Stalin's close friend and the 17-year organizational backbone of the Soviet state, the first fall that opened the Great Purge
Yenukidze's words as Orlov reports them. He urged against executing Kamenev and Zinoviev: "Soso, they are Old Bolsheviks, like you and me." Stalin answered: "Remember, Avel: whoever is not with me is against me."
An Old Bolshevik (party member since 1898), co-founder of the Baku Social-Democratic organization and the underground 'Nina' press in the Caucasus. As Secretary of VTsIK (1918–1922) and then the TsIK of the USSR (1922–1935), he managed the apparatus of the Soviet state's highest formal body for 17 years, across the formation and consolidation of the Union. A close member of Stalin's inner circle and godfather to Nadezhda Alliluyeva, he was the first individual recipient of the Order of Lenin (No. 3). His expulsion in 1935, the first member of the XVII Congress Central Committee to fall, was a significant prelude to the Great Purge.
Also known as: Abdul · Zolotaya Rybka
Activities and affiliations
-
1898–
Russian Social Democratic Labour Party (RSDLP)
Legislature and state representation -
1918–1935
Soviet Union state institutionsSecretary of VTsIK and of the USSR Central Executive CommitteeMain
Legislature and state representation -
Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks
Legislature and state representation
Career Timeline
- 1898Co-founder of the Baku Social-Democratic organization
- 1901–1906Co-founded and ran the underground 'Nina' press in the Caucasus
- 1902–1914Arrested seven times; exiled to Kresty, Metekhi Castle, Onega, Turukhansk
- 1917Petrograd Soviet executive committee, VRK member, October uprising participant
- 1918–1922Secretary of the All-Russian Central Executive Committee (VTsIK)
- 1922–1935Secretary of the Central Executive Committee (TsIK) of the USSR
- 1932First individual recipient of the Order of Lenin (No. 3)
- 1935Expelled from the CC and the party
- 1937Arrested and shot
- 1959Rehabilitated
Related historical events
- 1917.10–1918.01The October Revolutionmember of the Petrograd Military Revolutionary Committee
- 1922.12Formation of the USSRSecretary of the Union Central Executive Committee · administrative architect of the union apparatusHe served as Secretary of the TsIK from the very day the USSR was founded (31 December 1922) until 1935, managing the practical work of union formation and institutionalization. In 1932 he became the first individual recipient of the Order of Lenin (No. 3), awarded for 'exceptional services in the formation of the USSR.'
- 1937–1938The Great PurgeTargetAn Old Bolshevik at the center of the Soviet state apparatus for seventeen years, executed in 1937.
The Kremlin Affair and Downfall
After the assassination of Sergei Kirov in December 1934, the NKVD launched wide-ranging security checks on Kremlin personnel. In early 1935, the 'Kremlin Plot' (Кремлёвское дело) was announced: Mikhail Cherniavsky, an officer who had studied at MIT, was named leader of a 'terrorist' conspiracy to assassinate Stalin, with lax security supposedly allowing the plotters' access. Some 110 people were investigated, including Lev Kamenev's brother. Yenukidze, who oversaw Kremlin security as TsIK Secretary, left that post on 3 March 1935 with an assignment to the Transcaucasian Central Executive Committee. On 21 March, the Politburo circulated the 'Report on the Apparatus of the TsIK and Comrade Yenukidze' to Central Committee members. The report was delivered by Nikolai Yezhov, then newly promoted to CC Secretary, who accused Yenukidze of failing to exercise political vigilance. At the CC plenum of 5–7 June 1935, Yezhov claimed five 'terrorist groups' within the Kremlin had targeted Stalin and directly attacked Yenukidze. The plenum expelled him from the Central Committee and the party for 'political and personal dissolution.' He was the first member of the Central Committee elected at the XVII Congress to fall.
He pleaded with Ordzhonikidze and Voroshilov to spare him the move to Transcaucasia, and on 13 May was demoted to TsIK plenipotentiary for the Mineralnye Vody resort group in the North Caucasus. In a coded message to Kaganovich, Yezhov, and Molotov in September 1935, Stalin called even this appointment a 'mistake' and demanded a further demotion to a minor post in Rostov or Kharkiv. Yenukidze initially ignored the Politburo's order but was ultimately forced to accept the directorship of the Kharkiv regional auto transport trust. Miraculously reinstated in the party at a CC plenum in June 1936, he was arrested in Kharkiv on 11 February 1937 (exactly one week before Ordzhonikidze's death). Beria had already publicly savaged Yenukidze in a July 1935 Tbilisi lecture, denouncing his book 'Our Underground Printing Houses in the Caucasus' for erasing Stalin's revolutionary role; Yenukidze was forced to publish a humiliating retraction in Pravda.
How did Orlov tell of Yenukidze's fall?
Orlov gives Yenukidze a chapter of his book and writes that of all Stalin's killings, none struck him as this one did. To him Yenukidze was Stalin's only disinterested friend since youth. For Stalin's children he was 'Uncle Avel', who swam, skated and told tales of mountain spirits; for Nadezhda Alliluyeva he was the 'guardian angel' who made peace after quarrels and persuaded Stalin to let her study. The wives of arrested men, Orlov says, knew he would find them food and a doctor.
Orlov records his weaknesses too. He enjoyed luxury and power, and a former secretary said that what he liked most was comparing whether his life was better than the tsars'. Orlov describes a day with him in Austria in 1933, when he gave each of a group of Terek Cossacks dancing by the road 100 schillings; told by his bodyguard that they were White Cossacks, he blushed and answered: "They are people too." That was a year's income for a collective-farm family, Orlov calculates. In 1926 he is said to have passed a Politburo seat Stalin offered him on to Kaganovich, a story not confirmed outside Orlov.
Orlov's account of the fall fits the record in some places and departs from it in others. The broad line holds: the January 1935 Pravda article playing down his role in the Baku underground, and the demotion to running a sanatorium after the Transcaucasian posting. But Orlov has him staying two months in Tbilisi, while other sources think he never took up the post. The story of the old Kremlin employee turned into a 'princess' rests on Orlov alone, as does the Politburo anecdote. The cause of the quarrel he gives, the plea not to kill Kamenev and Zinoviev, is likewise a second-hand report of what Yenukidze told his interrogators.
When was he executed?
The charges against Yenukidze kept growing. The investigation cast him as a key figure in the Tukhachevsky 'military conspiracy' who had recruited the Kremlin commandant Peterson. Orlov reports that he burst into tears on hearing the espionage charge. His name appeared on the execution list of 10 July 1937, and Stalin struck it out with the note 'wait for now', apparently hoping to use him as a defendant at the third Moscow trial. Listed again on 21 October, he had his sentence formally confirmed by the Military Collegium on 29 October and was shot on the 30th.
Orlov places the execution in December 1937, because that is what the papers said. On 20 December Pravda reported that the Military Collegium had just tried Yenukidze, Karakhan and others and carried out the death sentences. The notice was false. Most of those named had already been shot between August and October on separate charges. Why Stalin had it published remains unclear.