Kantō Massacre
간토 대지진 조선인 학살
The killing of large numbers of Koreans across the Kantō region by officials and vigilante groups in the chaos after the Great Kantō earthquake of 1 September 1923, driven by false rumours that "Koreans have poisoned the wells" and that "Koreans and socialists have risen and are setting fires". Chinese people and Japanese mistaken for Koreans were also killed, and in the same chaos officials killed socialists in the Kameido and Amakasu incidents. Death tolls differ widely by source and author, and the exact number is unknown.
In depth
How did the rumours spread?
After the annexation of 1910 the land survey cost many Korean farmers their land and many moved to Japan and Manchuria; the Korean population of Japan, about 40,000 in 1920, was growing fast. Having put down the March First Movement of 1919 in blood, the Japanese government was wary of Korean resistance. Rumours circulated from 1 September, the day of the earthquake, and police officers as well as residents went about warning against Koreans. At about 5 p.m. on the 2nd the Metropolitan Police ordered every station to clamp down on "malcontents", and policemen on motorcycles and bicycles went round announcing a Korean uprising. The same day a notice went out in the name of Gotō Fumio, head of the Home Ministry's Police Bureau, saying that Koreans were setting fires in many places and should be strictly controlled; it was carried to the naval wireless station at Funabashi and telegraphed to prefectural governors across the country on the 3rd. According to the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture the telegram also went to the Governments-General of Korea and Taiwan, and the Home Minister of the day, Mizuno Rentarō, had been Vice Governor-General of Korea and the police chief, Akaike Atsushi, head of its police bureau. Martial law was declared on the 2nd and extended to Kanagawa on the 3rd and to Saitama and Chiba on the 4th.
Who killed, and how?
Vigilante groups formed everywhere after the earthquake, 1,593 in Tokyo Prefecture and 3,689 across Kantō, and armed themselves as the rumours spread. They picked out Koreans by making passers-by say phrases such as "fifteen yen fifty sen". The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture writes that in Tokyo and Kanagawa, where the killing began, the army and police were at its centre, and in Chiba and Saitama the vigilantes. Even the martial-law records count at least 39 Koreans killed by the army and about 215 killed by soldiers and civilians together. In Saitama, on 4 September, Koreans being moved by the police towards Gunma were killed at Kumagaya (46), Jinbohara (35) and Honjō police station (86). Koreans and Chinese sent "for protection" to the former prisoner-of-war camp at Narashino were in part killed on the way and in the camp.
Why were Chinese and Japanese killed?
On 3 September, at Ōshima on the eastern edge of Tokyo, soldiers, police and crowds took Chinese labourers from their lodgings and killed them. Most were workers from Wenzhou, and the dead are put at anywhere from nearly 200 to 400. The student Wang Xitian, who had been helping them, came from Changchun, had arrived in Japan about the same time as Zhou Enlai, and was one of the leaders of the Tokyo demonstration during the May Fourth Movement of 1919; as secretary of the Chinese YMCA he had founded a mutual-aid society for Chinese workers. He was seized when he went to Ōshima to see to the society, and before dawn on 12 September a lieutenant of the 1st Heavy Field Artillery Regiment cut him down. Survivors on a repatriation ship that reached Shanghai on 12 October made the facts known and the affair became a diplomatic issue; on 7 November a meeting of five ministers, among them Prime Minister Gonnohyōe Yamamoto and Home Minister Shinpei Gotō, decided on a cover-up. In December a Chinese government mission led by Wang Zhengting arrived, and in May 1924 the Japanese government decided to pay 200,000 yen in consolation money, but negotiations broke off with the civil war in China and no compensation was paid. The Chinese known to have been killed number more than 600.
Japanese mistaken for Koreans died too. On 6 September, in Fukuda village in Chiba, fifteen medicine pedlars from Kagawa were attacked by vigilantes and nine were killed. The authorities also used the confusion to kill socialists. At Kameido police station ten labour activists, among them Yoshitora Kawai and Keishichi Hirasawa, were killed by a cavalry regiment (the Kameido Incident), and on 16 September the military police captain Masahiko Amakasu and his men killed Sakae Osugi, Noe Itō and a young nephew (the Amakasu Incident). The massacre of Koreans and these two cases have long been called the three great massacres of the earthquake; counting the massacre of Chinese separately makes four.
How many died?
Sources differ widely. The Justice Ministry report counted 233 Korean victims in killings by civilians that led to prosecution; the Home Ministry gave 248, and the Government-General of Korea's police bureau, from an inquiry by its Tokyo staff, estimated about 813. Sakuzō Yoshino reported 2,613 from what a Korean relief team told him, and The Independent, paper of the Korean Provisional Government in Shanghai, printed 6,661 from a relief team made up mainly of Korean students in Japan. English-language overviews estimate about 6,000. A report by an expert committee of Japan's Cabinet Office Central Disaster Management Council wrote that "there were many cases in which the term massacre is apt".
How did the government handle it?
On 5 September the martial-law headquarters secretly resolved to investigate Korean violence so as to establish it as fact, and to spread abroad the claim that communist Japanese and Koreans had incited the violence from behind. On the 7th an emergency ordinance for the maintenance of public order was issued, the forerunner of the Peace Preservation Law of 1925. The Home Ministry's Police Bureau barred the press from printing anything about Koreans, and when the ban was lifted on 20 October the killings by the army and the authorities were concealed and the blame placed on the vigilantes. The government arrested 735 participants from 18 September, but the sentences were reportedly light. The Government-General of Korea paid 200 yen in condolence money to each of 832 victims' families. On 20 October the Justice Ministry announced that some arson and murder by Koreans had been real, and repeated statements to that effect; Tanzan Ishibashi, the lawyer Tatsuji Fuse, Sakuzō Yoshino and others criticised the announcement. Yoshino's article "The Massacre of Koreans" was cut from the book it was written for after censorship.
What did it leave to the movements?
On 16 March 1924 the Tokyo Korean Labour League and the Japan General Federation of Labour jointly held a memorial meeting in Tokyo attended by about 150 Koreans, some 30 Chinese and 200 Japanese. There Kim Chon-hae proposed that the federation protest to the Japanese government against the massacre of Koreans, but its officers did not agree. In China, opinion that had been raising relief money for the earthquake changed sharply with the reports of the killings. The Japanese government has never carried out an official inquiry. Some deny the massacre: the non-fiction writer Miyoko Kudō, for one, argues that the killings were self-defence against real riots.