Clement Greenberg

Independent activity United States Jewish American 1909.1.16.–1994.5.7. ○ Died

American art critic who wrote "Avant-Garde and Kitsch" and championed Abstract Expressionism

Born the eldest son of Jewish immigrants in the Bronx, New York, he graduated from Syracuse University. He began writing while working for federal agencies including the Customs Service, and established himself as an art critic in 1939 with the Marxist-influenced essay "Avant-Garde and Kitsch" in Partisan Review, the anti-Stalinist left magazine. He became an editor of the magazine in 1940, art critic for The Nation in 1942, and associate editor of Commentary from 1945 to 1957. Moving away from his Trotskyism of those years, by the late 1940s he called himself a "disabused Marxist", and in 1950 he joined the American Committee for Cultural Freedom. He championed Jackson Pollock and Abstract Expressionism and built a theory of modernist painting on the concept of "medium specificity".

Also known as: K. Hardesh

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Late 1930s to late 1940s: from Trotskyism to "disabused Marxist"

In the late 1930s Partisan Review held a distinctive place among New York's left intellectuals. Founded in 1934 as the organ of an organisation attached to the Communist Party USA and suspended in 1936, the magazine relaunched at the end of 1937 independent of the party and openly opposed to Communism and Stalinism. It invited Trotsky, then in exile in Mexico, to contribute, and in 1938 published two of his writings on art. A letter Greenberg wrote to the editor Dwight Macdonald led to an invitation to write for the journal, and "Avant-Garde and Kitsch" appeared in the fall 1939 issue, published shortly after the Nazi–Soviet Pact. The essay ends by quoting Marx and saying that today we look to socialism simply for the preservation of whatever living culture we have right now.

From 1940 to 1942 he was one of the magazine's editors, writing on literature, art and sociopolitical matters, often from his then-Trotskyist viewpoint. A 1994 review in Partisan Review describes him as one of the many New Yorkers who, having lived through the Depression, were attracted to Marxism and repulsed by Stalinism, which made him a Trotskyist; by the late 1940s, however, he claimed to be a "disabused Marxist", and in the 1950s he was anticommunist but liberal. At the end of 1950 he became a founding member of the anti-Communist American Committee for Cultural Freedom.

Greenberg himself looked back on those years in his 1961 essay "The Late Thirties in New York":

Some day it will have to be told how ‘anti-Stalinism,’ which started out more or less as ‘Trotskyism,’ turned into art for art’s sake, and thereby cleared the way, heroically, for what was to come.

The art historian T. J. Clark called his position in the 1940s "Eliotic Trotskyism", and scholars have commonly read "Avant-Garde and Kitsch" against Trotsky's theory of art. The Japanese aesthetician Sakai Takahiro argued in a 2026 paper, by contrast, that since only a few Partisan Review writers actually joined Trotskyist parties and their writings hardly ever referred directly to Trotsky's political theories, the "Trotskyism" of the time was largely a label imposed from outside by the Stalinists. He held that the essay should be read in the context of the journal's critique of the Popular Front, the charge that in turning to the Popular Front the Communist Party had abandoned the socialist revolutionary line, rather than through Trotsky's theory of art. Yet that critique, of a Popular Front that put off the revolution for an alliance with the "democratic" bourgeoisie, was also the case Trotsky himself made about the Spanish revolution in 1937. Pointing to a continuity that runs into Greenberg's concept of "positivism" in the 1940s, Sakai also questioned the common narrative of Greenberg's "demarxization" and turn to an apolitical modernism.

From "American-Type Painting" to "Modernist Painting": what was the theory of high modernism?

After the Second World War Greenberg held that the United States had become the guardian of "advanced art". With Harold Rosenberg he led the defence of Jackson Pollock and the other painters of the New York School, abstract expressionism, and in "American-Type Painting" (1955) he presented Pollock, Willem de Kooning, Hans Hofmann, Barnett Newman and Clyfford Still as the next stage of modernist art, moving towards greater emphasis on the "flatness" of the picture plane.

He summed up the idea in "Modernist Painting", delivered in the Voice of America's Forum Lectures in 1960 and printed the following year. There he located the essence of modernism in using the characteristic methods of a discipline to criticise the discipline itself, so as to entrench it more firmly in its area of competence, and called Kant, the first to criticise the means of criticism, "the first real Modernist". Since flatness is the only thing painting shares with no other art, Manet's pictures, which did not hide the flat surfaces on which they were painted, became the first Modernist paintings. He insisted again and again that modernism had never meant a break with the past.

This medium-centred formalism became orthodoxy in American museums and universities in the 1950s and 1960s, and later critics read it as the theory of "high modernism". In the 1960s he argued for the move from abstract expressionism to colour field painting and lyrical abstraction, and gave Pop art a mixed verdict: it tended towards "openness and clarity" against the turgidities of second-generation abstract expressionism, but did not really challenge taste on more than a superficial level. The post-war course of modernism is treated under "Modernism (arts)".