Enrico Berlinguer

Architect of Eurocommunism who led the West's largest non-ruling communist party

In a landmark interview with La Repubblica (28 July 1981), he named the structural corruption of Italy's party system the 'moral question' (questione morale): "Today's parties are above all machines of power and clientelism: scant or distorted knowledge of society and people's lives; ideas, ideals, programs few or vague; sentiments and civic passion — zero." The phrase became a reference point in Italian political discourse for decades.

Born to a noble family in Sassari, he joined the Italian Communist Party (PCI) in 1943 and led the Italian Communist Youth Federation (FGCI) in 1949–1956. Elected to the Chamber of Deputies in 1968, he became party secretary in 1972 and led the party until his death in 1984. In articles in Rinascita analysing the Chilean coup of 1973 he proposed a "historic compromise" with the Christian Democrats, and in the 1976 election he led the party to its all-time peak of 34.4 per cent. He detached the party from Soviet influence, criticised the invasions of Czechoslovakia and Afghanistan and led the Eurocommunist turn. He collapsed during a rally in Padua in 1984 and died.

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

Eurocommunism and the Break with Moscow

Berlinguer's most consequential political legacy was the establishment of the Eurocommunist line. At the 1969 Moscow International Meeting of Communist and Workers' Parties, he openly criticized the Warsaw Pact invasion of Czechoslovakia as 'the tragedy of Prague' and signed only one of the four parts of the final document: a decisive break from Soviet direction. In 1973, while hospitalized after a car accident in Bulgaria, he published three articles in the PCI theoretical journal Rinascita analyzing the Chilean coup. He concluded that a left-wing government alone could not secure a stable transition to socialism and advanced the strategy of a 'historic compromise' with Christian Democracy: a coalition that could resist right-wing backlash. In 1977 in Madrid, together with Santiago Carrillo of Spain's Communist Party and Georges Marchais of the French Communist Party, he issued the joint Eurocommunist declaration, affirming a socialism that guaranteed 'pluralist democracy, a mixed economy, and freedom of thought.' Berlinguer defined the independent task of the Western European workers' movement as overcoming capitalism through 'structural reforms' and building a socialism that absorbed all the democratic values of European civilization. At the beginning of January 1980 the PCI leadership condemned the Soviet intervention in Afghanistan, and Berlinguer criticised the Soviet action in the European Parliament, rejecting the logic of opposing blocs. That year the PCI stayed away from the international conference of communist parties in Paris. After martial law was declared in Poland on 13 December 1981, he said two days later, on 15 December, on the television programme Tribuna politica, that the propulsive force for renewal of the societies born of the October Revolution in Eastern Europe had been exhausted, and proposed a 'third way' distinct from both social democracy and the Eastern European models. At the end of December (29–30 December) the PCI leadership condemned the military coup in Poland and the logic of power in the socialist camp in a document, and when Pravda attacked the PCI on 24 January 1982 an open polemic between the two parties followed.

The lesson of Chile and the "historic compromise", 1973–1980

In 1973 Berlinguer was hospitalised after a car accident during a visit to Bulgaria, which was later claimed to have been an assassination attempt orchestrated by Moscow. When the Allende government in Chile fell to a coup that September, he published three articles in the party's intellectual weekly Rinascita: "Reflections on Italy", "After the Facts of Chile" and "After the Coup". Amid fears, after the Piano Solo and Golpe Borghese plots had come to light, that forces in Italy too were manoeuvring for a coup, he put forward the strategy of a "historic compromise": a coalition of the PCI and the Christian Democrats to give Italy political stability in a time of severe economic crisis.

He wrote that it was ever more urgent to reach "the great new 'historic compromise' between the forces that gather and represent the great majority of the Italian people". It was an illusion, he judged, to believe that even if the left won 51 per cent of the votes and seats, a government expressing that 51 per cent would survive against an opposing front of 49 per cent. Instead of a purely left-wing alternative he therefore proposed a "democratic alternative" of collaboration between communists, socialists and Christian Democrats. The policy was not popular in the party and its base, and Longo, party president from 1972, disliked the word "compromise".

After winning 33.4 per cent in the local elections of 1975 and its all-time peak of 34.4 per cent in the general election of June 1976, the party supported governments of national solidarity from outside in exchange for consultation on policy and social reforms. When the Red Brigades kidnapped the Christian Democrat president Aldo Moro on 16 March 1978, Berlinguer stood with the "front of firmness" that refused to negotiate with the terrorists. He steered the unions towards moderating wage demands amid the inflation that followed the 1973 oil crisis, but Andreotti's government did not reciprocate with sufficient concessions. The party withdrew its support in 1979; austerity, the hard line against the Red Brigades and the courting of the Christian Democrats cost it votes in the 1979 election, and the historic compromise ended in 1980.