European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC)
유럽석탄철강공동체 (ECSC)
The first supranational European organization, established by the 1951 Treaty of Paris, which integrated the coal and steel industries of France, West Germany, Italy, Belgium, the Netherlands, and Luxembourg into a single common market. It was run by an appointed High Authority designed to uphold the common interest rather than national interests, and it originated in Robert Schuman's declaration of 9 May 1950, which sought to make war between France and Germany 'not only unthinkable but materially impossible' by pooling coal and steel production. It provided the institutional model for the European Economic Community (EEC) created by the 1957 Treaty of Rome and was dissolved when the treaty expired in 2002.
In depth
Why was pooling coal and steel a question of peace?
The wars of the first half of the twentieth century were fought with coal and steel. Steel became guns, tanks and warships, and coal was the fuel that made the steel. The largest concentration of both in Europe was Germany's Ruhr, whose great industrial combines (Konzerne) had underpinned the military power of Imperial and Nazi Germany. After France and Germany had fought three wars in seventy years, the question of who controlled their coal and steel was the question of whether another war was possible.
France's first answer after the Second World War was to hold Germany down. In March 1945 Pierre Mendès France wrote that one of France's main war aims was to transfer part of the Ruhr's steel capacity to Lorraine. The Ruhr was placed under the International Authority for the Ruhr set up by the Allies, and some German plant was dismantled as reparations. But once the Cold War began and West Germany rose again as part of the Western camp, a policy of keeping Germany permanently in check could not last.
The turn came with the declaration of the French foreign minister Robert Schuman on 9 May 1950. Schuman proposed placing the whole of Franco-German coal and steel production under a common "High Authority", in an organisation open to other European countries. Pooling production would make war between the two "not only unthinkable but materially impossible". Jean Monnet worked out the plan, and the West German chancellor Konrad Adenauer agreed at once. The European Union commemorates 9 May as Europe Day.
How did the Community work?
Negotiations opened on 20 June 1950, and on 18 April 1951 France, West Germany, Italy, Belgium, the Netherlands and Luxembourg signed the Treaty of Paris. The treaty came into force on 23 July 1952; the common market for coal opened on 10 February 1953 and the one for steel on 1 May 1953. Customs duties, subsidies and discriminatory freight rates between the members were abolished.
At the centre stood the nine-member High Authority. Its members were appointed by the governments but swore to defend the general interest of the Community rather than their national interest, and they could hold no other business interests during their term and for three years afterwards. Its first president was Jean Monnet. Beside it stood a Common Assembly of national parliamentarians, a Special Council of national ministers, a Court of Justice of seven judges, and a Consultative Committee of producers, workers, consumers and dealers. The High Authority could levy up to one percent on coal and steel sales, often called Europe's first common tax.
The United States carried great weight in the negotiations. Though not formally a party, the US High Commissioner in Germany, John J. McCloy, and his adviser Robert Bowie drafted the articles banning cartels and the abuse of monopoly power that became the basis of the treaty's competition rules. At American insistence the German coal sales monopoly was broken into four independent sales agencies, the steel giant Vereinigte Stahlwerke into thirteen firms and Krupp into two. Breaking up the combines that had sustained the war became part of the peace plan.
Who opposed it, and why?
Opposition came from both left and right. Kurt Schumacher, leader of West Germany's Social Democratic Party (SPD), held that a "Little Europe of the Six" would block the party's first aim, German reunification. He argued that the Community would end hopes of nationalising the steel industry and lock in a Europe of "cartels, clerics and conservatives". The German Trade Union Confederation (DGB), by contrast, took part in the negotiations, parted ways with the SPD, and won trade-union codetermination in the Community's institutions in return.
In France the Communists opposed it, and the East German government called the Community the armament base of the aggressive North Atlantic pact. Seen from the Eastern bloc, the Schuman Plan was a device for reintegrating West Germany's heavy industry into the US-led Western camp. On the right, Charles de Gaulle mocked it as "le pool, ce faux semblant" (the pool, that sham), argued that the French government was too weak to lead it, and held that it lacked supranational legitimacy because its Assembly had not been approved by a European referendum. The Gaullists voted against ratification in the French lower house.
The British prime minister Clement Attlee refused to join, saying he would not accept the British economy being handed over to an authority "utterly undemocratic and responsible to nobody". The coal and steel industries were also vocal in their opposition. Even so, the treaty was ratified by strong majorities in all eleven chambers of the six parliaments.
What did it achieve, and where did it fall short?
Many judge the economic results smaller than hoped. Writing in Le Monde in 1970, the French journalist Gilbert Mathieu argued that coal and steel output followed world trends more than the Community. From 1952 oil, gas and electricity competed with coal, and the 28 percent fall in coal mined in the Six had little to do with the treaty. On the other hand, abolishing discriminatory railway tariffs made steel trade grow tenfold, and the High Authority issued 280 modernisation loans. Mathieu also noted that the Community did not prevent the large coal and steel groups from re-emerging, so that cartels and price fixing returned, and that it never defined a common energy policy.
In social policy the results were clearer. Over fifteen years the Community financed 112,500 flats for miners and steelworkers, and it paid half the redeployment costs of workers who lost their jobs as pits and steelworks closed. Together with regional redevelopment aid it created around 100,000 jobs, a third of which went to unemployed coal and steel workers.
Crises exposed its limits. After miners' strikes in Belgium in 1959, the three Benelux states asked for a "manifest crisis" to be declared under Article 58 of the treaty, giving the High Authority strong powers such as production quotas and compensation payments, but West Germany, France and Italy refused. A manifest crisis was declared only in October 1980, when demand for steel collapsed: by Decision 2794/80 the Commission imposed production quotas on steel firms. An institution founded on a free common market became, in a crisis, one that allocated production directly.
What is its place in the history of European integration?
The Coal and Steel Community served as the model for the European Economic Community (EEC) and the European Atomic Energy Community created by the Treaty of Rome in 1957. The Merger Treaty, signed on 8 April 1965, combined the institutions of the three Communities, and the High Authority, Common Assembly, Council and Court became the prototypes of today's European Commission, European Parliament, Council of the European Union and Court of Justice. The fifty-year Treaty of Paris expired on 23 July 2002, and that day the Community's flag was lowered for the last time outside the European Commission in Brussels.
Judgements depend on the point of view. Schuman and his supporters held that the Community brought peace to Europe, pointing to the long peace the six founding states have enjoyed since. The German historian Nikolaus Bayer sees Adenauer's main aim as the quick return of West Germany as an equal member of the Western community of states. The same scholarship holds that the Community took on elements of liberal capitalism strongly backed by the United States while also marking one of Europe's first steps towards emancipation from the United States.
From the critical side, the Coal and Steel Community was a product of the Cold War. In the SPD's critique it sped up West Germany's integration into the West and its reconstruction while narrowing the road to German reunification and the nationalisation of basic industry; the Eastern bloc saw it as the economic base of the Atlantic alliance. Because coal and steel were where the management of cross-border capital and corporate ties by a supranational body was first tried out, the Community is also the starting point of the debate over the nature of today's European Union.
Related people
Sources
- Wikipedia (EN) Founding, institutional structure, Schuman Declaration origins, six member states, Treaty of Paris (1951), expiry in 2002, and role as precursor to the EEC and EU.
- ebsco.com Summary of the ECSC's establishment, Schuman Plan, Jean Monnet's role, Marshall Plan context, and the ECSC as the first major effort at European economic federalism.
- centre-robert-schuman.org 75th anniversary overview confirming the ECSC as the foundation of European integration, proposed by Robert Schuman on 9 May 1950.
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (EN) negotiations from 20 June 1950, McCloy and Bowie's anti-trust articles, DKV split into four sales agencies, Vereinigte Stahlwerke into thirteen firms, SPD and Schumacher's opposition, de Gaulle's "le pool, ce faux semblant", Attlee, common markets of 1953, institutions, Mathieu's 1970 assessment, housing and redeployment, 1 percent levy, expiry on 23 July 2002
- fr.wikipedia.org Mendès France in March 1945 on transferring part of the Ruhr's steel power to Lorraine, communist opposition in the French Assembly, Schuman's proposal of a High Authority, Bech's provisional seat in Luxembourg
- de.wikipedia.org entry into force 23 July 1952, GDR description as armament base of the North Atlantic pact, SPD opposition over reunification, DGB codetermination, Monnet's draft of 20 June 1950, Bayer and Herbst on its significance, Merger Treaty of 8 April 1965, 1959 coal crisis and the Benelux demand for a manifest crisis under Article 58
- Wikipedia (EN) Monnet became the first president of the ECSC High Authority in 1952
- lagen.nu Court of Justice, Case 270/82 (Estel v Commission), 1984: manifest crisis in the steel market under Article 58 ECSC, Decision 2794/80/ECSC of 31 October 1980 establishing steel production quotas from 1 October 1980, followed by Decision 1831/81/ECSC