半殖民地半封建社会 · 1922

Semi-colonial and semi-feudal society

반식민지 반봉건 사회

Semi-colonial and semi-feudal society (半殖民地半封建社会) is the Marxist characterisation of a society that keeps a feudal system of exploitation while dominated economically, politically and culturally by foreign capitalist powers. Lenin called modern China "semi-feudal" and "semi-colonial"; Cai Hesen joined the two terms in 1922. In "The Chinese Revolution and the Chinese Communist Party" (1939) Mao Zedong wrote that China had become such a society after the Opium War of 1840, and that grasping this was the basis for every question of the revolution. The revolution, he concluded, must be not socialist but new-democratic, aimed at both imperialism and feudalism. The concept travelled to India's Naxalites and to Korea's 1980s social-formation debate; historians outside mainland China question whether China was ever feudal in the strict sense.

In depth

Where did the concept come from?

Marx and Engels had used the term "semi-feudal", and Lenin described the character of modern Chinese society with the two words "semi-feudal" and "semi-colonial". In China Cai Hesen clearly used both concepts together in a September 1922 article, "Unification, Loans and the Kuomintang". The characterisation was formulated as the starting point of revolutionary theory in "The Chinese Revolution and the Chinese Communist Party", written under Mao Zedong's direction in December 1939.

自从一八四○年的鸦片战争以后,中国一步一步地变成了一个半殖民地半封建的社会。

"After the Opium War of 1840 China gradually changed into a semi-colonial and semi-feudal society." Mao added that since the Incident of 18 September 1931 Japanese aggression had turned China further into "a colonial, semi-colonial and semi-feudal society". In his account imperialism had on the one hand hastened the disintegration of feudal society and the growth of elements of capitalism, turning a feudal into a semi-feudal society, and on the other reduced an independent country to a semi-colonial and colonial one. The imperialist powers made the feudal landlord class and the comprador class the main props of their rule (see "Comprador Monopoly Capitalism").

How did the characterisation shape the revolutionary line?

Mao held that understanding the character of society was the key to every revolutionary problem:

所以,认清中国社会的性质,就是说,认清中国的国情,乃是认清一切革命问题的基本的根据。

He named the contradiction between imperialism and the Chinese nation and that between feudalism and the masses of the people as the basic contradictions of modern Chinese society, and the first of these as the principal one (see "On Contradiction"). Since Chinese society was colonial, semi-colonial and semi-feudal and the principal enemies were imperialism and feudalism, the revolution at the present stage was not a proletarian-socialist but a bourgeois-democratic revolution; yet not of the old, obsolete type but "of a new special type", led by the proletariat, which he called the new-democratic revolution (see "New Democracy"). The Chinese Communist Party and the government of the People's Republic still characterise China from the Opium War to 1949 this way.

What objections have been raised?

Many historians outside mainland China doubt that China had a feudal society in the strict sense for long, pointing out that after the First Emperor of Qin abolished enfeoffment in favour of commanderies and counties, no fiefs were created. The British Marxist historian Perry Anderson defined feudalism as serfdom and military protection imposed by law on the peasantry by an aristocratic class, with parcellised sovereignty. The Chinese historian Feng Tianyu argued that China from the Qin to the Qing should be called a "patriarchal-clan landlord autocracy" rather than a feudal society. Sun Yat-sen once said that China, being a colony of many powers, was a "hypo-colony", lower than a semi-colony.

How did it travel to other countries?

In India Marxists divided over the concept. The Naxalites held that the Indian economy was semi-colonial and semi-feudal, while the Communist Party of India saw India as a capitalist society. Mao himself regarded British-ruled India as a colony, unlike semi-colonial China.

In South Korea a debate on the social formation of the South began in the early 1980s. The current that saw South Korea as a colony of the United States, a semi-feudal society whose capitalism could not grow normally because of its colonial status ("colonial semi-feudal society"), became the National Liberation (NL) line, which put the national contradiction ahead of the class contradiction. The "neo-colonial state monopoly capitalism" thesis, which saw South Korea as a neo-colonial society different from the Japanese colonial era but already at the stage of monopoly capitalism, became the People's Democracy (PD) line (see "State monopoly capitalism"). By the mid-1980s the student movement had split along these two lines.

Related people

Sources

  1. zh.wikipedia.org
  2. Marxists Internet Archive
  3. Marxists Internet Archive
  4. Wikipedia (KO)
  5. Wikipedia (KO)