Korean social formation debate
한국 사회구성체 논쟁
The debate that South Korea's progressive scholars and movement activists carried on from the mid-1980s to the early 1990s over the character of Korean society and the path of its transformation; in Korean it is abbreviated sagusche nonjaeng. It began in 1985 in the journal Changbi (Creation and Criticism), where Park Hyun-chae's theory of state monopoly capitalism was set against Lee Dae-geun's theory of peripheral capitalism, and went on to oppose the theory of a colonial semi-feudal society (later "colonial semi-capitalism"), which saw South Korea as an American colony, to the theory of neo-colonial state monopoly capitalism, which saw it as a dependent monopoly capitalism. The former became the theoretical ground of the National Liberation (NL) wing, the latter of the People's Democracy (PD) wing. The debate died down as actually existing socialism collapsed in 1989–1991.
In depth
What was at issue
"Social formation" is the Marxist term for the whole make-up of a society, its economic structure together with the politics and ideas resting on it. The questions of the debate come down to three. What stage has Korean capitalism reached? Is South Korea, in relation to the United States, a colony or a formally independent neo-colony? And is the first contradiction for the movement to resolve the national one, between imperialism and the nation, or the class one, between capital and labour? Because the answer about the character of society decided whom to fight and whom to ally with, the theoretical debate was at the same time a dispute over line among the movement's organisations.
Background
The movement radicalised after the suppression of the Gwangju Uprising of May 1980. The Murim–Hakrim debate in the student movement in the early 1980s and the C-N-P debate inside the Youth Federation for the Democratization Movement, Mincheongnyeon (civil democratic, national democratic and people's democratic revolution) were the earlier stages. Around 1984 one side defined South Korea as a neo-colony of American imperialism and put the anti-imperialist struggle first, while the other, the Committee for the Promotion of Democratisation, defined Korean capitalism as "neo-colonial state monopoly capitalism". The former became the National Liberation (NL) group; the latter became the Constituent Assembly (CA) group and, after 1987, came to be called People's Democracy (PD).
Changbi, 1985
The debate reached the public page with the feature "The Debate on Korean Capitalism" in issue 57 of Changbi in 1985. Park Hyun-chae argued that South Korea had already reached the stage of state monopoly capitalism, in which the state and monopoly capital are intertwined; Lee Dae-geun questioned this from the standpoint of peripheral capitalism. That theory, rooted in Latin American dependency theory, holds that capitalism cannot develop normally in a periphery subordinated to the centre. Park's own argument was not simple: he located the basic contradiction in capitalism while naming anti-feudal democratic transformation as the task set by the principal contradiction.
Colonial semi-feudal society versus neo-colonial state monopoly capitalism
Through the June Struggle of 1987 the debate spread deep into the movement, and its axis shifted to the opposition of two theories.
The theory of a colonial semi-feudal society saw South Korea as a colony of the United States and its society as semi-feudal, with feudal remnants intact. The revolution was therefore one of national liberation, driving out imperialism and clearing away feudal survivals. The definition goes back to the view of the colonies taken by the Sixth Congress of the Comintern in 1928, that imperialism allies with feudal forces to block capitalist development in a colony, and it is linked to the Chinese revolution's definition of a "semi-colonial and semi-feudal society". Criticised for being unable to explain the growth of Korean capitalism, the NL wing took up Juche and moved to a theory of "colonial semi-capitalism". That theory became known through "Looking Again at Korean Society", a document issued in the second half of 1987 by the National Democratic Front of South Korea, which claimed to be the successor of the Revolutionary Party for Reunification, and one participant has testified that most of the counter-criticism came from the North. For that reason the debate has also been seen as the first debate over the line of transformation between South and North since the Korean War. Ahn Byung-jik, who represented the colonial semi-feudal theory in academia, abandoned it in 1989 with his essay on the Korean economy as "middle-level capitalism".
The theory of neo-colonial state monopoly capitalism answered as follows. Dependency cannot be denied, but South Korea is not a colony as under Japanese rule, so it is a neo-colony. Korean capitalism has not been blocked; monopoly has grown stronger and fused with the state, so it is state monopoly capitalism. The thesis of "stronger monopoly, deeper dependency" was worked out by Yoon So-young and the group around the journal Reality and Science (ten volumes, 1988–1991) and by the Seoul Institute of Social Sciences. Yi Jin-kyung's Social Formation Theory and the Method of Social Science (1987), which criticised Park Hyun-chae's version of state monopoly capitalism, became required reading in this current. The anti-imperialist, anti-monopoly people's democratic revolution that was the PD wing's programme came out of it. The National Democracy (ND) group of Yi Jong-ro (Baik Tae-ung), Park No-hae and others around the journal Labour Liberation Literature claimed, for its part, to have been the first to adopt the theory, and found the distinguishing mark of Korean state monopoly capitalism in the low productivity that came from subordination.
Decline and assessment
From the late 1980s to the early 1990s most of the intellectuals and activists of the progressive camp took part in the debate. Park Hyun-chae and Cho Hee-yeon collected the texts in the four volumes of The Debate on the Korean Social Formation. But as actually existing socialism collapsed between 1989 and 1991, the debate cooled quickly. Cho Hee-yeon judged that it had done much to make the movement scientific, but that it drifted into reductionism and theoreticism and that its bitterness hampered solidarity among movement groups. Others point out that, looking only at structures inside one country, it failed to grasp the advance of neoliberalism in the 1990s. Its vocabulary fell out of use, but the division between the NL and PD wings remained as the factional map of the progressive parties and of the labour and civic movements.
Roots abroad
Most of the theories the debate drew on came from outside. The colonial semi-feudal theory rested on the definitions of the Comintern and the Chinese revolution, peripheral capitalism on Latin American dependency theory, and state monopoly capitalism on Soviet Marxist political economy, whose research trends Reality and Science made it its business to introduce. How to judge feudal remnants and external dependency was also the question addressed by the Debate on Japanese Capitalism and the Debate on the Nature of Chinese Society in the 1930s.