Negative Dialektik · 1966

Negative dialectics

부정변증법

The philosophy set out by the German philosopher Theodor W. Adorno in his 1966 book of the same title. Unlike Hegelian dialectics, which draws a positive synthesis out of the negation of the negation, it upholds a thinking that remains conscious to the end that concepts never fully grasp their objects, the "non-identity" between concept and thing. Adorno called it an "anti-system" opposed to systems, and tied identifying thought to a social critique reaching from the exchange principle to Auschwitz.

In depth

Does the word "apple" hold all of the apple?

A greengrocer's stall is piled with apples. One is bruised on one side, one is unusually red, one has a long stalk. We call them all "apples" and price them by weight. At that moment each individual difference, the bruise, the redness, the stalk, disappears. Grasping things with concepts always cuts something off in this way. Theodor Adorno called what is cut off "the non-identical", and called the thinking that does not forget it "negative dialectics".

Adorno published a book under this title in 1966 and himself regarded it as his main work. According to German Wikipedia he saw the book's title as equivalent to the concept of critical theory. The book begins: "The formulation Negative Dialectics flouts tradition." He goes straight on to say that since Plato dialectics has sought to produce something positive by the intellectual means of negation, and that the figure of the "negation of the negation" later named this succinctly.

Die Formulierung Negative Dialektik verstößt gegen die Überlieferung.

The book seeks to free dialectics "from such affirmative traits without reducing its determinacy in the least".

What is identity thinking, and what is wrong with it?

What Adorno criticised was "identifying thought". A concept takes what several things have in common as their essence and makes them identical with the concept. As German Wikipedia puts it, when people abstract in concepts they exert a kind of compulsion on things. Adorno wrote: "Dialectics is the consistent consciousness of non-identity."

Dialektik ist das konsequente Bewußtsein von Nichtidentität.

He did not propose to give up concepts. Philosophy cannot think without them. The task he set was this: "The utopia of knowledge would be to open up the non-conceptual with concepts, without making it equal to them."

Die Utopie der Erkenntnis wäre, das Begriffslose mit Begriffen aufzutun, ohne es ihnen gleichzumachen.

Here his relation to Hegel shows. According to German Wikipedia, Adorno valued as "Hegel's truth" Hegel's criticism of Kant for severing the knowing subject from the thing itself. But Hegel did not acknowledge that the mediation of subject and object is unequal, that the subject enters the object in a wholly different way from that in which the object enters the subject. The result was a positive dialectics that reconciles contradictions in a higher synthesis. Adorno put forward the "priority of the object" (Vorrang des Objekts), arguing that the knowing subject is itself objectively constituted in society and that no object can be fully known by the rules of identity thinking. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy counts this as what most clearly distinguishes Adorno's materialist epistemology from idealism.

Why is epistemology social critique?

For Adorno identity thinking is not only something in the head. He criticised the exchange principle as "the identifying principle of thought". When different goods and labours are compared in the market as quantities of the same money, society makes everything equal in reality before thought does. In this respect negative dialectics connects with Marx's analysis of the commodity and with what Alfred Sohn-Rethel called "Real abstraction". Adorno did not, however, propose simply to abolish the exchange principle: remove the measure that makes things comparable and naked violence and privilege take its place.

Adorno named the place where identity thinking reached its extreme Auschwitz. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy notes that "Meditations on Metaphysics", the last part of Negative Dialectics, treats industrial mass murder as the culmination of identity thinking, in which the individual was reduced to a mere "specimen". The book's introduction begins with the situation of philosophy itself: "Philosophy, which once seemed obsolete, lives on because the moment to realise it was missed."

Philosophie, die einmal überholt schien, erhält sich am Leben, weil der Augenblick ihrer Verwirklichung versäumt ward.

The sentence reads against the grain of the eleventh of Marx's Theses on Feuerbach, that the philosophers have only interpreted the world while the point is to change it. After the attempt to change the world has failed, theory can no longer be belittled in the name of practice.

What criticisms did negative dialectics meet?

Criticism came from both sides. From the Marxist-Leninist side, negative dialectics was theory withdrawn from class struggle and revolutionary practice. In the debates over the West German universities in the late 1960s, Adorno was a target for both student activists and their right-wing critics. On the other side Jürgen Habermas led the criticism within the Frankfurt School. According to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Habermas objected to the conflation of instrumental rationality with rationality as such and of rationality with power, and pointed to a "normative deficit", a lack of grounds on which critique could stand. These issues are also treated in "Dialectic of Enlightenment" and "Critical Theory (Frankfurt School)".

Another question is consistency. The word for the non-identical is itself a concept, so negative dialectics relies on the conceptual thought it criticises. Adorno did not hide this and made it the reason for continued critical self-reflection. Gershom Scholem called the book the "most chaste defence of metaphysics".

What followed?

Adorno died in 1969, and Aesthetic Theory, on which he had worked throughout the 1960s, appeared posthumously the next year. Negative dialectics left a deep mark on cultural criticism, aesthetics and the debate on whether philosophy is possible after the Holocaust. English Wikipedia writes that Holocaust historians such as Zygmunt Bauman and Saul Friedländer were influenced by the book. The principles of social knowledge Adorno defended against Karl Popper in the positivism dispute that began in 1961, and the German critique of the value form and "New Reading of Marx" that put exchange abstraction at the centre, also touch on the concerns of negative dialectics. A Korean edition has appeared under the title 『부정변증법』.

Related people

Sources

  1. archive.org
  2. de.wikipedia.org
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. de.wikipedia.org
  5. plato.stanford.edu