Law of the Tendency of the Rate of Profit to Fall
이윤율 저하 경향의 법칙
A central crisis theory in Marxian political economy holding that as capital accumulation proceeds, the organic composition of capital (c/v) rises, causing the average rate of profit to fall. Individual capitalists invest in labor-saving technology to survive competition, earning short-term superprofits, but once the technology is generalized throughout the economy, the share of living labor (v), the sole source of surplus value, shrinks relative to total capital, depressing the rate of profit. Marx formulated this as a 'tendency' rather than an iron law in Volume III of Capital, and enumerated six counteracting factors: intensified exploitation, reduction of wages below the value of labor power, cheapening of constant capital elements, growth of a relative surplus population, foreign trade, and the expansion of joint-stock companies.
In depth
Origins and Formulation
While classical economists such as Adam Smith, David Ricardo, and John Stuart Mill recognized the falling rate of profit as an empirical phenomenon, Marx was the first to systematically explain it through the inherent contradictions of capitalist accumulation. He expressed the rate of profit as p′ = s / (c + v) and argued that because technological progress has a long-term labor-saving bias, c/v rises and p′ tends to fall.
Theoretical Controversy
In 1961, Nobuo Okishio published the 'Okishio theorem,' arguing that if real wages remain constant and a new technique satisfies the cost criterion, the rate of profit will rise. John Roemer modified Okishio's model to include fixed capital and concluded that a falling rate of profit cannot be demonstrated in a competitive equilibrium framework with constant real wages, though different assumptions might yield different results. Michael Heinrich and others have argued that Marx did not adequately prove the TRPF once productivity increases are accounted for. This debate remains one of the sharpest theoretical struggles within Marxian economics.
Empirical Research
Since the 1970s, empirical studies have proliferated. Michael Roberts, Minqi Li, and Deepankar Basu have presented findings supporting the TRPF, while Òscar Jordà, Marcelo Resende, and Simcha Barkai have reported contrary results. And the methodological disputes over measurement and data interpretation continue.
The Debate over the 2008 Crisis
The global financial crisis of 2007–2009 reopened the debate over the law. In The Failure of Capitalist Production (2011) Andrew Kliman argued that the profit rate of US corporations fell after the slumps of the 1970s and early 1980s and never recovered in a sustained way under neoliberalism. Because low profitability held back investment and bred debt-fuelled bubbles, he treated the fall in the rate of profit as an indirect cause of the Great Recession.
Other Marxists held that the profit rate had been fully or partly restored under neoliberalism and looked for the crisis in finance. Costas Lapavitsas stressed the mechanism of financialisation by which a capitalist's profitability rises with leverage, the ratio of borrowed to own capital, while giving little weight to post-war profit trends. The British Marxist Joseph Choonara summed up the debate as a clash between a position stressing long-term tendencies in production, chiefly a post-war fall in the profit rate never fully reversed, and one concentrating on the financial dimension of the crisis that downplays the falling rate of profit.
Related terms
Related people
Related historical events
Sources
- Wikipedia (EN) definition, historical formulation by Marx, the six counteracting factors, Okishio's theorem, empirical research survey, and mathematical formulation p′ = s/(v+c)
- Wikipedia (RU) Russian-language article confirming Soviet/Russian Marxist usage of the term
- de.wikipedia.org
- marxisthumanistinitiative.org
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Marxists Internet Archive
- Marxists Internet Archive