Idealismus / idealism / идеализм · Concept

Idealism (philosophy)

관념론

The philosophical position that mind, consciousness or ideas are the basis of the world or fundamental to what constitutes it. It is not the everyday "idealism" of pursuing high ideals. It is often divided into subjective idealism, which refers the world to individual perception, and objective idealism, which takes as fundamental an idea or spirit beyond the individual.

In depth

What question does idealism answer?

You may have seen a film in which a character realises that the whole world has been a dream or a simulation, or heard it said that "the world depends on your state of mind". Idealism is not such an impression pushed to the limit as a philosophical thesis. Most idealists do not say the desk does not exist or that bumping into it does not hurt. They ask where the order and meaning of what we call reality come from, and whether it can be spoken of apart from mind.

This word too must be kept apart from everyday use. The high purpose of the political "idealist" is one thing and philosophical idealism another. As Engels pointed out, in philosophy idealism names the position that asserts the primacy of mind over nature. The name itself came late. In the German-speaking world Leibniz first used it as a philosophical term in the early eighteenth century.

What did idealism look like from Plato to Berkeley?

Plato is famous for the allegory of the cave in Republic VII. Prisoners bound to face a wall take the shadows on it for real things. One who is freed and goes outside learns that the shadows were only shadows. Plato says: "Compare our nature to such an experience."

ἀπείκασον τοιούτῳ πάθει τὴν ἡμετέραν φύσιν

The individual things we see change and pass, but the Ideas (Forms) they copy do not change and exist more truly. Since the Ideas were thought to lie outside my head and not to be my thoughts, this is the distant ancestor of what would be called objective idealism.

In the modern period idealism became a problem of epistemology. Locke said that what we directly know are the ideas in our minds. The Irish bishop George Berkeley drew a bold conclusion. If things are bundles of perceived ideas, matter apart from perception is a needless assumption. The argument is simple. To say a desk exists means that I see and touch it, or would if I were in the room, and talk of things existing with no relation to perception is unintelligible. The motto came in Latin words: the being of things is to be perceived.

Their ESSE is PERCIPI

What then of a tree in a forest no one sees? Berkeley replied that God always perceives it, and by this argument he meant to pull up the idea of matter as the root of atheism. Such a position is called subjective idealism. Lenin opens Materialism and Empirio-criticism with Berkeley, arguing that Mach's calling things "complexes of sensations" repeats him.

What did Kant and German idealism change?

Kant took pains to distinguish himself from Berkeley, and in the second edition added a section, the Refutation of Idealism, to remove any trace of the subjective idealism that doubts or denies external objects. He did not deny that things exist. He argued that the form of the objects we experience, space, time, cause and effect, is contributed by our cognitive faculty. This is transcendental idealism. It is often explained by the image of someone who cannot take off a pair of spectacles: the world always appears through them, and the thing-in-itself beyond them cannot be known.

Fichte, Schelling and Hegel tried to remove this unknowable remainder, a story told under German Idealism. In Hegel's absolute idealism the whole history of the world becomes the process in which the Idea unfolds and comes to know itself. In this system cognition is not passive dictation but a process of wrestling with the object, like labour, and the world develops through contradiction. Here is the source of the dialectic Marx rescued as a "rational kernel".

How did materialism criticise idealism?

Engels's criticism has two layers. First, idealism is a refined form of "creation of the world". If mind comes first, one must finally say in some form that the world came from mind, and he remarked that with philosophers such as Hegel this creation is often "far more tangled and impossible" than in Christianity.

diese Schöpfung ist oft bei den Philosophen, z.B. bei Hegel, noch weit verzwickter und unmöglicher als im Christentum

Second, practice shows daily that the world is independent of our thoughts. Lighting a fire or synthesising a dye succeeds only when the laws of things have been grasped correctly.

Lenin put a sharper question. One section of Materialism and Empirio-criticism is titled "Did Nature Exist Prior to Man?" How can "complexes of sensation" account for natural science's conclusion that the earth existed before people? He also held that there is no neutrality in philosophy and that idealism ultimately opens the way to fideism.

Yet Marxism did not simply throw idealism away. In the Theses on Feuerbach Marx acknowledged that idealism had developed the active side, and Lenin changed his assessment in the notes he took while reading Hegel: "Intelligent idealism is closer to intelligent materialism than stupid materialism is."

Умный идеализм ближе к умному материализму, чем глупый материализм.

On the next line he rereads "intelligent" as dialectical and "stupid" as metaphysical and undeveloped. In On the Question of Dialectics (1915) he writes that philosophical idealism is mere nonsense only from the standpoint of crude, simple, metaphysical materialism.

Философский идеализм есть только чепуха с точки зрения материализма грубого, простого, метафизичного.

To dialectical materialism it is one side of cognition detached from matter and blown up into an absolute. So within this tradition "materialism or idealism" remained not only a badge of camp but a task: how to explain the activity of cognition materialistically. Ilyenkov's discussion of the ideal is the leading example.

In the USSR the word also served beyond philosophical classification as a political brand. "Menshevizing idealism", pinned on the Deborinites in 1930–1931, was such a case. When Stalin ended the dispute by decree in 1931, the Deborinites lost their influence.

How did other traditions see idealism?

In early twentieth-century Britain Moore and Russell revolted against the Hegelian idealism then dominant in the universities, and analytic philosophy began. New realists and Marxists were also among the critics. Contemporary philosophers point out that "idealism" is a word whose meaning is always fixed by contrast with its opponent, whether realism or materialism. It is worth remembering that traditions of "mind only" existed outside the West too, as in the Yogācāra school of Indian Buddhism.

Related people

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN)
  2. web.archive.org
  3. de.wikipedia.org
  4. raw.githubusercontent.com
  5. gutenberg.org
  6. web.archive.org
  7. plato.stanford.edu
  8. Wikipedia (EN)
  9. leninism.su
  10. leninism.su
  11. leninism.su
  12. Wikipedia (RU)
  13. Wikipedia (EN)