modernité

Modernity

근대성

The conditions of life and the experience that people undergo in modern society: the state in which rank and tradition collapse, cities, markets and machines keep overturning everyday life, and everything grows old almost as soon as it appears. The socio-economic processes that produce this condition (industrialisation, urbanisation, the world market) are called "modernisation", and the responses of art and thought to it "modernism". The word spread after the poet Charles Baudelaire defined it in 1863 as "the transitory, the fugitive, the contingent"; on the Marxist side, Marshall Berman and Perry Anderson argued over its meaning in the 1980s, taking the portrait of capitalism in The Communist Manifesto as their starting point.

In depth

What was a painter in Paris in 1863 supposed to paint?

Around 1860 the streets of Paris had a painter named Constantin Guys. Instead of large museum canvases he made newspaper illustrations and quick sketches of carriages, soldiers, dandies and the women of ballrooms and cafés. The poet Charles Baudelaire saw in him the model of a new art. The essay he wrote between late 1859 and early 1860 and published in three instalments in Le Figaro in November and December 1863 is "The Painter of Modern Life". The painter appears only as "M. G.", because Guys could not bear to have his name made public.

To Baudelaire the painters of his day were lazy. They painted people of the present yet dressed them in the costumes of the Renaissance, the Middle Ages or the Orient, and declared the clothes of their own time simply ugly. He named what Guys was looking for as he roamed the streets:

"He is looking for that something which we may be allowed to call modernity; for there is no better word to express the idea in question. The point, for him, is to draw out of fashion whatever poetry it may hold within the historical, to extract the eternal from the transitory."

Il cherche ce quelque chose qu’on nous permettra d’appeler la modernité ; car il ne se présente pas de meilleur mot pour exprimer l’idée en question. Il s’agit, pour lui, de dégager de la mode ce qu’elle peut contenir de poétique dans l’historique, de tirer l’éternel du transitoire.

Then comes the definition quoted more often than anything else in the essay:

"Modernity is the transitory, the fugitive, the contingent, the half of art whose other half is the eternal and the immutable."

La modernité, c’est le transitoire, le fugitif, le contingent, la moitié de l’art, dont l’autre moitié est l’éternel et l’immuable.

Baudelaire warned that the painter who studies only the old masters loses "the memory of the present": the folds of a crinoline, the sleek line of a new steamship or a thoroughbred at the races cannot be learned from Rubens or Van Dyck. Modernity is here first of all an experience: what passes quickly in the streets of the metropolis, the fashion that will be gone next month, the face met by chance. Art should seize that transience, not flee it.

As for the word, the French noun modernité was first used, disparagingly, by Chateaubriand in 1849, but it was Baudelaire who gave it its present weight. He lived from 1821 to 1867, and the poems of The Flowers of Evil sang of how the nature of beauty changed in a city being transformed by Haussmann's renovation of Paris; "Haussmann's renovation of Paris" treats that physical change. In the 1930s Walter Benjamin took this Baudelaire as his guide in the Arcades Project, his attempt to write the primal history of capitalist modernity.

How do modernity, modernisation and modernism differ?

The three words are often mixed up, but they name different things. By analogy: modernisation is the bulldozer that turns the ground over, modernity is the experience of the person living in the middle of the building site, and modernism is the poems, pictures and buildings that person makes of that experience.

Modernisation is a socio-economic process: industrialisation, urbanisation, migration, the growth of nation states and bureaucracies, incorporation into the world market. After the Second World War American social science formalised it as "modernisation theory". Scholars such as Seymour Martin Lipset and Walt Rostow held that traditional societies move through stages of economic growth to a Western-style modern society and democracy. The theory was the dominant paradigm of the social sciences in the 1950s and 1960s and a prescription against Marxism, and it underlay foreign-aid policies such as the Kennedy administration's Alliance for Progress. Against it André Gunder Frank and others argued that the underdevelopment of poor countries came not from too little modernisation but from the way they had been integrated into the world system. That debate is treated under "Dependency theory" and "World-systems theory".

Modernity is the condition of life and the experience that this process produces. Classical sociology disagreed about its core. Marx and Engels tied the emergence of modern society above all to the development of capitalism; Émile Durkheim saw it in industrialisation and the new division of labour, Max Weber in the rise of a distinctive way of thinking, rational calculation. Weber held that rationalisation, carried to its end, traps people in an "iron cage" (or "steel-hard casing") of rule-based rational control.

Modernism is the response of art, culture and thought to that experience. It includes the currents that, from the late nineteenth to the mid-twentieth century, broke with inherited forms in literature, art, music and architecture; the details are under "Modernism (arts)".

The same pairing continues afterwards. The style of art and culture that appeared from the 1970s is called "postmodernism", the term that characterises the era producing it "postmodernity", while the philosophical current that arose in France at the same time is named separately as "Post-structuralism". These distinctions are treated under "Postmodernism".

Korean translations differ too: social science usually renders modernity as geundaeseong, but many translations, including the Korean title of Habermas's The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity, use hyeondaeseong, and some simply write moderniti, because the English "modern" covers both the Korean geundae (the modern era) and hyeondae (the contemporary).

How did The Communist Manifesto portray the modern age?

Marxist discussion of modernity almost always returns to one passage in the first chapter of The Communist Manifesto (1848):

"The bourgeoisie cannot exist without constantly revolutionising the instruments of production, and thereby the relations of production, and with them the whole relations of society." "All fixed, fast-frozen relations, with their train of ancient and venerable prejudices and opinions, are swept away, all new-formed ones become antiquated before they can ossify. All that is solid melts into air, all that is holy is profaned."

Alle festen eingerosteten Verhältnisse mit ihrem Gefolge von altehrwürdigen Vorstellungen und Anschauungen werden aufgelöst, alle neugebildeten veralten, ehe sie verknöchern können. Alles Ständische und Stehende verdampft, alles Heilige wird entweiht, und die Menschen sind endlich gezwungen, ihre Lebensstellung, ihre gegenseitigen Beziehungen mit nüchternen Augen anzusehen.

The German verb verdampft means "evaporates", and what evaporates is "everything of the estates and everything standing still" (das Ständische und Stehende): the feudal order of ranks and whatever does not move. Samuel Moore's English translation of 1888 rendered the phrase "All that is solid melts into air", and English-language discussion of modernity has used that sentence as its motto ever since.

In this passage Marx and Engels do not simply denounce the bourgeoisie. The same chapter says that the bourgeoisie "has been the first to show what man's activity can bring about", and also that it stripped the doctor, the lawyer, the priest, the poet and the man of science of their halo and turned them into its paid wage labourers. This doubleness, liberation and destruction as two faces of one process, is what Berman later put at the centre of his theory of modernity.

Why did Marshall Berman call Marx a modernist?

The American political philosopher Marshall Berman published in New York in 1982 the book he had written between 1971 and 1981. Its title, All That Is Solid Melts into Air: The Experience of Modernity, comes from the English wording of the Manifesto; the Korean edition took its title from the subtitle, The Experience of Modernity. At its beginning and end he defines modernity like this:

"To be modern, I said, is to experience personal and social life as a maelstrom, to find one's world and oneself in perpetual disintegration and renewal, trouble and anguish, ambiguity and contradiction: to be part of a universe in which all that is solid melts into air. To be a modernist is to make oneself somehow at home in the maelstrom."

To be modern, I said, is to experience personal and social life as a maelstrom, to find one's world and oneself in perpetual disintegration and renewal, trouble and anguish, ambiguity and contradiction: to be part of a universe in which all that is solid melts into air. To be a modernist is to make oneself somehow at home in the maelstrom

In Berman's view twentieth-century thought had split into two sealed compartments, "modernisation" in economics and politics and "modernism" in art, culture and sensibility, and could not connect them. He sought to tie them together again through the middle term of modern experience, and named Marx as the thinker who had done this best: Marx hoped to heal the wounds of modernity not by abandoning it but through a fuller and deeper modernity.

The book has five parts. The first reads Goethe's Faust as "the tragedy of development". The aged Faust undertakes a vast project of reclaiming land from the sea, and the cottage of an old couple standing in his way is burned down. Berman saw this as the prototype of the giant development schemes the Saint-Simonians dreamed of, and argued that capitalist and socialist, developed and developing models of development all share this "Faustian model". As examples of "pseudo-Faustianism", which borrowed only its outward show, he cited Stalin's White Sea Canal, Soviet collectivisation and the Shah of Iran's development policies. The second part is about Marx and the Manifesto. The third reads Baudelaire as "the first modernist" and looks at how the boulevards Haussmann cut through Paris changed the social relations of its people. The fourth treats St Petersburg, built on a swamp by imperial command, as the most dramatic instance of "modernisation imposed from above", and reads its literature from Gogol and Dostoevsky to Osip Mandelstam as "the modernism of underdevelopment". The last part deals with Robert Moses, the New York planner whose expressways cut through the neighbourhoods of the Bronx, and with the streets of New York in the 1960s and 1970s. Berman himself grew up in that Bronx.

Berman wrote that reading the Manifesto closely also raises questions about Marx's answers. In a world where all new relationships grow old before they can ossify, what is to prevent the forces that melt capitalism from melting a communist society too? If solidarity and fraternity were to be protected by restricting expression, would that not betray Marx's aim of the free development of each? Berman concluded that Marx's dialectic of modernity re-enacts the fate of the society it describes, generating energies and ideas that melt it down into its own air.

What did Perry Anderson object to?

The British Marxist historian Perry Anderson took up the book directly in "Modernity and Revolution", a lecture printed in New Left Review 144 (March to April 1984). He first granted that its imaginative sweep, breadth of cultural sympathy and force of textual intelligence would surely make it a classic in its field. Then he reconstructed Berman's argument. For Berman modernity is neither the economic process (modernisation) nor the cultural vision (modernism) but the historical experience that mediates between them, and the link is the concept of "development": at once the gigantic objective transformations of society unleashed by the world market and the subjective self-development individuals undergo under their impact.

Anderson's criticism centred on periodisation. Because Berman bound everything from about 1500 to the present into one modern experience, he could not explain why modernist art exploded in one particular period. Anderson proposed a conjunctural explanation instead: modernism is a cultural field of force triangulated by three coordinates. The first is a highly formalised academicism, institutionalised in the states of pre-1914 Europe where aristocratic and landowning classes, economically overtaken, still set the political and cultural tone; here he drew on the historian Arno Mayer's The Persistence of the Old Regime (1981). The second is the still incipient, and therefore novel, emergence of the key technologies of the second industrial revolution: the telephone, radio, the automobile, the aeroplane. No mass-consumption industries based on them yet existed anywhere in Europe before 1914. The third is the imaginative proximity of social revolution, symbolised by the Russian Revolution of 1905 to 1907, which drew the attention of all Europe. Academicism gave the new arts a common enemy, the new technologies gave excitement, and revolution gave an open expectation whose outcome was still uncertain. Berman's reply summarises the argument as the claim that "the intersection between a semi-aristocratic ruling order, a semi-industrialized capitalist economy, and a semi-emergent or insurgent labour movement" nourished Cubism, relativity, psychoanalysis, The Rite of Spring and Ulysses. If those conditions disappeared after the Second World War, the art that followed could not have the same force. His conclusion, as Berman's reply quotes it: "What marks the situation of the Western artist is . . . the closure of horizons: without an appropriable past, or an imaginable future, in an interminably recurrent present."

What marks the situation of the Western artist is . . . the closure of horizons: without an appropriable past, or an imaginable future, in an interminably recurrent present.

In the same issue Berman published "The Signs in the Street: A Response to Perry Anderson". He granted that Anderson's historical analysis of the modernism of 1890 to 1920 was plausible, but called the conclusion that creation ended when those conditions vanished a leap: disappointment had always been a source of creativity. Disappointment with democratic Athens produced The Trojan Women and Plato's Republic; disappointment with the French Revolution produced Romanticism. Quoting Baudelaire's "The Heroism of Modern Life" of 1846, that city life is full of poetic and marvellous subjects we simply fail to see, Berman laid out scenes of a New York graduate student and of the streets like a collage, to show that modernism is still happening in our streets and in our souls.

The difference between the two shows two attitudes within Marxism. Berman saw modernity as an open experience that people can still make their own; Anderson saw it as a historical phenomenon bound to a particular conjuncture of class relations. In The Origins of Postmodernity (1998) Anderson later used the same method of periodisation to write the history of the postmodernism debate.

Is modernity over?

When from the late 1970s people speaking of the "postmodern" claimed that the whole project of modernity was finished, modernity returned to the centre of debate. In "Modernity: An Unfinished Project", his speech on receiving the Theodor W. Adorno Prize in 1980, the German philosopher Jürgen Habermas took aim both at the neoconservative currents critical of modernity and at the newly rising postmodern philosophy. He held that the Enlightenment is an "unfinished project" to be corrected and completed rather than discarded, and broadened this idea in The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity (1985). The postmodernist case and the Marxist assessments of it are treated under "Postmodernism".

In his preface to the 1988 reprint Berman likewise wrote that postmodernists maintain the horizon of modernity is closed and its energies exhausted, that modernity is passé, which clashes head-on with his own view that modern life, art and thought have a capacity for perpetual self-critique and self-renewal.

"Modernity" was also called up again as a problem of planning. In Seeing Like a State (1998) the political scientist James C. Scott gave the name "high modernism" to the overconfidence of states in their ability to design and run society by scientific laws; Brasília, built in the wilderness as a purely administrative capital, is its standard example. The word is the same as the "high modernism" of art criticism, meaning post-war American abstract painting and International Style architecture, but the meaning differs; the artistic high modernism is treated under "Modernism (arts)".

On the Marxist side, modernity is in the end an experience that cannot be separated from capitalism. Whether the constant upheaval the Manifesto describes is liberation or destruction, and whether that experience can be made our own, has been the same question from Baudelaire in the 1860s to Berman and Anderson in the 1980s. The distortions of human relations that arise from that experience are treated under "Alienation" and "Commodity fetishism".

Related people

Sources

  1. fr.wikisource.org
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. newleftreview.org
  4. fr.wikipedia.org
  5. Wikipedia (EN)
  6. de.wikipedia.org
  7. Wikipedia (EN)
  8. Wikipedia (EN)
  9. Wikipedia (EN)
  10. ko.wikisource.org
  11. de.wikisource.org
  12. aladin.co.kr
  13. Wikipedia (EN)
  14. newleftreview.org
  15. marxistarkiv.se
  16. Wikipedia (EN)
  17. de.wikipedia.org
  18. Wikipedia (EN)
  19. Wikipedia (EN)
  20. Wikipedia (EN)