US–USSR Joint Commission · 1946.03.20–1947.10.21

US-Soviet Joint Commission

미소공동위원회

The commission of representatives of the US command south of the 38th parallel and the Soviet command north of it, set up under the Moscow decision to help form a Korean provisional government. Its first session opened in Seoul on 20 March 1946 and adjourned indefinitely on 6 May; the second opened on 21 May 1947 and ended in October. It broke down over whether groups opposed to trusteeship could be consulted, and the United States then took the Korean question to the United Nations.

In depth

What was the commission for?

The US-Soviet Joint Commission was formed by representatives of the United States command in the south and the Soviet command in the north to assist in setting up a provisional government for Korea. Its basis was the Moscow Conference decision issued by the foreign ministers of the United States, the United Kingdom and the Soviet Union on 27 December 1945. The decision provided that a provisional Korean democratic government be set up, that the Commission draw up proposals in consultation with Korean democratic parties and social organisations, that the governments of the United States, the Soviet Union, the United Kingdom and China consider them, and that an agreement be worked out for a four-power trusteeship of up to five years.

there shall be established a Joint Commission consisting of representatives of the United States command in southern Korea and the Soviet command in northern Korea. In preparing their proposals the Commission shall consult with the Korean democratic parties and social organizations.

Whom to consult: that single line bound the Commission for two years.

How does it look from East Asia as a whole?

The Moscow decision was not a document about Korea alone. The same text created the Far Eastern Commission and the Allied Council for Japan, which set occupation policy for Japan; on China it recorded agreement on unity under the National Government and an end to civil strife, and it dealt with the withdrawal of American and Soviet forces from China. The Korean section itself names China as one of the four trustee powers. At the same moment the United States sent Marshall to China to mediate a unified government between the Kuomintang and the Communist Party (the Marshall Mission, December 1945 to January 1947), and that failed too. The same Marshall, as secretary of state, handed the Korean question to the United Nations in 1947. The US-Soviet negotiation in Korea was one part of the larger contest over how the two powers would divide occupied territories and zones of civil war in post-war East Asia.

Why did the first session stall?

From 16 January to 5 February 1946 Major General Arnold for the United States and Lieutenant General Shtykov for the Soviet Union held a preliminary conference in the Seokjojeon hall of Deoksu Palace, and the first session opened in Seoul on 20 March. The Soviet side set conditions for the parties to be consulted: they must support the Moscow decision, be truly democratic, and not be anti-Soviet groups. The American side replied that most Koreans opposed trusteeship and that excluding them for that reason was unjust. Communiqué No. 5 of 17 April offered a compromise, that parties and organisations signing a declaration of support for the Moscow decision would be consulted, but the two sides split again over whether signing meant accepting trusteeship, and on 6 May the Commission adjourned indefinitely. For the United States, if the right that had led the anti-trusteeship campaign was left out, the forces representing its interests could hardly take the lead in a provisional government. For the Soviet Union, admitting the anti-trusteeship forces meant a government opposed to the Moscow decision.

What happened in the year of adjournment?

After the adjournment Syngman Rhee called, in his Jeongeup speech, for a government in the south alone, while the centrists around Yeo Un-hyeong and Kim Kyu-sik formed the Left-Right Coalition Committee with American backing. The military government turned to repression of the left, and the left moved on to the September General Strike, the Autumn Uprising and the three-party merger. In the north the Provisional People's Committee for North Korea completed land reform and its other reforms. While the Commission stood idle, different orders were hardening in south and north.

How did the second session end?

After long exchanges of letters between Hodge and the Soviet commander Chistyakov, and then between Marshall and Molotov, the Commission reconvened on 21 May 1947. This time part of the right, including the Korea Democratic Party, decided to take part on the argument that trusteeship could be opposed once a provisional government existed, and almost every party and organisation except the followers of Syngman Rhee and Kim Ku applied. By 25 June, 425 organisations in the south and 36 in the north had applied; the memberships they declared added up to 70 million, twice the population. The two delegations held joint meetings with parties and organisations in Seoul on 25 June and in Pyongyang on 1 July.

The question of whom to consult was not resolved, and by August the session was back at the first session's opposition between the Soviet "adherence to the Moscow decision" and the American "freedom of expression". When the military government arrested members of the Workers' Party of South Korea and other leftists en masse in mid-August, the Soviet delegate Shtykov protested, the American delegate Brown called this interference in internal affairs, and the talks stopped. On 17 September US Secretary of State Marshall placed the Korean question before the UN General Assembly, and the Soviet delegate Vyshinsky objected that this violated the US-Soviet agreement. The Soviet Union proposed instead the withdrawal of both armies. On 18 October, at the 62nd plenary meeting, Brown proposed suspending the Commission's work until the UN debate ended; Shtykov announced the withdrawal of his delegation, and on 21 October the Soviet delegation left Seoul.

What did it leave behind?

On 14 November 1947 the UN General Assembly set up the United Nations Temporary Commission on Korea to supervise elections, but the Soviet Union and the north refused to recognise it, and the election came to be held in the south alone. The North-South Joint Conference of April 1948 was called against that. The Joint Commission was the last framework in which the two occupying powers could have agreed on one government for Korea; after it ended, the road that remained led to two.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. encykorea.aks.ac.kr
  2. encykorea.aks.ac.kr
  3. avalon.law.yale.edu
  4. Wikipedia (EN)
  5. encykorea.aks.ac.kr
  6. Wikipedia (EN)
  7. Wikipedia (KO)