The only American to head the Army, the State Department, and the Pentagon, organizer of Allied victory and architect of the Marshall Plan
At Harvard's commencement on June 5, 1947, Marshall received an honorary degree and delivered a speech of under 1,200 words — barely twelve minutes — sketching a recovery plan directed 'against hunger, poverty, desperation and chaos.'
Marshall was the only American to serve as Army Chief of Staff (1939–45), Secretary of State (1947–49), and Secretary of Defense (1950–51): the 'organizer of victory' who presided over the fortyfold expansion of the U.S. Army. At Harvard on June 5, 1947, he proposed a massive aid program to reverse Europe's economic collapse and contain Soviet pressure; the Marshall Plan channeled $13 billion over four years, stabilizing Western Europe's industrial base and currencies while reshaping U.S. Cold War strategy. As Secretary of State he clashed openly with Truman over the recognition of Israel, and as Defense Secretary during the Korean War he approved MacArthur's dismissal, reasserting civilian control of the military. He received the Nobel Peace Prize in 1953, the only career soldier ever to do so.
Also known as: George Catlett Marshall · General Marshall
Activities and affiliations
-
1939–1945
United States state institutionsChief of Staff of the ArmyMain
Military command
Career Timeline
- 1880Born in Uniontown, Pennsylvania, the youngest child of a coal and coke businessman
- 1902Graduated VMI, commissioned 2nd lieutenant, posted to the Philippines
- 1917–1918WWI: planned the Cantigny and Meuse-Argonne offensives as 1st Division G-3
- 1939–1945Army Chief of Staff: expanded the Army from 189,000 to 8 million, directed Allied strategy
- 1945.12–1947.01Special envoy to China; failed to broker a Nationalist-Communist coalition
- 1947–1949Secretary of State: launched the Marshall Plan and pushed for NATO's creation
- 1950–1951Secretary of Defense during the Korean War; approved MacArthur's relief and rebuilt the Pentagon
- 1953Awarded the Nobel Peace Prize
Related historical events
- 1914–1918First World War1st Division operations plannerAs 1st Division G-3, he planned the Cantigny and Meuse-Argonne offensives.
- 1940.06.10–1943.05.13The North African CampaignUS Army Chief of StaffArgued for a landing in northern Europe in 1942, declined to approve the Torch plan and suggested to Roosevelt a Pacific offensive instead.
- 1941–1944The Second Front and the Normandy LandingsU.S. Army chief of staffA leading candidate for Overlord, he remained Army chief of staff in Washington and supported the operation's preparation.
- 1944–1949The People's Democracies of Eastern EuropeUS Secretary of State of the Marshall PlanSeveral historians see the Marshall Plan and the Truman Doctrine as what sped the break-up of the East European coalitions.
- 1944.07.01–1973.03The Rise and Fall of the Bretton Woods SystemUS Secretary of StateProposed aid to Europe at Harvard on 5 June 1947, opening the way to the Marshall Plan that filled the dollar gap.
- 1945–1948Czechoslovakia: from the Košice programme to February 1948US Secretary of State behind the Marshall PlanIn July 1947 Stalin's intervention made the Czechoslovak government reverse its decision to join his plan, and the refusal cost the Communists support.
- 1945–1949The Chinese Civil WarUS mediatorMediated for a coalition from December 1945 and declared failure in January 1947.
- 1945.08.15–1948.08.15Southern Korea after Liberation: From the People's Committees to a Separate GovernmentUS Secretary of StateTook the Korean question to the UN General Assembly on 17 September 1947.
- 1947–1948The Marshall Plan and the Cold WarArchitect of the Marshall PlanIn his Harvard speech of June 5, 1947, he proposed a massive aid program for European reconstruction; the idea became the $13 billion European Recovery Program that bore his name.
- 1948–1949The Berlin Blockade and AirliftUS Secretary of State of the Marshall PlanThe Marshall Plan of 1947 made the West German currency reform unavoidable, and the reform triggered the blockade.
- 1950–1953The Korean WarApproved MacArthur's reliefAs Secretary of Defense, he approved MacArthur's relief during the Korean War.
How did an average graduate of the Virginia Military Institute make his name as the Army's master planner?
George Catlett Marshall was born on 31 December 1880 in Uniontown, Pennsylvania, the youngest child of a family in the coal and coke business. He wanted a military career from an early age, but with average grades he was unlikely to get into West Point, so he went to the Virginia Military Institute (VMI). After graduating in 1901 he won a commission as an infantry second lieutenant by competitive examination in February 1902 and went straight to the Philippines, where he served as platoon leader and company commander during the Philippine-American War against resistance to American colonial rule.
When the United States entered the First World War in 1917, he went to France as operations officer of the newly formed 1st Division. Late that year, when General John Pershing, commander of the American Expeditionary Forces, berated the division commander in front of his staff during an inspection, Marshall angrily intervened to explain logistical and administrative difficulties Pershing knew nothing about. Far from ending his career, the episode won him Pershing's confidence. In mid-1918 he moved to the AEF operations staff and helped plan and coordinate the Meuse-Argonne offensive, which contributed to Imperial Germany's defeat, earning the Army Distinguished Service Medal.
Reverting to captain after the war, he became Pershing's aide-de-camp in 1919 and, while Pershing was Army Chief of Staff from 1920 to 1924, worked on projects for training in modern, mechanised warfare. He then served as executive officer of the 15th Infantry Regiment in Tianjin, China, experience that formed the background to his mission to China in 1945. After losing his first wife Lily in 1927, he became assistant commandant of the Infantry School at Fort Benning, Georgia, where he modernised command and staff procedures; those reforms and the officers he spotted there proved important in the Second World War. When he married Katherine Tupper Brown in 1930, Pershing was his best man.
During the Depression he was a strong supporter of President Roosevelt and the New Deal. Douglas MacArthur, the Republican Army Chief of Staff with whom he had a contentious relationship, disapproved and abruptly transferred him to Chicago as an instructor with the Illinois National Guard. Back in Washington in July 1938 in the War Plans Division and then as Deputy Chief of Staff, he was the only participant at a White House meeting to object to Roosevelt's proposal to add 15,000 aircraft a year, arguing that balanced preparation of the whole Army must come first. The candour won him trust rather than costing it. He became acting chief of staff on 1 July 1939, and Roosevelt, preferring him to the conservative MacArthur camp because he was friendlier to New Deal liberalism, made him Army Chief of Staff on 1 September 1939, the day war began in Europe.
How did Chief of Staff Marshall expand the US Army fortyfold, and what did he argue about the second front?
The Army Marshall inherited was an outmoded, poorly equipped regular force of 189,000 men. Working with Secretary of War Henry Stimson, he organised the largest military expansion in American history, turning civilians into an army of more than eight million by 1942, a fortyfold increase within three years. He had Lesley McNair, commander of Army Ground Forces, produce large numbers of soldiers quickly through shortened training, and drawing on his years as an Army War College instructor he oversaw doctrine for modern warfare such as the field manuals. Churchill later called him the "organizer of victory", and Time named him Man of the Year for 1943.
The biggest dispute over Allied strategy was when and where to strike Germany. Marshall believed a landing across the English Channel in northern France was the fastest way to defeat Germany, and at first set 1 April 1943 as the target date for a cross-Channel invasion. But Churchill, who preferred Mediterranean operations, persuaded Roosevelt to commit troops instead to the invasion of Sicily (Operation Husky). Marshall and his advisers also opposed the landings in French North Africa (Operation Torch), because of likely Vichy French resistance, the danger of Axis intervention through Franco's Spain and Gibraltar, and suspicion that the operation was meant to defend European colonial territory of little strategic value to the war.
The dispute was bound up with relations with the Soviet Union. Fighting the bulk of the German army, Stalin had demanded from 1941 that the West open a "second front" in northern France. Marshall's military case for an early Channel crossing ended up pointing in the same direction as Stalin's demand, but British opposition pushed the landing back to 1944. At Tehran at the end of 1943 the three leaders committed themselves to Operation Overlord in 1944.
When rumours spread that Marshall would become Supreme Commander for Overlord, many saw it as a demotion, since he would give up his post as Chief of Staff and his seat on the Combined Chiefs of Staff. Marshall refused to lobby for the command, and Roosevelt chose Eisenhower, telling Marshall, "I didn't feel I could sleep at ease if you were out of Washington." He went on coordinating Allied operations in both Europe and the Pacific until the end of the war.
After the war, the congressional Joint Committee on the Investigation of the Pearl Harbor Attack criticised Marshall for delay in sending important information to Lieutenant General Walter Short, the Army commander in Hawaii. Marshall stepped down as Chief of Staff on 18 November 1945, but did not retire, since a General of the Army remains on active duty for life. A few weeks later Truman sent him to China as special envoy.
Envoy to China and the 'Loss of China' Charge
In December 1945, only weeks after leaving the post of Army Chief of Staff, Marshall was dispatched to China as President Truman's special envoy. His mission was to broker a coalition government between Chiang Kai-shek's Nationalists and Mao Zedong's Chinese Communist Party in order to prevent the civil war from resuming. The United States wielded the aid that was indispensable to the Nationalists as leverage, but it had no comparable hold on the Communists. Marshall arrived on 20 December 1945 and drew both sides into negotiations; the talks over a ceasefire and the integration of armies ran for more than a year without reaching substantive agreement, as both parties used the time to prepare for the coming decisive battle.
To preserve the neutrality of the mediation, the United States suspended the sale of weapons and ammunition to the Nationalists from 29 July 1946 until May 1947, a step that provoked domestic controversy. When both the Nationalists and the Communists rejected his proposals, Marshall returned to the United States in January 1947 to become Secretary of State, and the mission withdrew; some accounts also cite his deteriorating health and domestic criticism. The failure of his mediation led to the full resumption of the Chinese Civil War, and the Communists won in 1949. As Secretary of State, Marshall disagreed with the argument inside the State and Defense Departments that Chiang's success was vital to American interests, insisting that U.S. troops must not become directly involved.
The failed mission was later turned into a weapon of anti-communist political attack. In June 1951, Douglas MacArthur, himself dismissed during the Korean War, called Marshall's China mission 'one of the greatest blunders in American diplomatic history,' and Senator Joseph McCarthy cast him as the man responsible for the 'loss of China.' McCarthy alleged that during the mission Marshall had embargoed arms to the Nationalists and forced open the Kalgan mountain pass into Manchuria, thereby turning the situation in the Communists' favor. Alongside the stalemate in Korea, this campaign split American opinion over Marshall's reputation along party lines. In the 1952 election campaign, Dwight Eisenhower denounced the Truman administration's failures in China and Korea while refusing to defend Marshall's policy.
Why did the Marshall Plan become the turning point that divided Europe into East and West?
Back from China in January 1947, Marshall became Truman's Secretary of State. Widely respected and seen as above party, he was the ideal public face for the plans to rebuild Europe; he did not design them in detail, but became their spokesman. Two years after the war, Europe's recovery was slow. In 1947 agricultural production stood at 83 per cent of 1938 levels, industrial production at 88 per cent and exports at 59 per cent, and unemployment and food shortages led to strikes and unrest in several countries. In France and Italy the Communist parties were powerful mass parties.
The Moscow foreign ministers' conference of March-April 1947 was a turning point. The United States and Britain pressed for an economically self-sufficient Germany and a full accounting of the plants and goods the Soviets had removed from their zone, but Molotov refused to supply figures. Putting reparations first, the Soviets sought to delay rather than speed German recovery, and six weeks of talks failed. Washington concluded it could not wait any longer. In his commencement address at Harvard on 5 June 1947, Marshall diagnosed Europe's economic breakdown and offered American aid for reconstruction. Clark Clifford suggested calling it the Truman Plan, but Truman immediately rejected the idea and insisted on "Marshall Plan".
In principle the aid was open to the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe too. But Moscow was suspicious from the start. As early as October 1946 Molotov had warned that if American capital were given a free hand it would buy up the industries of the small states ruined by the war and become master in them. Stalin at first tried to wreck the plan from inside by joining the Paris talks and contesting its terms, but changed course when Molotov reported from Paris in July that the credit conditions were non-negotiable. Czechoslovakia's eagerness to accept the aid, and signs of a similar Polish attitude, were a particular worry. Molotov left Paris, and the Czechoslovak and Polish delegations were prevented from attending the Paris meeting that opened on 12 July. The other Eastern European states immediately declined, and Finland stayed out to avoid antagonising the Soviets. Moscow denounced the United States as a "fascizing" power and "the center of worldwide reaction", and blamed it for the communists' setbacks in Belgium, France and Italy that spring.
The Soviet alternative became known as the Molotov Plan. Between 1945 and 1947 the Soviet Union had already concluded eleven major bilateral trade agreements with its satellites, sending raw materials and food in exchange for manufactured goods and equipment; after the rejection of the Marshall Plan this network developed into the Council for Mutual Economic Assistance (Comecon). On 22-23 September 1947 the Soviets brought nine European communist parties to Szklarska Poręba in Poland and founded the Cominform (Information Bureau of the Communist and Workers' Parties), prompted by disagreements among communist governments over whether to attend the Marshall Plan conference. Andrei Zhdanov, who chaired the meeting, reported that the world was divided into an imperialist camp led by the United States and an anti-imperialist camp led by the Soviet Union, and castigated the French and Italian parties for collaborating with bourgeois parties at home. The French Communist Party was given the new task of fighting the Marshall Plan.
Truman signed the legislation on 3 April 1948. Over four years $13.3 billion went to seventeen countries, with Britain, the largest recipient, receiving about 26 per cent. The Marshall Plan is credited with stabilising Western Europe's industry and currencies and weakening the political base of the Communist parties. But it also split Europe's economy into a West integrated into an American-style market order and a Soviet-centred planned bloc in the East, hardening the Cold War division in economic terms. Marshall received the 1953 Nobel Peace Prize for it.
Why did Secretary of State Marshall oppose recognising Israel, and what did he decide on Korea as Secretary of Defense?
As Secretary of State, Marshall clashed repeatedly with Truman over the Middle East. He strongly opposed recognising the state of Israel that was about to be declared. He believed that a declaration of Israeli statehood would set off war in the Middle East, and indeed the first Arab-Israeli war began the day after Israel declared independence in May 1948. He saw recognition of a Jewish state as a domestic political move to win Jewish American votes, but Truman rejected his advice and recognised Israel at once.
On colonial questions he showed another side. When the Netherlands tried to retake by force Indonesia, which had declared independence in 1945, Marshall urged Truman to call on the Dutch to stop their invasion immediately. When the Netherlands ignored the first appeals, Washington put Marshall Plan aid for the Netherlands on hold and threatened to cut off all economic aid. He was severely exhausted throughout his time at State; Dean Acheson said in late 1947 that he was performing like "a four-engine bomber going only on one engine". He resigned for health reasons in January 1949 and took on largely honorary posts as chairman of the American Battle Monuments Commission and president of the American Red Cross.
When the first months of the Korean War, which broke out in June 1950, exposed the Defense Department's lack of preparation, Truman fired Secretary of Defense Louis Johnson and in September named Marshall in his place. The National Security Act of 1947 barred a uniformed officer from the post, and since a General of the Army stays on active duty for life, Congress had to grant a waiver. He brought in Robert Lovett as his deputy and Anna Rosenberg, former head of the War Manpower Commission, as assistant secretary for manpower to meet the troop demands of Korea and Europe. After the Inchon landing he took part in the discussions that authorised MacArthur to advance into North Korea, and in an "eyes only" message of 29 September he told MacArthur: "We want you to feel unhampered strategically and tactically to proceed north of the 38th Parallel."
After China intervened in late November, Marshall and the Joint Chiefs looked for ways to support MacArthur while avoiding all-out war with China. He opposed a ceasefire on the grounds that it would make the United States look weak and invite demands for further concessions, and when British Prime Minister Attlee suggested diplomatic overtures to China he objected that it was impossible to negotiate with the Communist government. Yet when some in Congress wanted to carry the war to China, he argued against a wider war in Korea and stressed instead the importance of containing the Soviet Union in Europe, the main arena of the Cold War. As MacArthur's public statements kept contradicting Truman's conduct of the war, Truman met Marshall, Bradley, Acheson and Harriman on 6 April 1951 to discuss removing him, and relieved MacArthur on 11 April. Taken in line with the views of Marshall and the Joint Chiefs, the decision is seen as reasserting civilian control of the military.
The attacks on his China mission by MacArthur and McCarthy in June that year are covered in the section on his China mission. In September 1951, after 49 years of public service, he retired to Dodona Manor in Leesburg, Virginia, where he grew vegetables. As chairman of the Battle Monuments Commission he oversaw the building of fourteen American war cemeteries in eight countries, and in 1953 he became the first career soldier to receive the Nobel Peace Prize. He died after a series of strokes at Walter Reed Hospital in Washington on 16 October 1959, and President Eisenhower ordered flags flown at half-staff.