Commercial Reasonableness
상업적 합리성
An administrative criterion for deciding whether a Korea-US strategic investment project proceeds. Under the 2026 enforcement decree of the Korea-US Strategic Investment Special Act, it is satisfied when the total expected income distributed to Korea over the project's expected lifespan can fully cover the principal and interest of that investment. The interest rate is the 20-year US Treasury yield at the time of each investment plus a spread agreed between Korea and the US. The decree also provides for separate review of a project's impact on national security or supply chain stability, opening a pathway for projects whose commercial reasonableness is not secured to proceed on strategic grounds.
In depth
Formation and codification
At the October 29, 2025 announcement of the Korea-US tariff agreement details, Presidential Policy Chief Kim Yong-beom said the two sides agreed to pursue only projects with commercial reasonableness guaranteeing recovery of principal and interest and to write this into the MOU. The term first entered Korea-US negotiations at that point. The MOU concluded on November 14, 2025 covered $200 billion in direct US investment plus $150 billion in shipbuilding cooperation investment, a total of $350 billion.
The Korea-US Strategic Investment Special Act passed the National Assembly on March 12, 2026 with 226 votes in favor of 242 voting, was promulgated on March 17, and took effect on June 18, 2026. It establishes governance, a dedicated corporation and fund, and National Assembly controls. On June 9, 2026, the Cabinet (25th meeting) deliberated and resolved the enforcement decree, which concretizes the definition of commercial reasonableness and the procedures for deciding its details; the decree took effect with the special act on June 18, 2026.
Decision procedure and exception pathway
Review operates at two tiers. The Korea-US Strategic Investment Project Management Committee, chaired by the MOTIR minister, conducts the first review including commercial reasonableness, and the Steering Committee, chaired by the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Economy and Finance, makes the final resolution on whether to proceed. When a candidate project for which commercial reasonableness is not secured is put to the Steering Committee, the Project Management Committee must review and report the project's impact on national security or supply chain stability. Under the special act, where investment proceeds despite commercial reasonableness not being secured, on national-security or supply-chain grounds, prior consent of the competent National Assembly standing committee is required, and the Assembly must be briefed before consultations with the US begin.
The Korea-US Strategic Investment Corporation is the institutional apparatus for the standard. It operates for 20 years from registration with 2 trillion won in statutory capital paid in cash by the government in installments, and reporting to the National Assembly and consultations with the US government occur before projects are finalized. The corporation was officially launched in June 2026, and its first head of strategic investment, Kim Kyung-han, resigned about two months after appointment.
Applications and distinction from the generic sense
As of late September 2026 the government was negotiating with the US to announce the first US-investment project, with Korea proposing energy on commercial-reasonableness grounds while the US showed interest in semiconductors and domestic production and employment; the launch slipped from late August-early September to September. The core of the $350 billion investment turns on narrowing the gap between the US demand for an expanded US industrial base and Korea's emphasis on commercial reasonableness.
The generic sense to be distinguished is a standard used in commercial and financial disputes whose meaning derives from commonly accepted business customs and practices in the relevant industry. It is rarely decided as a matter of law and often requires fact-intensive proof and expert testimony. Official Comments to the UCC state that reasonableness should be defined by commercial rather than legal standards, and contract language and the common law are further sources. The standard is central to, or in the shadow of, most commercial and financial disputes, may render a transaction unenforceable if absent, and courts increasingly merge the good-faith finding with evidence of commercial reasonableness based on established industry practices.
The Korean statutory standard is an administrative gateway for state-backed overseas strategic investment, deciding whether a project proceeds and whether guarantees or policy finance are provided, whereas the common-law standard governs the conduct of commercial parties and the enforceability of transactions.
How does it fit economic history and political economy?
The standard stands out in political economy because it shows together the direction of money and who bears the risk. Its language comes first. A definition under which a project is reasonable if total expected income can cover the principal and interest of the investment asks whether money advanced returns with interest. That is the same question as the circuit of interest-bearing capital Marx drew in chapter 21 of volume III of Capital, in which money passes across and returns as M+ΔM, the principal plus interest. Setting the rate by the 20-year US Treasury yield in effect takes the return on holding Treasuries as the baseline.
Next comes direction. In chapter 4 of Imperialism Lenin described the export of capital as surplus capital going abroad to backward countries in search of profit, and wrote that the creditor secures "some extra benefit", such as a favourable clause in a commercial treaty, in return for a loan. The $350 billion US investment touches the questions of this tradition as large state-backed overseas investment, but its direction is reversed. The money goes into the world's largest economy, and the investing country is closer to offering it to avoid tariffs than to extracting terms.
Positions therefore divide on what counts as reasonable. The South Korean government presented the standard as part of "multilayered safeguards" raising the likelihood of recovering principal. The annual payment cap of $20 billion, the 50-50 split of returns until principal is recovered and the adjustment of that split if recovery looks difficult belong to the same account. An analysis from the Korea Economic Institute of America sees it differently: the United States selects projects, South Korea provides the funds and 90 percent of returns go to the United States after break-even, while the threat of tariffs makes it hard for South Korea freely to reject risky projects, which creates a potential moral hazard. The same analysis also notes that the deal may help South Korea avoid higher tariffs and lower the cost of capital for strategic investments.
The standard thus sits where capital's measure of profitability meets the state goal of production and employment inside the United States. As noted above, the pathway for going beyond it on security and supply-chain grounds shows that this boundary is not drawn by commercial judgement alone.
Sources
- view.asiae.co.kr 아시아경제, 2026.06.09: 시행령의 핵심은 대미 투자 사업의 추진 여부를 판단할 잣대인 '상업적 합리성'의 기준을 명문화한 점. 상업적 합리성을 개별 대미투자 사업의 예상 존속기간 동안 한국으로 분배되는 총 예상 수입이 해당 투자의 원리금을 전부 충당할 수 있는 경우로 규정.
- thedailyeconomy.kr The Daily Economy, 2026.06.09: 수익성이 충분하지 않은 사업이라도 국가 전략적 필요성이 인정될 경우 별도 검토가 가능하도록 한 조항 확인.
- en.yenisafak.com Yeni Şafak/AA, 2026.06.09: A project will be considered viable if expected returns allocated to South Korea are sufficient to cover both principal and interest over the investment period. Interest calculations based on 20-year US Treasury yields plus agreed spread.
- clsbluesky.law.columbia.edu Columbia Law School Blue Sky Blog, 2025.12.12: Steven L. Schwarcz, 'Commercial Reasonableness' — the standard derives its meaning from commonly accepted business customs and practices; its application as a gateway criterion in statutory schemes discussed.
- motir.go.kr
- korea.kr
- en.yenisafak.com
- clsbluesky.law.columbia.edu
- yna.co.kr
- lawtimes.co.kr
- news1.kr
- Marxists Internet Archive
- Marxists Internet Archive
- asiae.co.kr
- keia.org