ゾルゲ事件 · 1941.09.27–1944.11.07

Sorge Incident

조르게 사건

The exposure of the Soviet intelligence ring led by Richard Sorge, who had come to Japan as a German journalist, for espionage in Japan on the eve of the Pacific War. Its members were arrested between September 1941 and April 1942, among them Japanese collaborators such as the former Asahi reporter Ozaki Hotsumi, an adviser to the first Konoe cabinet. Sorge and Ozaki were executed on 7 November 1944. It is a rare case of execution under the Peace Preservation Law and the National Defence Security Law in wartime Japan.

In depth

Where did the ring begin?

The roots of the Sorge ring lie in Shanghai, not Tokyo. Richard Sorge was sent to Shanghai in 1930 under cover as a correspondent of the German newspaper Frankfurter Zeitung. He made a name as an expert on Chinese agriculture, travelled the country and contacted members of the Chinese Communist Party, and sent Moscow intelligence on the plans of Chiang Kai-shek's Nationalist government for a new offensive against the Communists, obtained largely from the government's German military advisers. He was recalled to Moscow in December 1932.

Hotsumi Ozaki spent his boyhood in Taipei, Taiwan, and in November 1928 was posted to the Shanghai bureau of the Osaka Asahi Shimbun. He frequented the Uchiyama Bookstore, where he came to know Guo Moruo, Lu Xun and Xia Yan of the Chinese League of Left-Wing Writers, and he also had dealings with the Chinese Communist Party. He met the American journalist Agnes Smedley and through her Sorge, and helped Sorge's intelligence work in China. The Japanese Wikipedia writes that the person who actually introduced Ozaki to Sorge was Kitō Gin'ichi, a member of the Communist Party USA then assigned to the Pan-Pacific Trade Union Secretariat in Shanghai.

In Shanghai Ozaki was also linked to the student movement at the Tōa Dōbun Shoin, a Japanese college. In the autumn of 1930 a branch of the Chinese Communist Youth League was formed there, and students joined the "Japan-China Struggle League" led by the Chinese Communist Wang Xuewen and carried anti-war propaganda to the crews of Japanese warships. Kō Nakanishi and others in it were arrested by the consulate-general police at the end of that year. At a meeting of this league in the spring of 1931 Ozaki met Kawai Teikichi and sent him to Manchuria to watch the movements of the Kwantung Army. Ozaki returned to Japan in February 1932.

What did it do in Tokyo?

In May 1933 Soviet military intelligence decided to have Sorge build a network in Japan. Sorge joined the Nazi Party in Germany, obtained newspaper assignments and came to Japan, where he won the confidence of the German embassy. Miyagi Yotoku, a painter from Okinawa and a member of the Communist Party USA, served as go-between. Ozaki met Sorge again in 1934 and joined the ring.

Ozaki made his name as a commentator on China. In 1937 he joined the Shōwa Research Association, the policy study group run by an associate of Fumimaro Konoe; in 1938 he left the Asahi and became an adviser to the first Konoe cabinet; and from June 1939 he worked as a consultant to the research department of the South Manchuria Railway (Mantetsu). He passed to Sorge what he learned in these posts of the Japanese government's intentions. After his arrest Ozaki described the ring's purpose as "defending the Soviet Union, the most important pillar of the world communist revolution, from Japanese imperialism". On 14 September 1941 Sorge reported to Moscow that the possibility of a Japanese attack on the Soviet Union had disappeared. The English Wikipedia writes that this made possible the transfer of Soviet divisions from the Far East, while adding that Sorge was not the only source, since the Soviets had broken the Japanese diplomatic codes.

How was it uncovered?

From the 1930s the Special Higher Police gathered information on Japanese members of the Communist Party USA and kept watch on Miyagi Yotoku and those around him. Arrests began with Kitabayashi Tomo on 27 September 1941, and on 10 October Miyagi was arrested and began to talk. The prosecutors' office of the Supreme Court, mindful of relations with Germany, had Ozaki, who was close to Konoe, arrested first so as to be sure before any foreigner was taken. Ozaki was arrested in mid-October (on the 14th or the 15th, depending on the source), and on 18 October, the day Hideki Tojo became prime minister, Sorge, the radio operator Max Clausen and Branko Vukelić were arrested together. The German ambassador Ott at first protested against an unjust arrest, but heard from Sorge himself that he was a spy.

How were they punished?

Sorge and the others were indicted in 1942 under the National Defence Security Law, the Military Secrets Protection Law, the Military Resources Secrets Protection Law and the Peace Preservation Law. The trial at first instance was held at the Tokyo District Criminal Court from September 1943 to March 1944. Sorge and Ozaki were sentenced to death, Vukelić to life imprisonment and Clausen to life confinement, while Miyagi died in custody before judgment. Kawai Teikichi received ten years, and Saionji Kinkazu, an adviser to the Konoe cabinet, a suspended sentence. The Japanese side several times proposed to the Soviet embassy an exchange of Sorge for Japanese prisoners, but the Soviets answered that they knew no such person. Sorge and Ozaki were executed at Sugamo Prison on 7 November 1944, the anniversary of the Russian Revolution. Vukelić died in prison in January 1945, and Clausen was released that October.

How did it lead to the Chinese network and to later repression?

The investigation spread to China. Kō Nakanishi, a graduate of the Tōa Dōbun Shoin working in the Mantetsu research department, had been in touch with the Chinese Communist Party and supplying information to Mao Zedong and its leadership; in 1942 he was arrested in connection with the Sorge case as a member of a "Chinese Communist spy ring". The prosecution asked for death, but he was sentenced to life imprisonment in September 1945 and released in October. The China Research Office in which Ozaki had worked with Hosokawa Karoku and others was dissolved on Ozaki's arrest, and the following year Hosokawa was arrested over the article that set off the Yokohama Incident.

The Soviet Union rehabilitated Sorge in November 1964 and made him a Hero of the Soviet Union. After the war Willoughby of the American occupation forces published in 1949 a report naming Smedley as Sorge's collaborator, which the US Army withdrew after she protested. The claim that Itō Ritsu of the Japanese Communist Party had been the lead that exposed the ring spread widely on the strength of Kawai Teikichi's testimony but was refuted in 1993, and it has also emerged that Kawai cooperated with occupation intelligence after the war and was paid for it.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. ja.wikipedia.org
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. ja.wikipedia.org
  4. kotobank.jp
  5. ja.wikipedia.org
  6. ja.wikipedia.org
  7. ja.wikipedia.org
  8. ja.wikipedia.org
  9. ja.wikipedia.org
  10. ja.wikipedia.org