The brain a prison was meant to stop: theorist of hegemony

“The old is dying and the new cannot be born; in this interregnum a great variety of morbid symptoms appear.” — Prison Notebooks

Italian Marxist philosopher who theorized hegemony: the insight that rule is maintained not by force alone but through consent organized in civil society. From a fascist prison he wrote the Prison Notebooks, laying foundations for Western Marxism.

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

How did a poor Sardinian boy become a socialist journalist in Turin?

Antonio Gramsci was born on 22 January 1891 in Ales, a small town in Sardinia, the fourth of seven sons. His father Francesco, a low-ranking official from the mainland, came from a family of Albanian descent; his mother was from a Sardinian landowning family. In 1898 his father was imprisoned for embezzlement and the family fell into destitution; young Antonio had to leave school and do odd jobs until his father's release in 1904. A spinal deformity from childhood left him under 150 centimetres tall and badly hunchbacked. It was long blamed on a fall from a nurse's arms, but it may have been Pott's disease, a tuberculosis of the spine. The ill health that dogged him all his life began here.

He finished secondary school in Santu Lussurgiu and Cagliari, where he lodged with his elder brother Gennaro, who had come back from military service on the mainland a militant socialist. Antonio's own sympathies, though, lay with Sardinian autonomism rather than socialism. Islanders' anger that the privileges of the industrialising North had left Sardinia's poor peasants and miners neglected, and the sight of mainland troops crushing their protests, later became the root of his thinking on the "Southern Question".

In 1911 he won a scholarship to the University of Turin; Palmiro Togliatti sat the same exam. He studied literature, took a keen interest in linguistics under Matteo Bartoli, and encountered the philosophy of Benedetto Croce, the dominant figure in Italian intellectual life, and of Antonio Labriola, who had called Marxism a "philosophy of praxis". Turin, where Fiat and Lancia were drawing workers from poorer regions, was the centre of Italy's industrial labour movement. He joined the Italian Socialist Party (PSI) in late 1913, and poverty, illness and politics led him to abandon his studies early in 1915.

From 1914 he wrote for Il Grido del Popolo and the Piedmont edition of the party daily Avanti!, making a name as a journalist, and in 1916 he became co-editor of Avanti!'s Piedmont edition. He covered every side of Turin's social and political life, from theatre criticism to the factories, and in talks for workers' education he spoke on Romain Rolland, the French Revolution, the Paris Commune and the emancipation of women. After the arrest of Socialist leaders following the Turin rising of August 1917, he became one of the city's leading socialists.

On 24 November 1917 he published in Avanti! an article on the October Revolution, "The Revolution against Capital". The fact that revolution had broken out in Russia, where capitalism was underdeveloped, contrary to Marx's predictions, showed, he argued, that the mechanical Marxism which made socialist revolution wait on the full development of the productive forces was wrong. This view of history as made by human will and practice rather than by the automatic working of economic laws runs through all his later thought.

What did L'Ordine Nuovo and the Turin factory councils aim for, and why did they fail?

In May 1919 Gramsci founded the weekly L'Ordine Nuovo (The New Order) with his university friends Togliatti, Angelo Tasca and Umberto Terracini, to introduce news from Russia and Lenin's early writings. At first it leaned towards a cultural review, but in June Gramsci and Togliatti pushed Tasca aside and turned it into an organ of the revolutionary movement. It avoided sectarianism and opened its pages to many currents of Italian society; the liberal Piero Gobetti wrote its theatre criticism.

That summer the "factory council" movement swept Turin's plants. The councils, which workers set up themselves to replace the old internal commissions, aimed to understand the production process and eventually to run it. Gramsci and the Ordine Nuovo group saw them as Italian soviets, the seeds of a future council state. Their distinguishing feature was that workers who did not belong to a union or the Socialist Party could vote too, making them a mass movement that even included anarchists. The councils, he wrote, would prepare "the whole class for the aims of conquest and government".

The idea found little support in the Italian socialist movement, however. Amadeo Bordiga in Naples attacked the councils for sidestepping the question of seizing state power, calling them syndicalist; the Socialist leader Serrati objected to giving votes to unorganised workers; and the General Confederation of Labour put a brake on strikes. The great Turin strike of April 1920 was defeated for lack of support from other labour organisations, a break Gramsci called "the April split", and by then he was almost alone in defending the councils. In September 1920 workers occupied factories across the North, but without political leadership the movement was isolated and petered out.

The failure convinced Gramsci that a Leninist revolutionary party was needed. Lenin and the Comintern's Second Congress in 1920 judged the Ordine Nuovo group's line the closest to the principles of the Third International. Meanwhile fascist squads, tolerated and backed by the state, landowners and industrialists, were burning labour halls and attacking socialists. On 21 January 1921, at the Socialist congress in Livorno, the communist faction broke away to found the Communist Party of Italy (PCd'I). The Ordine Nuovo group allied with Bordiga's much larger abstentionist faction, and Gramsci was part of the founding leadership, but the party was led by Bordiga, with his stress on discipline and purity of principle. Unlike Bordiga, Gramsci supported the Arditi del Popolo, an armed anti-fascist group that fought the Blackshirts.

How did Gramsci, back from Moscow and Vienna, lead the party, and why was he arrested?

In 1922 Gramsci went to Moscow as the party's representative and worked on the Comintern Executive. In a sanatorium there he met the violinist Julia Schucht, whom he married; they had two sons, Delio (born 1924) and Giuliano (born 1926), and he never saw the younger one. That October Mussolini took power after the March on Rome, and the Comintern instructed Gramsci to promote, against the wishes of the party leadership, a united front of left-wing parties against fascism. When the fascist government arrested most of the party's leaders, Bordiga included, in early 1923, Gramsci moved to Vienna at the end of the year to try to rebuild a party torn by factional strife.

In 1924 he was recognised as the party's leader and, elected a deputy for the Veneto, returned to Italy with parliamentary immunity. In February he founded the party daily L'Unità. After the Socialist deputy Giacomo Matteotti was murdered by fascists and the opposition walked out of parliament in protest, the so-called Aventine secession, he argued that the communists had to go beyond passive protest to mass action.

In January 1926 the party's third congress, held secretly in Lyon, France, adopted by more than 90 percent the theses he had written with Togliatti. The Lyon Theses argued that Italy rested on a compromise between northern industrialists and southern landowners, and that fascism was not the expression of the whole ruling class but a product of the urban petty bourgeoisie and agrarian reaction, to be overcome by an alliance of the northern proletariat and the southern peasantry. The congress ended the influence of Bordiga's left, and Gramsci became party secretary. That year, in the unfinished essay "Some Aspects of the Southern Question", he explored the worker–peasant alliance and the role of intellectuals.

In October 1926, on a mandate from the party's political bureau, he wrote to the Central Committee of the Soviet party. The letter criticised the Trotsky–Zinoviev opposition but warned that the way the majority was crushing it could destroy the authority the Soviet party had built up. Togliatti, representing the party in Moscow, withheld the letter and argued against it, and Gramsci sharply rejected his reply. This "October 1926 controversy" left a breach between the two men that never healed.

That autumn, as police pressure tightened, the party planned to move its leading centre to Switzerland, but Gramsci put off leaving. After an attempt on Mussolini's life on 31 October, the government banned all opposition parties under emergency laws. On the evening of 8 November 1926 he was arrested in Rome despite his parliamentary immunity and taken to Regina Coeli prison, along with the entire communist parliamentary group.

How did the trial and eleven years of captivity destroy Gramsci?

After his arrest Gramsci was sent into internal exile on the island of Ustica off Sicily. There he met Bordiga again, and his friend from Turin, the economist Piero Sraffa, opened an unlimited account for him at a Milan bookshop so that he could read. In January 1927 he was moved to San Vittore prison in Milan; the nineteen-day transfer, feverish, chained and in the cold, did lasting damage to his health. From then on his wife's sister Tatiana Schucht looked after him, and she stayed at his side until his death.

In March 1928, as he awaited trial, he received a letter from the party leader Ruggero Grieco. Breaking the underground party's rule against discussing politics openly with prisoners, it marked him as a party leader and so made the charges heavier. For years he agonised over whether it was a betrayal by comrades aimed at him for his 1926 criticism of the Soviet leadership. On 28 May 1928 the newly created fascist Special Tribunal tried him in Rome along with Terracini, Scoccimarro and others, and on 4 June he was sentenced to twenty years, four months and five days. The prosecutor is reported to have said, "For twenty years we must stop this brain from functioning."

He was held at Turi, near Bari. His teeth fell out, his digestion collapsed so that he could not eat solid food, and he vomited blood and suffered convulsions. Political isolation deepened the suffering. When the Comintern's Sixth Congress in 1928 adopted the line that branded social democracy "social fascism", he opposed it, and instead of expecting revolution to follow directly on the fall of fascism he argued for an intermediate "constituent phase" in alliance with non-communist forces. As a result he was ostracised by his fellow communist prisoners; a course of political education he began for them in late 1930 had to be dropped after two weeks amid ridicule. The socialist Sandro Pertini was among those who comforted him then. Outside, Togliatti defended his authority, placing Gramsci's name at the head of the party's fourth congress in 1931 as honorary chairman.

There were several attempts to free him. In late 1927 the Soviet Union tried, through the Vatican, to exchange Gramsci and Terracini for Catholic priests held in Soviet prisons, and in 1934 Italian and Soviet diplomats negotiated, but Mussolini's veto defeated both. Sraffa and Tatiana campaigned internationally for his release. He refused to the end to petition Mussolini for clemency. In November 1933, gravely ill, he was moved from Turi to a clinic in Formia; he was granted conditional release in October 1934 but could not leave the clinic, and in August 1935 he was transferred to the Quisisana clinic in Rome.

On 25 April 1937, just as his sentence was about to end, he suffered a cerebral haemorrhage, and he died early on 27 April, aged forty-six. He had planned to convalesce in Sardinia or to go to the Soviet Union once free. He was suffering from arteriosclerosis, pulmonary tuberculosis, high blood pressure, angina, gout and acute gastric disorders. The regime had moved him from prison to hospital before the end, but his death was directly linked to his prison conditions. Tatiana carried his notebooks to the Soviet embassy for safekeeping, and his ashes were laid the following year in the Non-Catholic Cemetery in Rome.

The Prison Notebooks — thirty-three volumes under censorship

From 1929 Gramsci filled notebook after notebook under the eye of the prison censor. After arriving at Turi he had worked out in his head a plan of study along four lines: the history of Italian intellectuals, comparative linguistics, Pirandello's theatre and popular serial novels. When permission to write finally came on 8 February 1929, he opened the first notebook according to that plan. To slip past the censor he built a camouflage vocabulary (Marxism became 'the philosophy of praxis,' Lenin became 'Ilyich') and the detour sharpened the thought.

His health collapsed at the pace his thinking deepened. While his teeth fell out and his stomach refused food, the notebooks accumulated hegemony, civil and political society, wars of position and of maneuver, the organic intellectual. He analysed the Risorgimento, Italy's unification, as a "passive revolution" from above, and, borrowing from Machiavelli's The Prince, called the revolutionary party "the modern Prince". Some of the notebooks were translation notebooks, filled with his versions of German and Russian texts. When he could no longer write, in August 1935, there were thirty-three notebooks, some three thousand pages.

His sister-in-law Tatiana smuggled them out of the clinic where he died and, through the Soviet embassy, on to Moscow. In postwar Italy his Letters from Prison appeared first, in 1947; then Togliatti and Felice Platone rearranged the notes by theme and published them in six volumes with Einaudi between 1948 and 1951. That thematic edition was criticised for editorial choices shaped by politics, and in 1975 Valentino Gerratana's critical edition, restoring the order in which the notes were written, became the scholarly standard. Since 1996 a state-sponsored national edition of all his writings has been under way. His prison letters to his family and to Tatiana, which grew from 218 in the first 1947 edition to 511 texts in the 2020 critical edition, form a second record of his inner life and thought. The Prison Notebooks became the vocabulary of late-twentieth-century Western Marxism.

Hegemony — rule operates through consent

Gramsci's 'hegemony' goes far beyond mere political leadership. A ruling class does not govern by force and coercion alone. Through civil society (schools, churches, media, trade unions) it establishes its values and norms as 'common sense,' so that the dominated classes voluntarily consent to the existing order. This is the core of hegemony.

Where Lenin used the term narrowly, for the working class's political leadership in a democratic revolution, Gramsci expanded it into a full account of how capitalism secures cultural and ideological dominance. He divided the state into political society (army, police, courts) and civil society, arguing that in the West, unlike Russia, civil society is dense and resilient. A direct revolution (war of manoeuvre) therefore cannot succeed; revolutionaries must first wage a protracted 'war of position,' building counter-hegemony within civil society itself.

This insight answered the question of why revolution had failed in the advanced capitalist West, and became the starting point for late-twentieth-century cultural studies, critical pedagogy, and postcolonial thought.