高麗共産黨 (上海派) · 1921–1922

Korean Communist Party (Shanghai faction)

상하이파 고려공산당

A Korean communist party organised in Shanghai in May 1921 by Yi Tong-hwi on the basis of the Korean Socialist Party. It is called the Shanghai faction to distinguish it from the Korean Communist Party formed in Irkutsk at the same time. As the rivalry between the two factions intensified, the Comintern dissolved both parties in December 1922.

In depth

According to the Korean source, the Shanghai faction of the Korean Communist Party was a socialist organisation formed in Shanghai, China, in 1921 around Yi Dong-hwi, on the basis of the Korean Socialist Party founded on 11 May 1918. Yi had left the Provisional Government at the end of January 1921 after clashing with President Syngman Rhee and with Yi Dong-nyeong, Yi Si-yeong, Shin Kyu-sik and others over its reform, then set about founding the party, describing this as a shift from a “national movement” to a “social movement”. Its leading figures were Yi Dong-hwi, Kim Rip, Pak Chin-sun and Yi Han-yŏng.

The delegate meeting that opened in Shanghai on 20 May 1921 brought together some thirty delegates of Korean communist groups from inside Korea and from China, Manchuria and Japan. Eight delegates of the Social Revolutionary Party from Korea (Kim Cheol-su, Yi Bong-su, Ju Jong-geon and others) joined and took seven of the twelve seats on the central committee and every post in the home bureau. Kim Man-gyeom, An Byeong-chan, Yeo Un-hyeong and others who had worked with the group in its earlier form left, on the other hand, and made up the Shanghai branch of the Irkutsk faction, of which Kim Dan-ya, Im Won-geun and Pak Hon-yong were members.

The party's programme divided the revolution into two stages. The New History of Korea quotes these words from it:

National liberation is the premise of social revolution.

The idea was that a national revolution to throw off Japanese rule came first and would grow over into the dictatorship of the proletariat. The party was therefore eager for a broad alliance with the nationalists. Its entry into the Provisional Government came from this line, and so did its proposal at the later unity congress in Verkhneudinsk to include even the gradualist advocates of a cultural movement in the united front. The Irkutsk faction opposed both.

The party was closely linked with Voitinsky, secretary of the Comintern’s Far Eastern Bureau, and had ties with Chinese and Japanese socialists and with Jang Deok-su and Ch’oe P’al-yong at home. In Irkutsk, meanwhile, a congress of Korean communists on 4–17 May 1921 formed a rival Korean Communist Party. The two factions competed for recognition and support from the Soviet government and the Comintern, and their struggle over command of Korean armed units led to the Free City Incident of 1921.

The party's strength came from the fact that Pak Chin-sun, Han Hyeong-gwon and Kim Rip handled all diplomacy with Soviet Russia. They also held the receipt and distribution of the money Moscow had promised. Inside Korea the home branch of Jang Deok-su, Kim Myeong-sik and others used the Dong-A Ilbo as its platform and led the youth movement through the Seoul Youth Association and the Federation of Korean Youth Associations. But the money twice became a source of trouble. The Provisional Government's side held that Yi Dong-hwi's group had kept funds meant for the government, and in 1922 the "sham communist party affair" broke inside Korea, in which the home leaders were accused of spending the money as they pleased and were driven out of the youth organisations. The National Institute of Korean History's chronicle says the charge of embezzlement was not true, but also judges that the party was a loose organisation far from a Bolshevik vanguard party and that Yi Dong-hwi may well have regarded socialism as a means to independence.

When its calls for reconciliation and unification failed, the Comintern dissolved both parties in December 1922 and in February 1923 set up the Korburo under its Far Eastern Bureau to organise a unified communist party. The Korean source judges that the unprincipled factional strife between the Shanghai and Irkutsk groups harmed not only the early communist movement but the national liberation movement as a whole.

Communists of several countries were involved in the Comintern's handling of the two parties. In November 1921 a commission of Béla Kun, Kuusinen and Safarov ruled that the two should form a provisional centre with equal numbers from each. The joint congress at Verkhneudinsk in October 1922 became a congress of the Shanghai faction alone when the Irkutsk faction refused to go on with it. The Fourth Congress of the Comintern in November and December 1922 set up a Korean commission of eight, among them Sen Katayama, Chen Duxiu, Kuusinen and Voitinsky, which reached no conclusion, and in December the order came to dissolve both parties. Yi Dong-hwi entered the Korburo and left it in December 1923. The Shanghai faction's people afterwards allied with the Seoul faction inside Korea (Kim Cheol-su's "Seoul-Shanghai cooperation") and after the December Theses took part in the movement to rebuild the party as the Seoul-Shanghai group.

Members

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (KO)
  2. Wikipedia (KO)
  3. Wikipedia (KO)
  4. contents.history.go.kr
  5. contents.history.go.kr
  6. contents.history.go.kr
  7. contents.history.go.kr
  8. contents.history.go.kr
  9. encykorea.aks.ac.kr