North Korean land reform (1946)
북조선 토지개혁 (1946)
A reform of confiscation and free distribution that began with the Provisional People's Committee's land law of 5 March 1946 and was completed in about a month. It confiscated the land of Japanese and national traitors, of Korean landlords holding 5 chongbo or more and of land rented out continuously, and distributed it to hired hands, landless and land-poor peasants, carried out by 11,930 village rural committees. Distributed land was granted as permanent property but could not be sold, rented out or mortgaged, so interpretations differ on whether peasants received ownership or only a right to cultivate.
In depth
What was it?
The North Korean land reform began with a law of the Provisional People's Committee for North Korea on 5 March 1946 and abolished landlordism in about a month. Land was confiscated without compensation and distributed to peasants without payment. It was the first land reform completed in East Asia after liberation and serves as the benchmark against which those of southern Korea, Japan, China and Taiwan are compared.
Why the haste?
At liberation the poor peasants, more than half the farming population of the north, held only 5.4 percent of the cultivated land, and 45 percent had no land at all. Nearly everyone agreed that land reform was needed, but opinions differed on the method: between the socialist and nationalist camps, within the socialist camp, and on the Soviet side between the Foreign Ministry and the Maritime Military District. At the end of February 1946 the North Korean Peasants' Representatives' Congress in Pyongyang settled the plan: all tenanted land would be confiscated without compensation, and instead of nationalisation the peasants would receive ownership. The draft from the North Korean Peasants' Federation was put forward by the Provisional People's Committee over the names of its chairman Kim Il Sung and secretary-general Kang Ryang-uk, and after a debate on 5 March it was promulgated by the unanimous vote of the committee (the commentary of the National Institute of Korean History dates the promulgation to the next day, the 6th). That was a fortnight before the US-Soviet Joint Commission opened in Seoul.
What did the law lay down?
The law has seventeen articles. The first states its purpose (in the modern Korean rendering of the National Institute of Korean History):
토지 개혁의 과업은 일본인 토지 소유와 조선인 지주들의 토지 소유 및 소작제를 철폐하고 토지 이용권은 경작하는 농민에게 있다.
(The task of land reform is to abolish Japanese landholding, the landholding of Korean landlords and the tenancy system; the right to use land belongs to the peasants who till it.)
Six kinds of land were to be confiscated: land of the Japanese state, Japanese nationals and Japanese organisations; land of national traitors and of those who fled at liberation; land of Korean landlords holding more than 5 chongbo per household; land wholly let to tenants by owners who did not farm; any land continuously let to tenants, whatever its size; and land of religious bodies holding more than 5 chongbo. Land of schools and hospitals and of those with a record in the anti-Japanese struggle was exempt. The recipients were hired labourers, landless peasants and peasants with little land.
제2조, 제3조에 의하여 몰수한 토지 전부 농민에게 무상으로 영원한 소유지로 양여함
(All land confiscated under Articles 2 and 3 is transferred to the peasants free of charge as their permanent property.)
본 법령에 의하여 농민에게 분여된 토지는 매매치 못하며 소작주지 못하며 저당하지 못함
(Land distributed to peasants under this law may not be sold, let to tenants or mortgaged.)
All debts of peasants to landlords were cancelled; the draught animals, implements and houses of landlords with more than 5 chongbo were confiscated too; forests and irrigation works passed to the people's committees. A landlord who wished to farm by his own labour could receive land only in another county. The reform was to be carried out by the end of March and certificates of ownership issued by 20 June.
How was it carried out?
The Provisional People's Committee directed the reform and the provincial, county and township people's committees were responsible for it; in the villages it was done by rural committees elected at general meetings of hired labourers and tenants. There were 11,930 rural committees with 197,485 peasants taking part. Resistance from landlords and the right was weak. Landlords had to move to another county, and the way south across the 38th parallel was open, so many of them left for the south. This sets it apart from the reform in China, where mass struggle against landlords and killings recurred.
Did the peasants become owners?
The law spoke of "permanent property" but forbade sale, tenancy and mortgage, so interpretations differ on whether what was granted was ownership or a right of cultivation. The outcome was a "state-managed smallholder system" in which the state intervened in peasant production and grain circulation. From June 1946 an agricultural tax in kind took 25 percent of the harvest; the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture regards it as a land-use fee paid in place of rent. It was lighter than the old rents. Power in the countryside moved from the landlords and the nationalist camp to the peasants and the socialist camp. Collectivisation came only after the Korean War.
How does it compare with other land reforms in East Asia?
Between 1946 and 1953 landlordism was dismantled in all four countries of East Asia. The methods fall into two groups.
- China: the Chinese Communist Party turned to distributing land in the liberated areas with its Instructions on Land Issues of 4 May 1946, went on to confiscate rich peasants' land under the Outline Land Law of October 1947, and after the founding of the People's Republic swung back to preserving the rich peasant economy under the Land Reform Law of the People's Republic of China (1950). Like the northern Korean reform it confiscated and distributed without payment, but it was a movement of several years, carried through in civil war by classifying every village into classes and by mass struggle. The northern Korean law preceded the May Fourth Instructions by two months and finished in one month on a simple acreage criterion of 5 chongbo.
- Japan: under instructions from the occupation headquarters the second reform law was passed in October 1946 (the land reform in occupied Japan). The state bought all the tenanted land of absentee landlords and the tenanted land of resident landlords above 1 chobu (the Japanese reading of the same unit, chongbo) and sold it to the tenants. Tenanted land fell from 46 percent to 10 percent of farmland. Japanese Wikipedia notes that the reform was also intended as an anti-communist policy, to remove the Communist Party's base in the countryside.
- Taiwan: the Kuomintang government moved from a rent ceiling in 1949 to the sale of public land in 1951 and Land to the Tiller in 1953 (land reform in Taiwan). Landlords were compensated with commercial and industrial property taken over from the Japanese, and an American aid agency backed the programme.
- Southern Korea: the US military government went no further than dealing with the vested farmland formerly owned by Japanese, and the government of the Republic of Korea passed the Farmland Reform Act in June 1949 and carried it out in 1950 by purchase and sale, with a ceiling of 3 chongbo. The Encyclopedia of Korean Culture writes that the northern reform had a decisive influence on it.
The socialist side took land without payment and gave it away free; the three places under American influence bought it and sold it. The latter reforms also carried the aim of stopping the former from drawing the peasantry to their side. When the left in the south wrote uncompensated confiscation and free distribution into the Five Principles of Left-Right Coalition and the draft programme of the Workers' Party of South Korea in 1946, it was taking this reform as its model.