Philosophical scepticism
회의주의 (철학)
The philosophical current that doubts whether we really know what we take ourselves to know, and even whether knowledge is possible. The word comes from the Greek skepsis, inquiry. Unlike everyday reluctance to believe, it tests even the most plausible beliefs of common sense. It runs from ancient Pyrrhonism and Academic scepticism to Descartes's methodical doubt and Hume's scepticism.
In depth
What question does scepticism ask?
How do you know you are reading this now? In last night's dream too you saw something distinctly and believed it. In an age when the eye cannot tell a forged video from a real one, this is no remote question. Philosophical scepticism pushes such doubt to the end. Unlike the everyday "I don't buy that", it demands grounds even for the most certain-looking belief, such as that there are two hands in front of you.
The sceptic has two typical arguments. One is the argument from "what if". If I were dreaming, or if an evil demon were deceiving me, or in today's terms if I were a brain in a vat, my experience would be just what it is now. If I cannot rule this out, I cannot say I know. The other is the trap of justification. To justify a claim one needs a ground, and that ground needs a ground in turn. So one must go back forever, go in circles, or stop somewhere without a ground. This is the argument attributed to the ancient Agrippa.
Why did the ancient sceptics suspend judgement?
For the Greek sceptics doubt was not despair but an art of living. Pyrrho (fourth century BC) left no writings, and in the first century BC Aenesidemus founded a school in his name. The fullest account of the tradition is in the books of the second-century physician Sextus Empiricus, who defines it thus: "Scepticism is an ability to set appearances and thoughts in opposition in any manner whatever."
Ἒστι δὲ ἡ σκεπτικὴ δύναμις ἀντιθετικὴ φαινομένων τε καὶ νοουμένων καθ’ οἱονδήποτε τρόπον
Stock arguments help with this, above all the ten modes of Aenesidemus, which point out that the same thing appears differently to different observers and in different conditions, so that one cannot decide which appearance is true. Set in opposition, the two sides weigh the same, and so one suspends judgement (epoché). The Pyrrhonist's promise is that peace of mind (ataraxia) then arrives unexpectedly. The sceptic merely refrains from asserting, and lives an ordinary life following custom and appearance.
Another branch came from the Academy founded by Plato. Around 266 BC, when Arcesilaus took charge, the Academy turned to scepticism, and Carneades and others argued against the Stoics until around 90 BC. Their story comes down through Cicero's Academica.
How did Descartes and Hume use doubt?
When Sextus was read again in the Renaissance, scepticism became a starting point for modern philosophy, and Montaigne revived it. Descartes was not a sceptic but used doubt like a blade. Count as false whatever can be doubted in the least: what remains? That I who doubt exist remains. In the Discourse on the Method (1637) he wrote that the truth "I think, therefore I am" could not be shaken by "all the most extravagant suppositions of the sceptics".
je pense, donc je suis […] toutes les plus extravagantes suppositions des sceptiques n'étoient pas capables de l'ébranler
Hume went the opposite way. Followed to the end, empiricism finds no experience of a necessary connection of cause and effect, and the belief that the sun will rise tomorrow is only habit. Neither the external world nor the self is proved by reason. Yet Hume granted that excessive doubt loses its force in daily life: "The great subverter of Pyrrhonism or the excessive principles of scepticism is action, and employment, and the occupations of common life."
The great subverter of Pyrrhonism or the excessive principles of scepticism is action, and employment, and the occupations of common life.
Hume's doubt woke Kant from his "dogmatic slumber". But Kant held it still "a scandal of philosophy" that the existence of things outside us must be accepted merely on faith.
so bleibt es immer ein Skandal der Philosophie und allgemeinen Menschenvernunft, das Dasein der Dinge außer uns […] bloß auf Glauben annehmen zu müssen
What answers has scepticism received?
Hegel took doubt in as a moment of philosophy. It tears down present knowledge, but moves on from the ruins to better knowledge. In the twentieth century Moore held up his two hands, replying that the belief that he has hands is more certain than any premise of a sceptical argument. Contextualism, for which the standard of "knowing" varies with the context, and foundationalism and coherentism, which redraw the structure of justification, are also responses. In a way much of modern epistemology is an answer sheet to this question.
The Marxist answer touches Hume's admission above and goes further. Marx held that the question whether objective truth belongs to human thinking, if separated from practice, becomes "a purely scholastic question". In the English introduction of 1892 Engels replied that before there was argumentation there was action: "The proof of the pudding is in the eating." When we use things we put our sense-perceptions to an infallible test. To the sceptic this may look like evading the question, but for Marxists the problem is the starting point itself: an individual sitting alone and doubting. People first live by wrestling with the world, and doubt arises within that.
Lenin partly agreed with the sceptic's observation that knowledge is always incomplete. But he held that the slide from there to "there is no objective truth" is relativism, while dialectics sees knowledge as historically conditioned and yet approaching objective truth. He warned that where scepticism speaks of the limits of knowledge, faith moves in. The boundary with agnosticism is drawn here too. Agnosticism says what lies beyond experience cannot be known, whereas scepticism also calls into question knowledge of the world of experience.
Terms such as "climate scepticism" or "vaccine scepticism" today mean disbelieving a particular scientific conclusion, and differ from the philosophical scepticism of this entry. A philosophical sceptic would doubt the opponents' grounds just as much as the climate scientist's.