Avant-Garde and Kitsch · 1939

Avant-Garde and Kitsch

아방가르드와 키치

An essay by the American critic Clement Greenberg, published in Partisan Review in 1939. It argued that industrialisation and urbanisation had produced "kitsch", a mass-produced ersatz culture, and that the avant-garde had withdrawn into the medium of art itself to keep living culture alive amid it. Written under the influence of 1930s Marxism, it charged that totalitarian regimes promote kitsch to ingratiate themselves with the masses, and ended by looking to socialism to preserve living culture. The essay established Greenberg as an art critic.

In depth

Why does the peasant choose Repin over Picasso?

Picture a museum gift shop: mugs, umbrellas and phone cases printed with Van Gogh's The Starry Night. They resemble Van Gogh's painting but have nothing to do with the problems he wrestled with on the canvas. Clement Greenberg would have called them "kitsch". In his 1939 essay "Avant-Garde and Kitsch" he made a thought experiment. An ignorant Russian peasant, given a hypothetical freedom of choice, stands before two paintings, one by Picasso and the other, Cossacks, by the Russian academic painter Ilya Repin. In the Picasso he sees a play of lines and colours that reminds him of the icons of his village. In the Repin he sees a battle scene, and discovers values that seem far superior to those he is used to finding in icons: the vividly recognisable, the miraculous and the sympathetic. He recognises things in the picture as he recognises them outside it; there is no discontinuity between art and life.

For Greenberg this was not the peasant's fault. Repin delivers, predigested, the effects that a viewer of Picasso must draw out for himself; he spares the viewer effort and provides a shortcut to easy pleasure. This is the principle of kitsch. "Avant-Garde and Kitsch" appeared in Partisan Review in 1939, and with this Marxist-influenced essay Greenberg established himself as an art critic.

Why did the avant-garde arise?

Greenberg began from a diagnosis of cultural decline. When religion, authority and tradition are thrown into question, the writer can no longer gauge how his audience will receive his symbols. In the past such a state usually ended in a motionless "Alexandrianism", an academicism that leaves the large controversial issues untouched, follows the precedent of the old masters and dwindles into virtuosity in the details of form. Greenberg held that a part of Western bourgeois society refused this last phase and produced something unheard of: avant-garde culture. A new kind of criticism of society, a historical criticism, made this possible.

The avant-garde abandoned subject matter and withdrew into the processes and disciplines of art itself. If, as Aristotle said, all art is imitation, Greenberg wrote, then the avant-garde is "the imitation of imitating".

the imitation of imitating

Picasso, Braque, Mondrian, Miró, Kandinsky and Brancusi drew their chief inspiration from the medium they worked in; their excitement lay in a pure preoccupation with the invention and arrangement of spaces, surfaces, shapes and colours. But Greenberg also noted a paradox. The avant-garde drew its livelihood from an elite of the ruling class from which it believed itself cut off, and to which it remained attached "by an umbilical cord of gold".

an umbilical cord of gold

With that elite now shrinking, he warned, the survival of the avant-garde, the only living culture left, was under threat.

What is kitsch?

"Where there is an avant-garde, generally we also find a rear-guard." Greenberg called the second new cultural phenomenon that appeared in the industrial West alongside the avant-garde by the name the Germans gave it, kitsch: popular, commercial art and literature with its chromeotypes, magazine covers, illustrations, ads, slick and pulp fiction, comics, Tin Pan Alley music, tap dancing and Hollywood movies.

Where there is an avant-garde, generally we also find a rear-guard.

Kitsch was made for the peasants who settled in the cities as proletarians and petty bourgeois, learned to read and write, but lacked the leisure and comfort to enjoy traditional culture. Greenberg defined it: "Kitsch is vicarious experience and faked sensations."

Kitsch is vicarious experience and faked sensations.

Kitsch uses the debased and academicised simulacra of genuine culture as raw material, operates mechanically by formulas, and remains always the same though its styles change. It demands nothing of its customers except their money. Greenberg went so far as to say that all kitsch is academic and all that is academic is kitsch, but this equation drew heavy criticism and he later withdrew from it.

What did he say about totalitarianism and socialism?

Greenberg held that the regimes of Germany, Italy and Russia all encouraged kitsch: because kitsch is the culture of the masses there as everywhere, and because encouraging it is one of the cheap ways totalitarian regimes seek to ingratiate themselves with their subjects. Since these regimes cannot raise the cultural level of the masses short of surrendering to international socialism, they flatter the masses by bringing all culture down to their level. That, he wrote, is why the avant-garde is outlawed.

The encouragement of kitsch is merely another of the inexpensive ways in which totalitarian regimes seek to ingratiate themselves with their subjects.

This judgement, which put Soviet socialist realism alongside kitsch, was strongly contested from the Soviet side. In "Why Am I Not a Modernist?" (1963) Mikhail Lifshitz first gave voice to the objection: "But didn't Hitler persecute so-called modern art and declare it a plague and degeneracy?" Lifshitz answered with an anecdote: when a Nazi regional government closed the Bauhaus in 1932, the Paris journal Cahiers d'art, a champion of Cubism, lamented that it could not understand the National Socialist party's hostility to modern art. In his conclusion Greenberg invoked Marx: "Today we no longer look toward socialism for a new culture… Today we look to socialism simply for the preservation of whatever living culture we have right now."

Today we look to socialism simply for the preservation of whatever living culture we have right now.

What became of Greenberg and the essay?

Greenberg became an editor of Partisan Review in 1940 and art critic for The Nation in 1942, and was associate editor of Commentary from 1945 to 1957. In December 1950 he joined the government-funded American Committee for Cultural Freedom. After the war he argued that the best avant-garde artists were emerging in America rather than Europe and championed Jackson Pollock as the greatest painter of his generation; in "American-Type Painting" (1955) he presented the Abstract Expressionists' movement towards the "flatness" of the picture plane as the next stage of modernism. The concept of "medium specificity", that each medium has inherent qualities and that modernism means ever greater commitment to them, also came from him.

From the mid-1970s it was argued that in the early 1950s the CIA saw Abstract Expressionism as a symbol of free thought and free markets and promoted it through the Congress for Cultural Freedom. Frances Stonor Saunders's The Cultural Cold War treated this in detail; on the other side Michael Kimmelman, chief art critic of The New York Times, countered that this revisionist interpretation was false or decontextualised. From the standpoint of the art market Lifshitz wrote in The Crisis of Ugliness that "the total value of the paintings in Jackson Pollock's posthumous exhibition of 1963 is estimated at five million dollars". For him the picture trade was a case of the rule of capital, summed up in his remark that "the transformation of the battle of talents and trends into a kind of stock-market game began as early as the end of the last century, in the days of Durand-Ruel and Vollard". Greenberg later came to regard his definition of kitsch as ill thought out, and located the threat to high art rather in middlebrow taste, which lies closer to the academic. Even so, the essay remains the first to define the avant-garde's social and historical context.

Related people

Sources

  1. alchemists.com
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. Wikipedia (EN)