Critical realism (Bhaskar)
비판적 실재론 (바스카)
The philosophy of science and of social science founded by the British philosopher Roy Bhaskar in the 1970s. It holds that the world is stratified into structures and mechanisms that exist and operate independently of our knowledge (ontological realism), and that knowledge of them is socially produced and fallible (epistemic relativism). It criticises turning questions about being into questions about knowledge as the "epistemic fallacy", and argues that social science can contribute to emancipation by exposing the sources of false beliefs. It is widely used in Marxist social theory, and is distinct from other positions of the same name in the philosophy of perception and in Russian writings of the revolutionary era.
In depth
Do laws work outside the laboratory?
In the laboratory a physicist drops a feather and a steel ball in a vacuum tube without air resistance and shows that they fall together. Outside the laboratory the feather drifts in the wind and the steel ball lands first. Is the law of gravity then true only in the laboratory? Surely not. Gravity works outside too; it merely overlaps with other forces so that the visible result differs.
The British philosopher Roy Bhaskar drew a large conclusion from this ordinary fact. If experiments are to make sense, what science seeks must be not regularities of events, "whenever A, then B", but mechanisms of nature that operate constantly inside and outside the laboratory. And those mechanisms must exist whether or not we observe them. The philosophy that starts from this thought is critical realism.
What did Bhaskar argue?
In his first book, A Realist Theory of Science (1975), Bhaskar called this position "transcendental realism". Like Kant he used a transcendental argument, asking what the world must be like for science to be possible, but unlike Kant he found the answer not in the forms of the subject but in the structure of the world. In The Possibility of Naturalism (1979) he extended it to the social sciences under the name "critical naturalism". "Critical realism" is an elision of the two names, proposed by others and accepted by Bhaskar.
First, knowledge has two dimensions. The "transitive" dimension is the theories, concepts and evidence produced by social activity. The "intransitive" dimension is the world itself to which that knowledge refers. Bhaskar's starting point is a paradox: people create knowledge as a product of social activity, yet that knowledge is of things not produced by people at all. He accepted Thomas Kuhn's insight that scientific communities develop knowledge, without holding that the community also makes the objects of that knowledge.
Second, the world is stratified. Bhaskar divided it into nested domains of the real, the actual and the empirical. The empirical is the events people actually experience; the actual is the full set of events that occur, whether or not anyone is aware of them; the real also includes the objects, structures and causal powers that produce those events. In the feather example the mechanism of gravity belongs to the real, the drifting of the feather to the actual, and the scene we saw to the empirical.
Third, one must guard against the "epistemic fallacy". Bhaskar's name for reducing statements about being to statements about knowledge, or analysing them in those terms, was the epistemic fallacy, which he held had been committed repeatedly over the last three hundred years of philosophy of science. In his own words, the epistemic fallacy "consists in the view that statements about being can be reduced to or analysed in terms of statements about knowledge".
consists in the view that statements about being can be reduced to or analysed in terms of statements about knowledge
Fourth, society is reproduced and transformed by human activity. Bhaskar rejected the methodological individualism that explains social events purely in terms of facts about individuals, while accepting that society has no material presence apart from persons and the products of their actions. Society is a condition of human action, and human action is a condition that continually reproduces and transforms society. He called this the "transformational model of social activity".
Why "critical"?
Bhaskar held that science need not stop at describing facts but can move on to evaluations. The logic is the "explanatory critique" he worked out in Scientific Realism and Human Emancipation (1987). Other things being equal, a science that explains that something produces false beliefs gives grounds for a negative evaluation of that source and a positive evaluation of action to remove it. He later extended this logic to the sources of failures to meet human needs. In English Wikipedia's example, it becomes an argument that capitalism should be removed because it causes human suffering, not because it misleads people. Bhaskar claimed that this refutes "Hume's law", that an ought cannot be derived from an is.
In this respect critical realism is close to Marx. Among the ten main influences on his early work Bhaskar named Marx, particularly his conception of praxis, and structuralists such as Althusser. His ontology, which separates surface appearances from the hidden structures that produce them, fits well with Marx's analyses, such as commodity fetishism and the value form, showing that social reality may differ greatly from its empirical surface. English Wikipedia writes that critical realism has become the ontological root of some contemporary Marxist political and economic theory, and that Alex Callinicos defends a critical realist ontology while acknowledging Bhaskar's influence.
What criticisms were there, and how did it divide?
The criticisms fall into two lines. One comes from positivism and empiricism: positing unobserved mechanisms and a "domain of the real" is unverifiable metaphysics. Bhaskar answered that experimentation, the actual activity of science, presupposes such mechanisms. The other comes from social constructionism and post-structuralism: if knowledge is socially produced, speaking of a reality independent of knowledge is itself just one perspective. Against this critical realism upholds "judgmental rationality", that although knowledge is fallible one can judge some accounts to be better than others.
There were internal divisions too. With Dialectic: The Pulse of Freedom (1993) Bhaskar moved into "dialectical critical realism" and called Marx "a proto-dialectical critical realist". But the "spiritual turn" that began with From East to West: Odyssey of a Soul (2000) divided his supporters. Callinicos acknowledged Bhaskar's influence while rejecting this spiritual turn.
How does it differ from other "critical realisms" of the same name?
"Critical realism" is also used in other senses. In the philosophy of perception the name refers to the view that some sense data are accurate to external objects, and Lenin's Materialism and Empirio-criticism and the debates around it feature a "critical realism" in a different sense, as in the Russian Machist Pavel Yushkevich's book Materialism and Critical Realism. English Wikipedia notes that Bhaskar's critical realism should not be confused with Lukács's aesthetics or with theological critical realism either. Nor did Bhaskar coin the name: the American Donald Campbell used it earlier, in the 1970s. This entry covers the current that began with Bhaskar and was continued by sociologists such as Margaret Archer.
Where is it used today?
Since Bhaskar, critical realism has become a major strand of social scientific method, standing against positivism and empiricism on one side and post-structuralism and interpretivism on the other. Margaret Archer's morphogenetic approach, Cambridge social ontology, critical discourse analysis, critical realist feminism and critical realist Marxism build on it. In 2016 nine scholars including Archer summed up what the various versions share as four tenets: ontological realism, epistemic relativism, judgmental rationality and cautious ethical naturalism. In Korea too, Bhaskar's Scientific Realism and Human Emancipation (in Korean as 『비판적 실재론과 해방의 사회과학』) and several introductions have been translated.