 or 1933 Pauker asked Smirnov (Glinsky), the head of Soviet intelligence in Prague, to buy up through intermediaries the erotic drawings of a certain pre-revolutionary artist from Russian émigrés in Czechoslovakia. Smirnov refused, and Slutsky and then Agranov warned him to keep quiet. Orlov writes that he later heard from his superior Alexander Shanin that Pauker bought such pictures for Stalin in many countries. All of this rests on Orlov's word alone.
Why did Stalin slap Pauker and then decorate him?
Orlov places this story in 1927. On the night word came that Chiang Kai-shek had begun mass arrests of Chinese communists and that the Soviet embassy in Beijing had been searched, Stalin, drinking with Pauker, flew into a rage and ordered every Chinese person in Moscow except the embassy staff arrested by morning. Pauker mobilized the OGPU and spent the night seizing everyone from laundry owners to an old professor at the Military Academy, then amused Stalin at breakfast by acting out the scenes.
A few hours later things looked different. A Comintern leader, Piatnitsky as far as Orlov recalls, told Stalin's secretariat that the Chinese working at the Comintern and the students of the Communist University of the Toilers of the East had all been arrested too. When Pauker, summoned, answered that he had taken them from their beds, Stalin struck him in the face, shouted "Fool!" and ordered them released at once.
At one o'clock that night Stalin telephoned in a gentle voice to ask why Pauker had not come for him. At the Kremlin he handed Pauker the Order of the Red Banner for "exemplary fulfilment of an important assignment". Orlov's reading is that Stalin knew how dangerous an insulted bodyguard could be and meant the order to wipe out the insult. OGPU men joked that it should be worn not on the chest but on the injured cheek. The award record does show an Order of the Red Banner in 1927, so the year fits, but that it was given for this incident rests on Orlov's word.
What did Orlov report of Pauker and Nadezhda Alliluyeva?
In Orlov's book Pauker appears as the closest witness to Stalin's private life. When Nadezhda Alliluyeva, with Yenukidze's help, entered a college to study textiles, Pauker is said to have placed two secret agents in her department disguised as students to guard her. When she later heard from two students, who had been mobilized for collectivization, about cases of cannibalism in Ukraine and passed this on to Stalin and Pauker, Stalin ordered Pauker to find and arrest them. With his agents at her side, that was no hard task.
About three months after her death, when guests at his home remembered her as meek, Pauker answered sarcastically that they should have seen her shout in Stalin's face: "You are a tormentor! You torment your own son, your wife, the whole people!" At the funeral Stalin announced he would walk behind the hearse, and Yagoda and Pauker mobilized the Moscow police and thousands of officers from other cities, posting men in every house along the route. But according to Orlov, Stalin walked for some ten minutes, then left the procession with Pauker and drove round to the Novodevichy cemetery.
The book also has him sending an imported radio to Ivan Zaporozhets, exiled over the Kirov case. Orlov reads this as a clue. Since the unwritten rule was to cut ties at once with anyone in disgrace, such a gift meant that Pauker knew Zaporozhets was not really out of favour. Orlov also names Pauker among the four department heads who received no mandate in March 1937, when NKVD officers were lured out on false missions and arrested. All these stories rest on Orlov's word alone.
What stories did Pauker tell about Stalin?
According to Orlov, Pauker was talkative and loved passing Kremlin news to colleagues, and so blindly admired Stalin that it seemed not to occur to him that his stories discredited his master. Orlov sorts them into three kinds: Stalin's cruelty ("Oh, when he loses his temper!"), his political intrigues ("How he fooled them!") and his regard for Pauker ("Excellent work, Pauker!").
Orlov's main example of the first kind dates from the first half of June 1932 at Stalin's residence near Sochi. While Pauker was away in Gagra inspecting a new villa built by Beria, Stalin was woken by a howling dog and ordered it shot. Told the next morning that it was the guide dog of a blind old Bolshevik and had already been taken off toward Gagra, Stalin had the old man and the dog brought back and waited until shots came from the far end of the garden.
The other is a story about fish. At a banquet in a government residence on the Georgian coast, Stalin remarked that another kind of fish tasted better, and Pauker promised it for the next day. Told that the fish lay at the bottom of the lakes in that season, Stalin replied that Chekists should be able to get anything, even from the bottom, and his guards went to a mountain lake with hand grenades. The villagers who lived off the lake drove them away. In the ending Pauker told, Stalin ordered all the villagers except children and the frail old exiled to Kazakhstan for "anti-government mutiny".
How did Orlov report Pauker's end?
Orlov writes that Pauker took no part in preparing the Moscow trials, since guarding Stalin was considered more important. But expecting those involved to receive decorations, he adds, Pauker wanted his share and volunteered to arrest some former oppositionists himself.
Other sources give him a much larger role. As chief of the Operations Department he directed the arrest and exile of the Left Opposition, took part in fabricating the Kremlin Case and the Moscow Centre case, belonged to the group of NKVD officers who prepared the Zinoviev–Kamenev trial and helped organize the Radek–Pyatakov trial in early 1937. Montefiore writes that he attended the execution of Zinoviev and Kamenev on 25 August 1936 alongside Yezhov and Yagoda.
The well-known story of the reenacted execution of Zinoviev also comes from this chapter. Orlov did not see it: he says he heard it in a Paris café in the summer of 1937 from G., a Hungarian secret agent and old friend of Pauker. According to G., at a small banquet on 20 December 1936 for the founding anniversary of the Cheka, Pauker played Zinoviev being dragged to the cellar between two colleagues, and when Stalin laughed the guests demanded it again. This time, instead of falling to his knees, he stood up, stretched his arms to the ceiling and cried out, in words taken from a Jewish prayer, "Hear, O Israel, our God is one God!" Stalin, choking with laughter, signalled him to stop.
Orlov followed what came next from abroad, by rumour. In July 1937 word spread that Pauker had been dismissed, and by the end of the year the whole Kremlin guard command had been replaced. Orlov had thought Stalin would spare a man who had protected him for fifteen years (in fact some thirteen, from 1924); when Yagoda testified at the third Moscow trial in March 1938 that Pauker had been a German spy, he writes, he understood that Pauker was dead. Pauker had by then been dead for seven months.
Why was Pauker arrested, and how was he executed?
After Yagoda was pushed out in September 1936 and Yezhov became People's Commissar, Pauker kept his place for a while. In November he became chief of the guard department, and he went on leading it when it became the 1st Department of the GUGB in December. The turn came when Yagoda was arrested in March 1937 and named him under interrogation. Pauker was expelled from the party and dismissed on 15 April and soon arrested for allegedly preparing an attempt on Stalin. Sources give the arrest date variously as the 15th, 17th or 19th. Yezhov described him as an "old German spy" and the man closest and most devoted to Yagoda.
Stalin is reported to have said later: "How loyal Pauker had seemed... and yet, when I did not appoint him to replace Yagoda, he immediately went over to the Trotskyists." Montefiore's verdict is that he "knew too much and lived too well".
His name appeared on the 'special procedure' execution lists of 16 June and 14 August 1937, with Stalin, Molotov, Zhdanov and Yezhov voting for the first category, meaning death. There was no trial. On 14 August he was shot by Ignatiev, commandant of the Military Collegium of the Supreme Court, in the presence of Deputy Prosecutor Roginsky, Tsesarsky and Blokhin. The 25 people executed that day included his Operations Department deputy Volovich and Volovich's wife, and Shanin, whom Orlov names as the source of the drawings story.
His ashes went into common grave no. 1 for unclaimed remains at the Donskoye cemetery. His decorations had already been revoked by the Central Executive Committee on 7 June, and posthumous rehabilitation was refused. His brother Georgy Pauker was arrested in April 1937 and shot in Leningrad on 27 August; he was later rehabilitated.