Rationalismus (라틴어 ratio 이성) / rationalism / рационализм · Concept

Rationalism (philosophy)

합리론

The position in epistemology that the ground of knowledge lies in reason more than in sensory experience. It takes as its model the kind of knowledge, like mathematics, that is proved with certainty by thought alone. Its representatives are the seventeenth-century continental philosophers Descartes, Spinoza and Leibniz. It stood against British empiricism until Kant sought to combine the two.

In depth

What question does rationalism answer?

How do you know the angles of a triangle add up to 180 degrees? Not by drawing a thousand triangles and measuring them with a protractor. Drawings are crooked and protractors imprecise, and a thousand measurements say nothing of the thousand and first. Yet once we follow the proof we know it holds without fail of every triangle. How did we learn what the senses do not tell us? Rationalism starts here: the most certain knowledge comes from reason and not from eyes and ears.

It must be kept apart from the everyday "rational". Unlike the rationality of comparing prices or Max Weber's rationalisation, philosophical rationalism is a position on the source of knowledge. "Rationalism" sometimes broadly means Enlightenment respect for reason or criticism of religion, but this entry treats the position in epistemology opposed to empiricism.

Rationalism's core claims are usually summed up as three. First, some truths can be known by intuition and deduction alone, as in mathematics and logic. Second, some knowledge is innate. In the Meno Plato shows Socrates leading a young slave to geometrical knowledge by questions alone. The boy never studied geometry, so what he grasps is recollection of knowledge already in him. Third, some concepts are innate and not gained from experience. To be a rationalist it is enough to accept at least one of these for at least some domain, so a rationalist need not say that experience is useless. The dispute lies beyond relations among one's own concepts. Both sides grant that thought alone can tell us that the concept of God includes omniscience. They part over whether such reasoning can also tell us facts about the outside world.

What did Descartes, Spinoza and Leibniz hold?

Descartes doubted everything in search of an unshakeable foundation. The senses deceive and dreams cannot be told from waking. But that I who doubt exist cannot be doubted: "I think, therefore I am."

je pense, donc je suis

From truths grasped so clearly and distinctly he sought to derive others in the manner of geometry. The wax argument of the second Meditation shows his method well. Wax fresh from the comb tastes of honey, smells of flowers, and is white and hard. Brought near the fire it changes in taste, smell, colour and shape, yet we still judge it the same wax. Since all that reached the senses has changed, what tells us it is the same wax is not the senses but the insight of the mind. As a result he divided mind and body into two wholly different substances, and this dualism became a problem for all later philosophy.

Spinoza closed the gap by treating the two as aspects of a single substance ("God or Nature"). His Ethics is written in the geometric form of theorems derived from definitions and axioms. He wrote: "The order and connection of ideas is the same as the order and connection of things."

ordo et connexio idearum idem est ac ordo et connexio rerum

The proposition is a bold answer to why thought can know the world. It is one reason why Marxists such as Plekhanov and later Ilyenkov honoured Spinoza as a distant ancestor of materialism.

Leibniz answered Locke's Essay with the New Essays, adding a phrase to the old empiricist maxim: "Nothing is in the intellect that was not in the senses, except the intellect itself."

Nihil est in intellectu, quod non fuerit in sensu, excipe : nisi ipse intellectus.

The mind is not blank paper but like veined marble, in which the shape to be carved is to some degree already set by the veins. He also distinguished truths of reasoning from truths of fact. The former are necessary truths whose opposite is impossible, and the latter contingent truths that could have been otherwise. The angle sum of a triangle is of the first kind, and a given city's lying on a river of the second.

How was the quarrel with empiricism resolved?

Locke objected that innate principles would have to be known to everyone, yet children have no thought of them. Empiricists distrusted any claim to know about the world by reason alone. Rationalists replied that experience alone yields no necessity or universality. Hundreds of white swans do not guarantee that the next will be white. When Hume demolished the necessity of causation this weakness showed on the empiricist side too.

Kant meshed the two sides. In his famous sentence: "Thoughts without content are empty, intuitions without concepts are blind."

Gedanken ohne Inhalt sind leer, Anschauungen ohne Begriffe sind blind.

But he rejected the rationalist ambition that reason could know God, the soul or the world as a whole beyond experience, for there, he said, it falls into antinomies. Hegel crossed this limit again and made reason a moving, developing historical process. In contemporary debate, claims of cognitive science such as the linguist Chomsky's theory of innate grammar carry on the argument over innate knowledge in a new form.

What did rationalism mean for society and politics?

Rationalism was not only an argument at a desk. Descartes's opening statement that everyone is endowed with reason had the power to put authority and tradition on trial. With the same reason Spinoza criticised the Bible and was excommunicated by his congregation. The French Enlightenment put religion, society and the state before the court of reason. Engels noted that the kingdom of reason then proved to be no more than the idealised kingdom of the bourgeoisie, but the roots of that criticism too lay in that court.

How does Marxism see rationalism? The Marx of The Holy Family depicts seventeenth-century metaphysics as what French materialism overthrew, yet saves Descartes's physics as one source of French materialism. In Fundamental Problems of Marxism Plekhanov, following Feuerbach, judged that Spinoza, though dressed in theology, gave a correct expression for his time of the materialist trend of modern times.

Mao's On Practice (1937) describes an ascent from perceptual to logical knowledge. Logical knowledge differs from perceptual knowledge in reaching the totality, essence and internal relations of things, while resting on the activity of material production. Ilyenkov gave a chapter of Dialectical Logic to Spinoza, writing that his view of thought as an attribute of substance played a role in the development of logic far from fully appreciated.

Related people

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN)
  2. web.archive.org
  3. plato.stanford.edu
  4. Wikipedia (EN)
  5. gutenberg.org
  6. thelatinlibrary.com
  7. fr.wikisource.org
  8. gutenberg.org
  9. web.archive.org
  10. Wikipedia (EN)
  11. Wikipedia (EN)
  12. plato.stanford.edu
  13. Wikipedia (EN)
  14. gutenberg.org
  15. Marxists Internet Archive
  16. Marxists Internet Archive
  17. Marxists Internet Archive