Realism (arts)
리얼리즘 (예술)
The attitude in art of depicting reality as it is, without embellishment, exaggeration or supernatural elements, and the mid-nineteenth-century movement in literature and painting that took it as its programme. It became widely known in France when Courbet put the name "Realism" over his own exhibition in 1855; its representatives include Balzac and Flaubert in literature, and the Russian Peredvizhniki painters and Tolstoy. In Marxist aesthetics the yardstick became the definition Engels gave in his letter to Margaret Harkness: truth of detail together with typical characters in typical circumstances.
In depth
Can you not paint an angel if you have never seen one?
Think of the winged angels painted on church ceilings. Nobody has ever seen one, yet for centuries painters painted them and people called them beautiful. The nineteenth-century French painter Gustave Courbet stubbornly set himself against this. He insisted on painting subjects from life and became famous for saying that he could not paint an angel because he had never seen one.
In the arts, realism generally means the attempt to represent subject matter truthfully, without artificiality, exaggeration, or speculative or supernatural elements. It does not mean the skill of copying like a photograph. The bigger question was what counts as worth painting, and whose lives are put at the centre of the canvas and the book. The word is often used interchangeably with "naturalism", although the two are not necessarily synonyms.
When and how did the name arise?
The catchword réalisme was first used of literary works in 1826 in the French journal Mercure français, and from about 1833 critics used it of the historical and contemporary novels of Walter Scott, Victor Hugo and Balzac. It spread widely from 1855, when Courbet exhibited his paintings of everyday subjects under the title "Realism", and when the critic Jules Champfleury published an anti-Romantic collection of essays, Le réalisme (1857).
In 1855, when part of his work was refused by the Salon held together with the Exposition Universelle, Courbet built a brick-and-timber "Pavilion of Realism" near the exhibition grounds, and there he explained publicly what he meant by realism. He began by saying that the name was not his choice: "The title of Realist was imposed on me as the title of Romantics was imposed on the men of 1830."
Le titre de réaliste m'a été imposé comme on a imposé aux hommes de 1830 le titre de romantiques.
And he wrote of his aim: "To know in order to be able to do: that was my thought. To be able to translate the customs, the ideas, the appearance of my time according to my own judgment, to be not only a painter but a man as well, in a word, to make living art: that is my aim." Champfleury wrote part of this quasi-manifesto.
Savoir pour pouvoir, telle fut ma pensée. Être à même de traduire les mœurs, les idées, l'aspect de mon époque, selon mon appréciation, être non seulement un peintre, mais encore un homme, en un mot, faire de l'art vivant, tel est mon but.
What did the Realist painters paint?
The Realist painters took common labourers and ordinary people engaged in real activities in ordinary surroundings as their subjects. Their chief exponents were Courbet, Jean-François Millet, Honoré Daumier and Jean-Baptiste-Camille Corot. Courbet's The Stone Breakers (1849) was criticised at the Paris Salon of 1850 for a subject not considered proper for high art, while the social theorist Pierre-Joseph Proudhon praised it as a successful socialist painting. The painting is said to have been destroyed in the bombing of Dresden in 1945. A Burial at Ornans (1849–50) painted an ordinary provincial funeral frankly, on the grand scale until then reserved for heroic or religious history painting.
The same current appeared somewhat later in other countries. In Russia the Peredvizhniki, the Wanderers, who formed in the 1860s and held touring exhibitions from 1871, included realists such as Ilya Repin, Vasily Perov and Ivan Shishkin. These painters were influenced by the views of the literary critics Vissarion Belinsky and Nikolai Chernyshevsky.
How did the novel record society?
Literary realism is taken to begin in mid-nineteenth-century French literature with Stendhal and in Russian literature with Alexander Pushkin. Its most prominent representative in fiction was Honoré de Balzac (1799–1850), who tried to portray a whole society by piling up specific detail and bringing the same characters back in many works. The works he gathered into La Comédie humaine number 91 finished pieces. In the preface he gave the series in 1842, Balzac claimed that poetic creation and scientific creation are closely related activities. In the next generation Gustave Flaubert, with Madame Bovary (1857), the tragedy of a provincial doctor's wife undone by romantic illusions, and Sentimental Education (1869), is judged to have reached the high point of French realism.
How does it differ from naturalism?
Naturalism, at the end of the nineteenth century, resembled realism in rejecting Romanticism, but differed in its embrace of determinism, detachment and scientific objectivism. The naturalist novel sought to be a kind of experiment observing how heredity and environment determine human behaviour, and the movement grew chiefly from the theories of Émile Zola. When Engels wrote that Balzac was "a far greater master of realism than all the Zolas", he showed that he did not take realism to be accuracy of detail or scientific observation alone.
How did Marxism read realism?
The yardstick of realism in Marxist aesthetics became a sentence from the letter Engels sent in 1888 to the English writer Margaret Harkness: "Realism, to my mind, implies, besides truth of detail, the truthful reproduction of typical characters under typical circumstances." In the same letter Engels called it a triumph of realism that Balzac, politically a legitimist, depicted the downfall of his own class. This idea, that a writer's views and the truth his work shows can part ways, became a major theme of later Marxist criticism (see Engels's letters on realism).
Realism, to my mind, implies, besides truth of detail, the truthful reproduction of typical characters under typical circumstances.
In 1908, in "Leo Tolstoy as the Mirror of the Russian Revolution", Lenin set out Tolstoy's contradictions and placed on one side "the most sober realism, the tearing away of any and every mask". The writer who preached religion and non-resistance was at the same time the realist who exposed Russian society most soberly.
С одной стороны, самый трезвый реализм, срывание всех и всяческих масок
In the twentieth century realism passed into the name of socialist realism, the official creative method of the Soviet Union, and fights such as the Expressionism debate, in which Lukács, Brecht and others clashed, were fought over whether nineteenth-century realism should serve as the model.